Remix.run Logo
▲ ezst 40 minutes ago

I doubt so, because not being compatible with the git repo format (and therefore requiring distinct hosting, therefore socially excluding from GitHub) is what slowly drove mercurial into obscurity, even though its UX was (and still is) superior to that of git (and JJ, which drew from it), not to mention the other aspects which made hg a much sounder choice on technical merits (e.g. very large monorepos), the users and decision makers both couldn't stand breaking away from the git repo format.

▲danpalmer 25 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I agree that this was a factor in Mercurial dying, but I'm not sure this holds today. Mercurial performed significantly worse than git, that was a factor at the time, but in 2026 the perception is that git doesn't perform well enough (see GitHub outages, GitLab writing on this topic, Anthropic developing their own VCS, etc). Even small teams I know (circa 10 committers) are finding Git to not scale to the speed they're working at now.

JJ has the potential to be a substantial step forward in performance. This will depend on the backend to fully realise it, but a backend that prioritises scalability could vastly outperform git and GitHub's storage.

I think in the post-Microsoft acquisition, post-Dear GitHub letter era, GitHub's shine has worn off. I see a lot more use of GitLab for open source, a lot more use of various other forges. I don't think it's a requirement for a thriving open source project in the way it was for ~2010-2020.

▲nvme0n1p1 35 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Compatibility helps with adoption, but it isn't absolutely required. Git wasn't compatible with the CVS repo format, but still became popular.

▲ezst 19 minutes ago | parent [-]

Sure, but that was before the GitHub monopoly, the social/gamification of it, before the monoculture that ensued, and at a time when it was normal to cruise through the day using 2/3 distinct VCSes (being a FOSS contributor before 2010, you probably would use svn/git/hg/bzr on a daily basis and not need to RTFM for most routine commands like branching, checking in, merging and sharing a diff/series in one form or another).