Remix.run Logo
▲ bigbaguette 10 hours ago

100%. And It’s pure hubris to pretend that “intelligence”, especially of the general kind will be reached with language alone.

▲semiquaver 10 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Maybe you’re right. But it’s also wise to be cautious, just in case we do accidentally create something more intelligent and potentially more powerful than humanity.

You have to admit the prospect looks more likely than ten years ago.

▲Forgeties79 10 hours ago | parent [-]

We’re also closer to flying cars than we were 10 years ago but I’m not exactly planning for them.

▲semiquaver 10 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Flying cars definitely wont take my children’s livelihood. AI might.

▲jasomill 5 hours ago | parent [-]

Sure, but a surplus of labor doesn't pose an existential race to the species.

▲cowlevel 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

It does, as we all fight over who gets to provide the labour, because we built our economy on top of one big perverse incentive. People will kill each other over the right to drive a moving box 12 hours a day.

▲Forgeties79 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

If we refuse to rethink capitalism it kind of does

▲defrost 10 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I'm pretty happy with the flying boats we already have.

Local garage build, gotta love builders plastic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ILbQHnHPnY

▲origini 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I can explain an issue to some AI and it will 'understand' faster and better than human co-worker.

AI is here doing literaly the same job as a human who needs to be intelligent.

I see your stand as hubris from your side.

For such a strong viewpoint, you deliver not any context of why you think like this.

▲layer8 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Why did you put “understand” in quotes?

▲origini 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Because I don't think we are at the point that the word understanding matches what AI does.

I would say yes it understands things but it was a causios 'understand'

▲layer8 2 hours ago | parent [-]

I agree that while AI has some understanding, it doesn’t feel like it’s full understanding, the way we know it in humans. For that very reason I disagree that current AI can do the same job as a human. Regarding intelligence, it surpasses humans in some aspects of intelligence, but is lacking in others. In that sense, we haven’t reached AGI yet.

▲hologramofham 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> And It’s pure hubris to pretend that “intelligence”, especially of the general kind will be reached with language alone.

A human is born without any sensory connection to their body, except hearing. They can't feel their body or anything on their skin. They're blind. They can't taste or smell or touch. They can only hear, and make clumsy sounds in response, with no feeling of what their mouth is doing.

Are they intelligent?

▲layer8 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

With only hearing, I’m doubtful they’ll be able to learn language, because there’s nothing they can correlate what they’re hearing to.

▲danlitt 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I'm not sure what you're getting at here. Obviously not? I don't think anyone considers babies intelligent, at most they have the potential for intelligence.

▲ssivark 10 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I concur with the first part of your statement on hubris, but to be fair these models moved beyond language a long time ago.

They now have everything from videos and 3d modeling to robot behaviour be part of the training.

L"L"Ms is a bit of a misnomer that's stuck. Language just happens to be our interface to the AI.

▲oska 8 hours ago | parent [-]

LLMs may be a bit of a misnomer but it's far better than "AI"

At least LLMs include Model in the name, which is an accurate description of the tech

And actually, I've heard ppl just using the word "models" by itelf and that might be the best way to go

▲Scarblac 6 hours ago | parent [-]

Do you use "brain" instead of intelligence for humans too?

Why is it better to refer to something in terms of the technology it's based on?

▲oska 6 hours ago | parent [-]

I only talk about intelligence as a subjective value judgement of other conscious beings (i.e. humans & animals)

Consciousness & intelligence are not derivative of the material universe and will not 'emerge' in some special way from machines. That's a good science fiction story device (and actually the idea extends back in human storytelling before sci-fi) but ppl thinking that the idea can be reified in the real world are suffering from what I call "Science Fiction brain". (Or they are simply fraudsters, happy to talk rubbish to prop up a bubble.)

▲origini 5 hours ago | parent [-]

Are you arguing on an esotheric level aka soul and god and believe?

Or on a technical note because certain brain structures etc. might not exist in an LLM and stuff like a default mode network and sensory input and a world to move in, is missing?

▲oska 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Yeah, maybe esoteric (depends on your point of view) but not soul or god or spirit etc

Basically, I'm not a materialist (a widely shared position in philosophy across millennia and across cultures up until just recently). I treat consciousness as fundamental, not the material universe . Thus 'conjuring intelligence' into machines is simply not possible.

BTW, machine learning is a totally valid (and powerful) concept & technology from where I stand. But it's "dumb" learning.

▲origini 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Are you aware of the medical cases we had over the centuries which gave us insight how our brain contains everything we are?

Like the people who got certain brain injury and their whole persona changed or certain capabilites were lost?

There also research papers that certain brain structures have emerged in ML models.

▲namero999 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The esoteric angle is that held by materialists, which is based on the blind faith that complexity transmutes quantities into qualities. That's shallow religion, it's alchemy in its trivial form. An ontology based on consciousness is way more rational, as it is the in-your-face pre-cognitive given of existence.

▲semiquaver 3 hours ago | parent [-]

I am pretty sure you are making a logical error here (strawman). Materialism is not in any way at odds with taking the existence of consciousness as a given.

▲namero999 an hour ago | parent [-]

Ever heard of eliminative physicalism or even illusionism? Those are materialists metaphysics, and they are _very much_ at odds with the existence of consciousness.

At any rate, sure, not being at odds with the existence of consciousness might be a trait of the more reasonable strands of materialism (if there's even such a thing), but they will always see it as emergent/derivative and often even epiphenomenal, otherwise they wouldn't be materialist stances.

So am not sure where you see the logical misstep here, but am happy to hear. The point of the previous comment is that framing an ontology whose primitive is C, is in no way "esoteric", term that is usually used in contraposition with "rational". Taking C as epistemologically or even ontologically prior is the rational stance, not only on accounts of parsimony.

▲Scarblac 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

But language + all the tools, compute and storage an LLM can be given access to might be enough.

▲bananaflag 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What if it is true? Does it matter anymore whether it is also hubris?

▲paulddraper 10 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

There are many models modalities, some of which are language.

▲semiquaver 10 hours ago | parent [-]

In fact, many of these “large language models” are actually trained directly on language, images and sound! names stick past their aptness.

Y’know: come to think of it that’s the same three things our own brains are mostly trained on… I’m sure that without mammalian proprioception and weird physically-motivated limitations like saccades the result is just sparkling cognition though.

▲ 10 hours ago | parent | next [-]
[deleted]
▲8n4vidtmkvmk 9 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

That settles it boys. Just add 2 more senses and we have AGI.