Remix.run Logo
▲ hypfer 6 hours ago

What workflow requires a report with a fixed length on an arbitrary topic?

The idea of writing documents of course makes a lot of sense, and it is also true that they probably should end up somewhere along the length of 10 pages, if the topics are all somewhat equally shaped and sliced.

But "do a report and make it 10 pages" without context to me sounds exactly like the kind of bureaucratic assignment that of course gets offloaded to LLMs. Any sort of bureaucracy where the purpose isn't apparent, is indirect, or might not make sense, will be automated by LLMs, because no one (rightfully!) wants to do that.

So it might be a process and management failure when people do not see why the task is actually necessary. And, if the majority of the reports handed in is written by AI, maybe it isn't?

___

I guess the takeaway here should be that the heuristics previously used as performance optimizations are broken, and it is now time to update them. Which is probably not easy, but just because alternatives are hard to find doesn't mean that the status quo has not been bullshit.

▲petterroea 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

These kinds of requirements are usually used in academia to force you to go enough into detail, etc. Useful when you are dealing with people who don't want to do the task or are bad at writing, although a bit arbitrary. Maybe a necessary evil for some, but with increased maturity you'd expect to not have to ask for a minimum.

Not everyone understands that writing is one of the skills they are being taught

▲hypfer 6 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, of course. This is clear to every reader.

But it's trying to doctor with symptoms instead of focusing on the root cause that is lack of intrinsic motivation.

Why are people in academia that don't really want to be there?

I believe that any human has intrinsic motivation. Why are we not seeing it?

I want to see that answered and fixed instead of people just cursing at the inevitable war of workarounds

____

Even a stressed student juggling multiple jobs to stay afloat will care about something. And that care will drive them.

Why are we not harnessing that care and intrinsic drive?

Why are we instead throwing them something that vaguely resembles a vector pointing at a desirable outcome if some preconditions are true and then get angry when that obviously doesn't work for all.

▲vouwfietsman 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This is an optimistic take of academia and its students, which I applaud you for.

I am afraid though that many people in academia are unmotivated for at least part of the curriculum. I know I was.

The cause of this is I'm sure multi-faceted, but consider as a start that the curriculum itself is already 'a vague vector pointing at desirable outcomes'. Those outcomes being constructively contributing to society.

I had no eagerness in jumping through arbitrary hoops laid out for me to obtain a gatekept ticket to a successful life. In hindsight I can confidently say many of those hoops were hoops, only.

▲petterroea an hour ago | parent [-]

Yeah, I am happy I have a degree, but I am pretty sure 50% of the time spent was useless.

▲toyg 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

For the same reason we have schools and classes and not private tutors for everyone: because economies of scale tend to work well enough to achieve acceptable results (in the case of academia: producing some scientific advancement and certifying one's ability to carry out skilled jobs). So we build systems that are imperfect but scale relatively well.

Yes, each human is an individual snowflake who would "work" so much better if the world revolved around their each and every wishes. But historically, that's just not been materially possible. Will AI change that? I doubt it: we will continue to have education systems, which will continue to have a number of disaffected participants.

▲azornathogron 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The author is at school/university. Report writing with a fixed length and somewhat arbitrary topic is a completely normal task to give to students, because the point is for them to get practice writing reports.

▲hypfer 6 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, but it's also complete bullshit. That is exactly my point.

Not the idea of course. The idea of repetition and forced engagement is indeed how learning happens, and you gotta facilitate that somehow.

But that somehow has so far been mostly terrible, because most people kinda suck at didactics and sparking genuine intrinsic motivation to understand something.

So instead you get the crushing force of bureaucracy, which, of course, gets side-stepped, the moment that becomes viable.

___

Of course this is only in part on the people teaching, and a huge chunk of it is also the system forcing people into academics, who actually would be better off literally anywhere else.

Academics came up with blunt defenses against that, and the other side now adapted too.

The root cause however is to be found elsewhere.