Remix.run Logo
▲ tito 3 hours ago

One unintended side effect of the removal of sulfur from shipping fuels is a drastic reduction in cloud cover over the ocean. This is estimated to have doubled global warming in the 2020s (!).

I’m exploring how to cleanly re-create those lost clouds over the ocean. Fuel additives, spraying sea salt into clouds, modifying ship routing. If this is up your alley hit reply.

▲smartmic 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Good intentions, but I would like to see a balanced discussion involving also the risks of geoengineering. It is always delicate if we interfere with a system we have not yet fully understood.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geoengineering

▲andrewvc an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I wish we could afford to be very circumspect about geo engineering. There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.

If reduction alone was an effective strategy we wouldn’t be where we are today.

▲bshepard 2 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Is there really too much warming or is there a power grab by alarmist scientists and enemies of civilization? Perhaps a little of both, but I would not leave out the power story here. There is significant variance in predictions of the GDP impact of global warming because, well, it’s a complex adaptive system…this is not to deny climate change but to suggest a measure of skepticism about the alarmist predictions

▲capitainenemo 15 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There's been a few interesting proposals for solar shade to block like 1.5% or so of the sun's light at the lagrange point. One using a single shield as opposed to a swarm (seems more reliable) would require like 100-200 starships to lift the mass. Probably relatively cheap in terms of geoengineering if starship actually becomes a standard lift vehicle at their targeted costs. Doesn't fix acidification, but is a lot more reversible than many geoengineering plans.

▲modo_mario 5 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.

And yet we're still pumping up fossil fuels and this geoengineering would be used as an excuse to keep doing it. At some point we're going to feel other effects or potentially be trapped expending resources to keep the geoengineering going.

▲spwa4 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Anything we do is geoengineering. So in terms of outcome, choosing the outcome seems like the superior option to just letting things happen.

What you're worried about is people looking for someone to blame ... and finding you. Politics, in other words.

Although I'll agree with politics on one front: any form of geoengineering, including further increasing global warming, will have winners and losers. And global warming is pretty unique in that it essentially only has winners. The earth becomes greener, more fertile, and needs a lot less heat. Fixing it will ... well, it will do the opposite.

▲tito an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Can I offer something here? My sense is you might have a mental model that says the changing climate is a bit like a dimmer switch. A little warmer, things seem better off, let's do it. And I'm receptive to that to a certain extent.

But my mental model is that the stable climate we have is more like a light switch. It's not about a little warmer, it's about we go too far and switch into a chaotic climate unknown in the entirety of human existence. Even with the "big" affects we've seen so far, they're still in the "stable climate zone", haven't flipped the switch yet. Thoughts?

▲unrented7977 an hour ago | parent [-]

We are already in a chaotic climate unknown. Things are already really, really bad and they can't realistically get worse, only bad faster.

Doing nothing is certain doom, so why not do something? We can't fuck the planet any harder than we already have.

▲ifyoubuildit 43 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

This sounds like a pretty dangerous mindset. Its already broken so why worry about breaking it worse?

What do you mean doing nothing is certain doom?

▲alphawhisky 6 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Yeah, I will spend my entire adult life trying to convince people like you to listen to the experts (me, and others who study and work with the environment). You are so wrong it's not even funny. Would you take this same stance of "we can't mess it up any more" in regards to the market? You can pretty obviously see where that is taking us. Personally, I refuse to let you liquidate polar bears at a loss, metaphorically speaking. You need to take a step back and get in touch with OUR vision here. Treat our planet like you're renting, not owning.

▲TFNA 21 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Would you consider millions of people forced from lowlands like in Bangladesh winners? Are the populations of other countries that have to take in refugee swells winners?

▲dimes an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Of course choosing the outcome is better than not choosing the outcome. No one disputes that. The question is, can you accurately choose the outcome without unintended side effects?

