Remix.run Logo
▲ FinnLobsien 3 hours ago

AI and LLMs, in my opinion, are effectively the industrialization of knowledge work.

Like it or not, industrialization brought many benefits and we couldn't imagine our modern way of living without it (just think about medicines). Industrial production made so many things so much more accessible for so many people.

But an industrialist perspective doesn't care about the process of making stuff, only about the outcome. The shoemakers deep knowledge of leathers, his intuition of all sorts of different shoes, and the pride of that competence—that doesn't matter when you can make thousands of shoes a day that cost 0.5% of something artisanal. The people working at the shoe factory only carry things to and fro and occasionally fix some machine issue.

This has tons of benefits and tons of downsides. But with physical goods, a shoe is a shoe.

With knowledge work like writing, the process is often the entire point. The point of writing a paper is what you learned in the process. The point of documented software architecture is to develop an understanding deep enough to drive coherent downstream decisions. If those things are no longer true, the asset it stands for is basically worthless.

▲pegasus 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

If the point of writing a given paper is learning about a subject, then it's not knowledge work, it's studying. Just like an apprentice shoe maker is making shoes mainly to learn, not to produce footwear. Acquiring more of a skill while working is incidental both when shoe making and when writing documentation. Documentation which will help others understand the system. In both cases, the main point is the finished product. I really don't see the distinction you're drawing.

▲kitku 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

We're inclined to think of them as separate, but shoemaking also requires some knowledge work. Industrialization detracts from the value of process in physical manufacturing as well, though to a lesser extent.

▲FinnLobsien 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Yes, I totally agree. But yeah, with physical products, there's always a utilitarian function of "does it accomplish its physical purpose", e.g. keep feet warm and protected.

To what degree, for how long, under what circumstances, and with what externalities that is accomplished is a separate discussion.

But in knowledge work, the output's purpose is often merely to represent a cognitive process, in which case sidestepping the process negates the output's value.

Think of an architecture document. The entire point is to obviate downstream questions and discussions because the thinking process has already been done and agreed upon from multiple sides. If we AI-generate an architecture document, the humans evaluating downstream work output may still end up arguing because the cognitive process the document represents never happened, in which case the document was pointless from the start.

▲rocqua 20 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

I'd wager the thought that industrialization, after the steam-engine, was largely about reducing the amount of knowledge and training needed to for production of certain goods. Which pushed skilled labor into the areas not yet industrialized. Which was largely knowledge work.

▲zahlman an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's actually quite interesting here, now that I think of it, that we've been calling it "knowledge work" the whole time, rather than "thought work".

▲skydhash 26 minutes ago | parent [-]

Knowledge is mass, thinking is force. Needs are what makes us applies that thinking to the present form of knowledge to create new knowledge, and thus output.

▲rixed 11 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's also how I picture things; except that LLMs are not the whole industrialization process, just the latest and most visible step (former steps include standardization of low quality in various ways - yes, the beloved "industry standards" are quite often horrendous from a purely technical standpoint).

One of the consequences that industrialization has had in the past regarding the production of physical goods, is that quantity and affordability has often been (but not always) detrimental to quality of the goods and loss of knwoledge for the people (so many crafts that have disapeared, which makes society less robust as a result). Also, a loss of social connection and peer-to-peer relatedness, as we find ourselves increasingly dependent on large scale processes that we can't even see, or feel not taking part of, instead of more local relationships.

The same thing happening to "intellectual" work is not really appealing: more slop and less education, is that where we are heading to?

▲ 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲hirako2000 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

industrialized medicine requires trained consultants, and researchers who understand the underlying science and can still think.

The nuance is, industrialized material production.

▲FinnLobsien 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, my point is not that industrial production requires no knowledge. Modern factories are extremely sophisticated and embody incredible amounts of specialized knowledge.

My more detailed point is more "each medicine no longer requires a local pharmacist to mix a bunch of things together."

The person operating the Ibuprofen-producing robot doesn't need to know anything about the chemical composition of Ibuprofen, or knowledge of the medicine and its side effects, much less knowledge about a broad set of medicines.

▲hirako2000 27 minutes ago | parent [-]

I think I understand, but do you understand that design knowledge for material production at scale isn't comparable to that of knowledge production in general?

Consultancy isn't for scale. That's why big 4 have thousands of people.

Edit: to clarify, material production doesn't require knowledge, it's pure mechanical reproduction. Design production doesn't need reproduction, we have human ingenuity for that already.

