Remix.run Logo
▲ pembrook 2 days ago

So by your definition the only elites are Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk? You’re also closer in wealth to Nancy Pelosi than them.

Under what historical precedent did we draw the line of “elites” at only the 3 richest dudes?

Sorry, we’re going to have to take your stuff too. There’s not enough Elon Musks to pay for what you want.

▲LtWorf 2 days ago | parent [-]

> Sorry, we’re going to have to take your stuff too. There’s not enough Elon Musks to pay for what you want.

I'm already taxed. I just want them to be taxed as much as I am, not way less :)

I don't hate taxes, society or mankind (unlike some people on this site).

▲pembrook a day ago | parent [-]

They are? Everyone is subject to the same tax rates.

But I get it, you dislike that building companies means you make capital gains vs. income (what you get taking zero financial risk and working an adult daycare corporate job). And you don't want to try to create/market/sell something new that society finds valuable to make capital gains yourself, you just want other people to take those risks and pay for you to live comfortably instead.

The problem: the 400 richest Americans pay about $40B in tax per year collectively (federal only, not including state). So how much should they pay instead? Double? Triple? 10X?

Even if they paid 10X as much (they can't without liquidating their companies) it wouldn't solve the yearly deficit on the current government programs we have (we run a $2T yearly deficit).

Sorry, we're going to have to take a lot more of your stuff too.

▲LtWorf a day ago | parent [-]

> And you don't want to try to create/market/sell something new that society finds valuable

None of these people did anything that society finds valuable. In fact they get rich by doing stuff decent people (clearly not you) would be appalled at doing.

> Sorry, we're going to have to take a lot more of your stuff too.

I don't understand your logic. They cannot liquidate… so why can I? You just said "Everyone is subject to the same tax rates." but now I have to liquidate but rich people don't? You're all over the place.

▲pembrook 12 hours ago | parent [-]

I am not all over the place, my entire line of argument is logically coherent.

Your position, being one rooted in the 'memetic vibes,' is not. Hence why, under scrutiny, your only rebuttal is mischaracterization and obfuscation.

> None of these people did anything that society finds valuable

Unlike the government, private companies generally don't hold a gun to people's heads and force them to purchase their services. They have the largest body of evidence that people find their services comparatively valuable of any entities on earth.

> They cannot liquidate… so why can I?

You have literally just proven my point: if you want more free stuff (or to even support the free stuff we give right now at 2T deficit!), everyone will have to pay for it due to the numerical reality (there aren't enough billionaires). Yet, you don't want to pay for it. This is the entire clownish political stance of the US in a nutshell.

At least leftists in Europe understand that their system requires middle class people to pay 50-60% taxes between income and VAT. And even their system is underfunded, overextended, and in slow collapse.

▲LtWorf 10 hours ago | parent [-]

> I am not all over the place, my entire line of argument is logically coherent.

I have just shown you that it isn't. Claiming something doesn't make it true. You'd know that if you weren't all over the place.

> Hence why, under scrutiny, your only rebuttal is mischaracterization and obfuscation.

I will cherish the moment when someone who can do such scrutiny and hold a rational conversation will reply to me. Until then, I won't bother continuing this because this ain't it.