▲alphawhisky 11 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Hey Environmental Engineer (P.E.) here. That's a crazy thing to claim. Our energy needs for cooling just surpassed our energy needs for heating. Water chemistry and the water cycle on Earth (the carbonate cycle, wind/ocean currents, rainfall) all rely on our existing delicate balance and temperature. Our goal should never be to launch ourselves into further climate change. We know far too little, and simpletons like you convince everyone else that we don't need more money going into research.

▲hackeman300 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Only winners? What about the extreme heatwaves and stronger hurricanes due to the warmer oceans?

▲darkwater 27 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

> And global warming is pretty unique in that it essentially only has winners. The earth becomes greener, more fertile, and needs a lot less heat.

Wait, what? Are you seriously saying this?

▲tito 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Here here! Would love to hear about what format you would like to see this in. There’s some existing discussion I can point you to but there’s so much more to be discussed about what we do understand, and so much to be explored that we don’t understand. At the same time, warming is accelerating and inaction is having real consequences too.

▲tcptomato 2 hours ago | parent [-]

what is here?

▲tito an hour ago | parent [-]

hah, “Here, here is a common misspelling, caused by the fact that hear and here are homophones—words that sound the same but have different meanings and spellings” TIL

▲throwaway2037 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

China has already be doing it for more than 20 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beijing_Weather_Modification_O...

▲tito an hour ago | parent [-]

Humanity has been doing “it” since the industrial revolution to the tune of a trillion tons of excess carbon dioxide.

▲blach 27 minutes ago | parent [-]

Humanity has been doing “it” since we figured out large scale agriculture and gained the ability to produce widespread land use change.

It just so happens that Beavers are the only other species capable of this kind of land use change.

So I think for this problem it’s us and the beavers…

▲Timshel an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Not sure where your doubling is coming from.

https://attheu.utah.edu/research/cleaner-ship-fuel-changed-c...

Not even clear if there was a change ...

> It turned out that the clouds after the fuel change held more total water overall, which balanced out changes in droplet size and maintained cloud solar reflectivity, known as albedo. Had the albedo of Atlantic clouds reduced, they would have reflected less of the sun’s heat back into space, thereby warming the climate.

▲psp99 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I have a PhD in cloud formation, so hit me up if you want to work together.

▲tito 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Yes happy to email you if you share it, or ping my email in my profile

▲DANmode 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Of course you’ll tell me it’s been studied for some decades and is fine,

but does anyone in this space take interest in public objection to (further, and continuously) altering the atmosphere and its balances/patterns?

Is this discussed? What is the community model on this - is it like fracking, where everybody tells each other there’s no way it’s big enough to make a difference to anything?

▲tito 2 hours ago | parent [-]

First off sorry about the downvotes from people. It’s a great question and sometimes downvotes even lead to the reply button disappearing.

I don’t think this sulfur-in-shipping-fuels-creating-cloud-cover topic has been studied for decades, a lot of the research is new in just the last couple years

Carbon dioxide annual emissions, despite years of discussion around lowering them, continue to rise. With the resulting atmospheric levels reaching levels not seen in human existence. And this shipping fuel change is (surprisingly quickly) revealing some of the impacts of that, that the warming caused by carbon emissions is much higher than previously understood.

▲leoedin 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

My dad's involved in a project to find technical solutions to that. They're researching technologies to increase cloud cover - the core idea is a salt spray to seed clouds. I think the biggest challenge is creating small enough salt crystals with a low enough energy input.

https://oceancooling.org/

▲tito 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Haha small world! Would be great to chat with your dad. I’m doing a fellowship at a philanthropy including building a technoeconomic model for marine cloud brightening. If you’re open to it my email is in my profile.

▲trueno 2 hours ago | parent [-]

damn it you guys do cool stuff, respect

▲tito an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Shoot, re-reading my comment now, it seems clearer for me to say "This is estimated to have doubled the rate of global warming in the 2020s (!).'. I could see someone reading it as saying it doubled global warming entirely, which is not accurate.