▲delis-thumbs-7e 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> The people working at the shoe factory only carry things to and fro and occasionally fix some machine issue.

Were this to be true, there would be no workers at all, it had all been automated decades ago. Still there’s around million shoe workers in Vietnam around, I think. Adidas tried automating shoe production at it failed miserably[1]. Seems nothing beats us pesky monkeys in hand-eye-coordination for quite some time. I think the problem was also that recalibrating the system to create different type of a sneaker was extremely hard and expensive, whereas doing same to a bunch of Vietnamese workers requires you to just, y’know, tell them.

People who never done any manual labour with their hands always think a job ω is quite simple to automatise away. And if you try it, whaddayaknow, it fails miserably. How many years now the fully automatised driving has been supposed to completely take over long-haul trucking just next year?

Coming back to your main point, with which I agree with, having an LLM doing your reading or writing for you is kinda pointless. It is like paying somebody to watch them to eat your dinner. In the end of that process is starvation. But equally we have been afraid of industrial automation taking completely over for at least hundred years, and we find that automating a making of a single sneaker is bloody expensive and bloody difficult.

That leads me to believe this automatisation of knowledge will not look quite like the C-suite prophecises and we monkeys will be needed for long time being, even in SW development.

[1] https://techcrunch.com/2019/11/11/adidas-backpedals-on-robot...

▲sedictious 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Like it or not, industrialization brought many benefits and we couldn't imagine our modern way of living without it (just think about medicines). Industrial production made so many things so much more accessible for so many people.

I largely agree with your point but I see a lot of people lumping everything together.

Do we need 50 different shoes produced by borderline-slave conditions in SEA to have plumbing? Do we need to pollute be getting a car to drive to the gym to have ambulances rushing people in to the latest medical facilities?

A lot of what we are seeing is simply capitalism running rampant without much of a care with regards to actual humanity. There was no preconditions we needed to eliminate shoemakers to have a safer, more functional society. I would even argue that it's a mistake that we are paying for in human livelihoods, reduced production and over-reliance on foreign countries in the West and climate change.

Also "a shoe is a shoe" is unnecessarily reductive. Even assuming the quality stays the same (it does not and has no incentive to) and leaving all semantic arguments aside, with shoemakers you have decentralised production that boosts local economies. You have a community that can provide both (mostly locally sourced) material and ultimately knowledge. Up to a couple of decades ago, people used to go to the local shoemaker to fix their shoes, making the whole chain more sustainable. And of course you have none of the scale of the climate impact, the oversupply of cheaper goods and centralisation of production to a few major countries who have control both over the workforce and consumer.

And none of this is antithetical to technological progress. You can have shoemakers that have new tools and new techniques to aid them, without the need to build shoe factories pumping out Nikes 24/7

▲wellakshually 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> And none of this is antithetical to technological progress. You can have shoemakers that have new tools and new techniques to aid them, without the need to build shoe factories pumping out Nikes 24/7

I don't see how the tech coming from "factories" will end up in shoemakers' hands without said factories? The scale is driving the progress?

▲sedictious 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

You have not seen a home workshop? Or sewing machines? Automatic looms? Knitting machines?

All of these can be used at an individual case (and have been, textile manufacturers have been using looms for quite a while). I own all of this and I am able to create clothes for almost the entirety of my friends and family even as a hobby on my free time, it really does not take ages to create something by hand wpoith the aid of technology.

The difference is that all of this still gives the full control to the craftsman. I can decide to do difficult colourwork by hand, or hand-sew a specific part of the garment while it allows you to automate the repetitive parts. Factory work does not let you choose what is repetitive, _you_ are the repetitive and expendable part of the process.

Also if you assume that said equipment must come from huge factories this is also wrong. It requires a lot of expertise to create something like a sewing machine but the point is that you can achieve this without massive production lines. We've had quality products in Europe for a while - and you can tell the difference if you get your hands on a vintage Bernina. Looms are still being worked by hand in some cases. For a lot of consumer electornics, hand-soldering is very achievable and local smaller-scale parts can easily do metal and woodwork -- but those are dying out in an alarming rate

I am not against automation of all kind, I explicitly am against this scheme of infinite scale to get ever cheaper goods. We can instead strive to strike a balance between a sea of cheap goods and local, resilient and self-sufficient communities that don't aim to enshittify their whole production line and environment to get a slightly better margin

▲moron4hire 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Have you seen the inside of a shoe "factory?" It's not like the Hershey Park Chocolate Factory ride were everything is depicted as going through a completely automated, warehouse-sized robot. They are mostly just massive horizontal scale outs of traditional hand making techniques, but with cheaper materials and more glue than stitching.

