Remix.run Logo
▲ meekoAMH 5 hours ago

I agree and disagree... i think in our zeitgeist we're catastrophising a little too..

it's just a tool, like a knife... useful to chop up your vegetables and eat your dinner, or to cause harm... it's not inherently negative... and blaming the tool rather than the actor as the dangerous one is probably the bigger issue here.

On using AI to replace thinking i agree, is a slippery slope and we will continue to see and be hurt by this going forward, and we need to try to contain the impact of this, but by the same token since i started using AI to develop, I've genuinely become a better developer. I can iterate and learn faster, I'm being forced to process analyze, understand things at a greater scale and more steps ahead, and able to better create systems that i believe will genuinely improve health outcomes for the general public.

So if it were me I'd probably change that final line in your blog to: "Please read and understand it, before you ask AI to do it for you"

Great post, do definitely keep writing!

▲herrherrmann 5 hours ago | parent [-]

However, to make a knife you don't need to destroy forests, poison rivers (and animals and people), emit poisonous gases into the atmosphere, waste taxpayer's money, steal creative works, create billionaires, and do other horrible things on a huge scale. It's not like a new framework or editor extension that you can either use or not. By choosing to use AI, you agree to all of these terrible consequences, and contribute to their further growth. That's why some people are very justifiably appalled by AI.

▲leoedin 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> emit poisonous gases into the atmosphere

I don't think it's possible to make steel without burning coke. So actually you do need to emit poisonous gases into the atmosphere.

The others are broadly not unique to AI. It isn't AI that creates billionaires, it's the capitalist system and winner-takes-all nature of software. It isn't AI that destroys forests and poisons rivers, it's poorly regulated construction. We've been doing that to build power stations and factories and houses for a long time.

> steal creative works

AI definitely does that. I think that's the only true consequence of AI specifically, as opposed to just a product of technology driven capitalism.

▲hoppyhoppy2 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

>Knives cause more disabling injuries than any other type of hand tool. [...] An estimated 8,250,914 (95% confidence interval [CI] 7,149,074–9,352,755) knife-related injuries were treated in US EDs from 1990 to 2008, averaging 434,259 (95% CI 427,198–441,322) injuries annually, or 1190 per day.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S073646791...