▲gosub100 36 minutes ago | parent [-]

So more acidic rain in exchange for less direct sunlight on the ocean? Not sure that's a better tradeoff

▲dr_dshiv 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I love this enormously, hit me up. At TU Delft. To demonstrate my love of clouds, see them in a realtimelapse: https://earthlove.live

▲tito 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Emailed!

▲dr_dshiv 17 minutes ago | parent [-]

Btw (and this is a digression, I warn you)

Cornelis Drebbel (1572-1633) is my favorite Alchemist. Not only did he create the first cybernetic system (a thermostat) and perpetual motion machine (powered by fluctuations of barometric pressure) but also the first functional submarine.

Around 1620, witnesses saw it row under the Thames for hours.

Robert Boyle speculated how they might refresh the air — and of course oxygen is an issue — but carbon dioxide build up is bigger.

I suspect Drebbel used a slurry of lime as ballast to pull out the CO2. (I have a full sized replica of his sub in Amsterdam, but no I haven’t tried it yet.)

Just in case you wanted a historical perspective on carbon sequestration!

▲whazor 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Makes me wonder if you could build autonomous solar/wind powered ships.

For lots of cargo, it doesn't matter if the shipment takes extra couple months.

We used to have a wind powered shipping industry before.

▲pingou 31 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

If it takes 3 times more time, I imagine it costs around 3 times as much, as the ship is only able to move a third of a normal ship cargo in the same amount of time, with the same crew cost and same ship cost (or perhaps even higher cost, although you do save money on fuel).

▲nkoren 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I've got a friend doing exactly that: https://www.ladonrobotics.com/

▲greggsy 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Colombia are innovators in the field of autonomous sea cargo.

▲ an hour ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲DunnoKruegerSfx 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Solar driven ultracsonic evaporators?

▲tito 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Maybe! What’s that?

▲shagie 29 minutes ago | parent [-]

https://research.noaa.gov/injecting-light-reflecting-particl...

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/salt-spray-may-pr... (2013)

> There are many ways to try and climate engineer the planet, but many of them are so far-fetched that scientists aren't sure if they would even be physically possible, let alone physically successful. Sea-salt climate engineering (SSCE) might be the most low-tech, and plausible, possibility.

> In such a situation, specially designed unmanned boats would plow the seas, spraying salt water into the air. The water would evaporate and leave behind sea-salt particles, which may be lifted into the clouds, increasing their albedo, or reflecting power.

> A study released last month in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres used three different models to run the same SSCE scenario in which sea-salt engineering was used in the low-latitude oceans to keep top-of-atmosphere radiative forcing at the 2020 level for 50 years and was then abruptly turned off for 20 years.

(If you want to read the study in full, https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/201... )

https://www.barrierreef.org/news/explainers/what-is-cloud-br...

https://atmos.uw.edu/faculty-and-research/marine-cloud-brigh...

> Atmospheric scientists are still not certain just how much of a cooling effect these aerosol particles have on the climate overall. Scientists estimate that aerosols from human emissions are offsetting 0.5℃ of global warming from greenhouse gases, but they could be cooling as little as 0.2 ℃ or as much as 1.0 ℃ (Forster et al., 2021). The uncertainty in this number leads to uncertainty about how much warming to expect in the coming decades.

> If the effect of aerosols on clouds is large, reducing aerosol pollution might significantly accelerate climate warming in the very near term. One recent paper concluded that there has already been an acceleration in global warming due to the decline in atmospheric aerosols since 2010, and projects that between now and 2040 the rate of warming may double due to this effect (Hansen et al., 2023). Recent steep reductions in particulate pollution emissions from ships that coincided with record ocean surface and global temperatures have increased interest in understanding and quantifying these effects.

▲npongratz an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

So... are you looking to create a real life Terminal Shock?