▲api an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

The critique of capitalism would hit harder if it had competition. Ironically.

I look around the world. I see societies that are wealthy or developing where capitalism is running rampant. It sometimes calls itself other things (Chinese “communism”) or is organized in different ways but it’s capitalism running rampant.

Then I see poverty.

Then I see totalitarian managed economies of various kinds (theocracy, real communism) that are sometimes marginally better than poverty but basically poverty with guard rails.

Where is the successful alternatives?

I suppose you could reach for Northern Europe. But it’s basically capitalism running slightly less rampant with more safety net. Maybe that’s the pragmatic answer. But it’s not a different system, just a differently tuned instance of the same system.

▲sedictious 43 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

The existence to hyper-capitalism is not anti-capitalism and I never argued for a complete overhaul of the system, I think you are attacking an argument that is slightly different than mine.

In a lot of European countries we hit a sweet spot around the 60s to 80s (depends on how much plagued by poverty each country was after the war). Things were not prefect but there was a strong social net and strong unions (which have existed for far longer) that prioritised local production. Of course there is much more nuance than that and I can't condense the reality of halt the continent in a single paragraph, but it is very different to what we are experiencing now and it's still a "capitalist" society at its core. There is even a stark difference compared to two decades ago, where the process of globalisation and concentration of power to a vanishingly small minority was already evident

What you are seeing today is an echo of the past because we have reduced local production and are paying the price for this so you end up with a welfare state which is fueled by a service economy, which is almost self-evident why it is bad and a matter of time until the system collapses.

▲throaway1985asd an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Capitalism "works" because it allows economic production to remain in the hands of whoever created the venture. But when production starts to get centralized, and more and more production gets in the hands of fewer people, that ability to "work" gets lost.

▲api an hour ago | parent [-]

Good simple take, and this happens within capitalism itself when huge monopolies take over a market.

▲scotty79 22 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> But an industrialist perspective doesn't care about the process of making stuff, only about the outcome.

It sounds nice, but in actuality the process of making stuff in the most optimal way possible is the pure essence of any industry.

At the artisanal budget, industrial version will have orders of magnitude better tolerances because the processes are perfected.

When you do things artisanally your ability to perfect the process is very limited. Only going industrial affords you the scale to perfect the processes.

▲motionlessveloc 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Well, no, the point of writing a paper (or a Hacker News comment) is to share what you learned in the process with other people.

It only truly becomes slop if nobody reads it and learns something.

▲FinnLobsien 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> Well, no, the point of writing a paper (or a Hacker News comment) is to share what you learned in the process with other people.

It's more complicated in practice because:

a) Communicating something well is an important skill and of itself.

b) The writing process often continues to sharpen our thoughts, even after the research is already done. Writing is rarely a mechanical task of putting what's on your mind onto paper.

c) I'm not only talking about using AI to write the final paper. Anyone writing the paper with AI can be presumed to have used it heavily in the other parts as well.

▲keybored 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> Like it or not, industrialization brought many benefits and we couldn't imagine our modern way of living without it (just think about medicines). Industrial production made so many things so much more accessible for so many people.

It is extremely easy to sit in the First World and like the fruits that the Industrial Revolution brought now, some centuries later. Workers that were brought into factories had to work long days. Now we have the 40-hour workweek, and a two-day weekend. Now we have a “middle class”, i.e. wage workers with disposable income and a mortgage. We exploit the rest of the world for cheap goods. We exploit our immigrants for cheap labor.

Climate change is becoming a bit on the nose, but we don’t have to worry about the worst effects.[1]

In short, it is extremely easy to compress modernity to the headline: Progress Happened. But in the real, uncompacted world there was strife, struggle, malcontent, protestations, probably every shade of opinion and reaction. And with all that we didn’t arrive at a polished gem. We got a rich First World, for the most part (right up to the rise of China).

To bring up that compressed view of the Industrial Revolution in order to stifle discussion (let’s be real) makes no sense. We are living in it now. Of course we are struggling and debating with it now. Just like all the other historic, uncompressed events

- - -

To also compress the dimension to “progress” and “not progress” is a falsehood. People want progress that works for them. Not progress that oppresses them.

[1] https://ruralindiaonline.org/article/mosquitoes-are-ladakh-s...