Remix.run Logo
▲ komali2 5 hours ago

> It's soul crushing, and I don't want to outsource so much of my thinking to it.

Been thinking about this a lot lately. For the last maybe 200,000 years, humans, as social and curious creatures, have seemed to develop our satisfaction cycles around exploring, creating, and doing useful labor that is helpful to other people, or at least recognizable to other people as interesting and hard.

This is basically how most humans have spent most of their time, throughout every economic system experimented with in the last 200,000 years. Whether dictated by the State, the Corporate Machine, or just the raw physical requirements to get calories and maintain shelter, we've been filling our time with labor, and attaching meaning to it (artificial or otherwise).

I think about "Man's Search for Meaning," and how Frankl rationalized his way to find meaning in being subjected to the worse things humans have ever done (the book was partially inspired by his surviving a nazi concentration camp). If the meaning isn't inherent to something - such as our labor - we'll create it, and rationalize it. Thus we've been able to derive at least some level of the same satisfaction from carrying a deer we killed into a village as we have when pressing the widget making button in the widget making factory. The alienation has been increasing, of course, but we work around it.

I think AI era presents us with maximum alienation. There really is no point to human participation in this labor (or soon there won't be). What's the point of doing a thing when a machine can do it better than you? Our last sliver of rationalization has been taken away from us, but our economic system hasn't caught up with that fact, so not only do we need to deal with the maximum alienation, we also need to deal with the existential dread of not being able to justify our labor in the "your labor has to have commercial value in order to eat" economic system.

I understand that optimists are saying that AI is just the new automated loom, that there'll be some job losses at first but there'll be new jobs created by the new technology and the opportunities it opens, but there's also people saying that the AI are only going to get smarter, and as they get smarter, I can't reconcile this idea that they'll somehow create new jobs for us, rather than eliminate more and more. Ironically enough, the unsolved frontier is moving into blue collar jobs, because we can't make plumbing robots yet - but there certainly are not enough plumbing jobs to go around once every white collar job is automated.

So, what do we do with ourselves then?

▲toyg 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I think you underestimate the shift from industry to services, which don't necessarily produce anything tangible. To simplify: what people often call "bullshit jobs" will be fundamentally unaffected by AI, because their objective was never to make anything but to buzz around talking to this or that, fostering someone's agenda. Somewhat ironically, the shift to AI will reinstate the power of naturally social people, which had eroded quite dramatically with the rise of technology in everyday life. The winners will be people who can bend to their will what AI cannot touch: other people's desires and motivations.

▲leoedin 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> I think you underestimate the shift from industry to services, which don't necessarily produce anything tangible. To simplify: what people often call "bullshit jobs" will be fundamentally unaffected by AI, because their objective was never to make anything but to buzz around talking to this or that, fostering someone's agenda. Somewhat ironically, the shift to AI will reinstate the power of naturally social people, which had eroded quite dramatically with the rise of technology in everyday life. The winners will be people who can bend to their will what AI cannot touch: other people's desires and motivations.

I completely agree. You see the same effect in every large organisation - people want to hire more reports because it increases their social status. If AI makes companies more profitable, the people in those companies will still be using those profits to build fiefdoms and trying to show how important they are.

▲kombookcha 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

>AI is just the new automated loom, that there'll be some job losses at first but there'll be new jobs created by the new technology and the opportunities it opens

I hear people say this too and each time I think 'but it took literally hundreds of years and in the meantime involved a precipitous drop in living standards and the value of the labor of generations of human beings who lived and died in squalid, unsafe factories'. The opportunities were for the owner class, not the skilled workers who were summarily demoted into a permanent underclass of disposable cogs serving the machines. Those people were completely right to be upset, because it had life-ruining consequences for multiple generations of their family.

Anyway I agree with your "maximal alienation" take.