▲ 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲gambiting 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Ah, the aerosol masking effect[0]

Somewhat counterintuively, if we suddenly somehow reduced our emissions to 0 overnight, the global warming would rapidly accelerate for a few years before declining.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_dimming

▲sandworm101 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

>> I’m exploring how to cleanly re-create those lost clouds over the ocean.

But haven't we recently learned that marine algae are the primary net absorbers of CO2? cutting their sunlight therefore cannot do much good. Better than we cut sunlight over land than water. (Plants absorb CO2 but do not sequester it nearly as much as oceanic algae.)

▲shagie 23 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

http://jmc.stanford.edu/commentary/progress/iron.html is a different (much more controversial) approach to geoengineering.

https://www.whoi.edu/ocean-learning-hub/ocean-topics/climate...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_fertilization

It's based on that the bottleneck for marine algae is nutrients... and so if you dump a few tons of rust in the ocean, you'll fertilize it, start an algae bloom which absorbs CO2 out of the water (allowing it to be replaced by atmospheric CO2)... and then when the algae dies it descends to the ocean floor where its trapped.

▲bluGill 40 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Algae is often not sunlight limited, but other necessary nutrient limited. We know we can create algae blooms but adding iron to the ocean in places where the water is clear. (what we don't know is what the effects of that will be)

▲2OEH8eoCRo0 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Phil Mason has been working on burning sodium that produces very fine particles of harmless baking soda. He thinks if it were retrofitted to already available passenger jets it could make a difference.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ST49jDo4d-Q

▲metalman 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There is no credible follow up research and investigations to the extravagent claims around sulfur DIOXIDE made years ago, just cut and paste till you puke, not to mention the article is about sulfur monoxide, an even more nasty compound.

edit: this data about cruise ships, handily omits the emmisions caused by billionare lifesyle, and rest of the 'liesure industry', and plonks respinsibility on people who are often enjoying a once in a lifetime post retirment adventure that is relentlessly promoted to them everywhere they look.

▲tito 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Just so I understand, you’re saying the extravagant claims were that a) a drastic reduction in cloud cover b) accelerated global warming c) caused by lowering sulfur dioxide emissions in shipping fuels. Is it all a/b/c of those claims have no credible follow up research or some subset?

▲metalman 2 hours ago | parent [-]

you catch on quick, so yes the aerosol forming particles and the proprted results are unsubstantiated, and are promoted and exagerated relentlessly, with NO DATA.

▲tito 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I’m not clear where you’re saying is unsubstantiated. Is it that particles don’t form aerosols, so then the rest of what follows is unsubstantiated? I don’t think that’s what you’re saying but let me know. I linked some papers in a comment elsewhere in this thread, happy to hear comments about those articles in case you’ve read them.

▲metalman 2 hours ago | parent [-]

wiki on topic, the bottom line is that SO² is marginal, and will be zero'ed out with methane, and is a non issue, but more to the point SO² emmisions are mostly land based in the first place, AND we are supposed to be talking about SO, so

Regardless of the current strength of aerosol cooling, all future climate change scenarios project decreases in particulates and this includes the scenarios where 1.5 °C (2.7 °F) and 2 °C (3.6 °F) targets are met: their specific emission reduction targets assume the need to make up for lower dimming.[85] Since models estimate that the cooling caused by sulfates is largely equivalent to the warming caused by atmospheric methane (and since methane is a relatively short-lived greenhouse gas), it is believed that simultaneous reductions in both would effectively cancel each other out.[86] [87] Yet, in the recent years, methane concentrations had been increasing at rates exceeding their previous period of peak growth in the 1980s,[88][89] with wetland methane emissions driving much of the recent growth,[90][91] while air pollution is getting cleaned up aggressively.[92] These trends are some of the main reasons why 1.5 °C (2.7 °F) warming is now expected around 2030, as opposed to the mid-2010s estimates where it would not occur until 2040.[83]

the rest

https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Search&se...

▲tito 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Hi, the link is to Wikipedia results containing “sulphur dioxide”, not sure if there’s a specific page you meant to link.

