Remix.run Logo
▲ jonathanlydall 5 hours ago

I was recently thinking of the depiction of AI in Star Trek. Specifically TNG, DS9 and VOY, and specifically their "Computer, ..." prompts, not the more advanced kinds like for Data or holograms (including the EMH).

I recall thinking at the time I first watched them that it was a bit weird that the computer seemed capable of answering general questions and doing things like data analysis, but that seemed to be all it was ever used to do.

And I think this is exactly the kind of AI we now have today, you can ask it a general question which it can somewhat mostly answer correctly, but requires human guidance to be applied effectively at real world problems.

▲francisofascii 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Yep. There are several scenes in TNG where a crew member, Geordi comes to mind, is collaborating with the computer, having a back and forth brainstorming conversation, solving a problem. Very much like using an LLM today.

▲neom 16 minutes ago | parent [-]

https://youtu.be/kLBYFWgpvos?t=56 0:56 - "Yesterday's Enterprise" is that the episode you're thinking of by chance?

▲FinnKuhn 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I always imagined AI as what you saw in futuristic movies. There it was generally text or language based. We generally have that now.

What we don't really have is physical AI, e.g. autonomous robots, human looking robots, self-driving cars, etc. I think this is what is next.

▲XenophileJKO 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Why do people keep saying self driving cars? I'm surrounded by them every day.. like I see probably 10-20 on the way to work.

▲FinnKuhn 35 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Some of the other examples I gave for physical AI also exist already, but in general none of them are ubiquitous around the world yet the same way language-based AI is today.

However, this isn't a binary scenario anyway and the limited availability today is exactly why I think that this is the next thing. Similar to the first version of ChatGPT that was also quite limited in what it could do and not widely used yet.

▲slfnflctd 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Probably because the rollout was far slower and more expensive than many were led to expect it would be, is still not profitable, and still requires new custom software changes for every additional city it operates in rather than being able to just drive anywhere.

▲LtWorf 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

How often does a remote human driver need to take over?

▲05 an hour ago | parent [-]

Never? Remote assistance only hints the car at what it could/should do, no direct remote driving involved (it's unsafe if e.g. connection drops in the middle of planned maneuver). At least that's what Waymo does, Baidu's Apollo Go is seemingly using direct teleoperation over 5g.

▲treespace8 39 minutes ago | parent [-]

But something is limiting scale. Once software works, it just works and scales fast. (Smart phone is a great example)

Self Driving has been working since 2009? But is still extremely limited in scale. Given the amount of money to be made, and time saved by eliminating the need for human drivers, What is the hold up?

▲user43928 2 minutes ago | parent [-]

From what I heard on a review of Tesla's FSD, the version before this year made for an adventurous experience in challenging urban environments.

It has only now become somewhat reliable. They still don't have the same new version as the Robotaxi service. This version should roll out to consumers later this year or in Q1.

Then the next generation of the onboard AI hardware is expected Mid-2027.

I have no idea about the timeline for an unsupervised, globally working self-driving feature.

My uneducated guess would be that perhaps the next major version of the model, on the new hardware, could be reliable enough.

▲ 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲aeonik 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I had the same thought.

When when I got my CS degree, I revisited this thought, and reinforced it.

I thought, this is not how AI and Statistics work. We would need to have an ensemble of thousands of specialized models to run a ship.

▲threethirtytwo 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The ai we have today is even stranger than the star trek computer.

On one hand it is far superior to humans. On the other hand it needs our guidance. Both of these are true at the same time.

▲teamonkey an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

The weird thing is that the Enterprise’s computer is a writing device to serve the story, and so its abilities from episode to episode vary wildly. This somehow makes its behaviour seem more consistent with modern LLMs.

The most unrealistic thing about it is that it would often openly reply “unknown” and then stop talking.