Agree the OP article is about SO, thanks for playing along.

I didn’t understand SO2 being zeroed out by methane. Like one warms, one cools, they cancel eachother out? In this case humanity is removing SO2 (net = warmer) and adding methane (net = warmer) so if seems they both make things worse.

▲3lambda an hour ago | parent [-]

I respect you a lot for engaging!

▲HelloMcFly an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

[flagged]

▲TeMPOraL 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

No data, or just not enough sociopolitical commentary on your pet favorite topic, "billionaire lifestyle"?

▲cheeze 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Dummy here: Why are clouds over the ocean important?

It seems like those clouds _shouldn't_ exist if they are caused by sulfur being pumped into the atmosphere? Why do we want them back?

▲Tarq0n 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

That's the naturalistic fallacy. They served a useful purpose (keeping sunlight out) even if they were artificial.

▲modo_mario 3 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

If they kept sunlight out wouldn't that prevent evaporation which would in turn contribute to cloud cover?

▲DANmode 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

At what cost?

Sunlight does stuff besides create heat.

Are you aware of fungal infections and deaths spiking recently?

▲subscribed 18 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Fungal infections of the plankton and mass deaths of the prawn?

We're talking, strictly, about loss of the cloud cover over the oceans. Put that strawman away.

▲TeMPOraL 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> At what cost?

At the cost of whatever it is the sulfur in shipping fuel did that got it banned.

▲layer8 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The fact that they shouldn’t exist doesn’t contradict that they purportedly slowed global warming.

▲tito 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Great question, the comments already here give a good indication. One thing I want to get better at is explaining this in a way that answers your question because there’s something really counterintuitive about all this!

Happy for any followup questions.

Here’s an article from MIT explaining more: https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/how-much-global-warming-has-...

▲pepperoni_pizza 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes, but we also _shouldn't_ have > 400 ppm of CO2 in atmosphere. Counteracting that is good.

▲kachnuv_ocasek 3 hours ago | parent [-]

It's not counteracting, though. It's only masking and delaying the effects.

▲shagie 18 minutes ago | parent [-]

It's changing the slope of the change to one closer to what was observed a century ago before things like the Clean Air Act addressed other issues with atmospheric pollutants and unmasked the real rate of change from global warming.

It would give us more time to address the issues before things go catastrophically wrong with the climate that we have.

If the argument is "we're not going to do anything anyways, might as well take our lumps with the new climate" then geo-engineering is a waste of time.

If the argument is "we need a bit more time to address the social and political issues that decarbonization brings about and get some sanity in the larger industrialized nations", then geo-engineering helps provide that time.

▲modo_mario a minute ago | parent [-]

>It would give us more time to address the issues before things go catastrophically wrong with the climate that we have.

I'd predict that it would be used as an excuse to keep pumping fossil fuels for longer to increase that ppm since the urgency is dimished.

▲weird-eye-issue 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Arsenic is naturally occurring, why shouldn't you eat it with each meal?

▲Hikikomori 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Clouds can reflect sunlight.

▲TacticalCoder 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> This is estimated to have doubled global warming in the 2020s (!).

I'd like explanations and excuses from all those who want to pack us in cities, in high-rises, like ants, and who keep attacking individuals' rights to move freely using cars.

▲sdoering 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> I'd like explanations and excuses from all those who want to pack us in cities

I'd like to know who you are talking about? I have never heard of bands of eco activists rounding people up and herding them into cities and high rises like cattle.

> who keep attacking individuals' rights to move freely using cars

Absolutely. Those street gangs of eco activists stopping us at gun point and forcing us out of our cars are really becoming a nuissance.

/s

▲TeMPOraL 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> Absolutely. Those street gangs of eco activists stopping us at gun point and forcing us out of our cars are really becoming a nuissance.

Like never before, we need the street fighting mathematicians and other scientists to engage these roving hordes.

▲tito an hour ago | parent [-]

Taking to the streets: https://xkcd.com/356/