Remix.run Logo
▲ pixl97 a day ago

Yesterday on a post I was stating that Responsible Disclosure has been the worst thing for computing ever. It has lulled humanity into the idea that computers are safe and we've built just massive amounts of digital infrastructure under that delusion.

If every bug was a zero day then we'd have never hooked things like water grids and electrical grids to networks. Grocery stores and bloodbanks would have never put freezers on the internet. Along with a million other huge security risks, too many to be named here.

The AI age has exposed that stupidity.

▲malfist a day ago | parent | next [-]

That's just not true. People don't hook up freezers to the internet because they think it's safe, they do it because it's cheap and convenient, and saves having to send someone out to manually check them every X hours. The free market doesn't reward more than legally minimum safety requirements.

▲RobotToaster 13 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> People don't hook up freezers to the internet because they think it's safe

I don't think that's true.

They may have known there was a risk, but historically it was small. If they knew it was certain to be hacked before next Thursday most would stop doing it pretty quickly.

It's like driving. Every time you drive there's a small chance of an accident, but everyone still does it. If there was a 50% chance of death most would stop doing it pretty quickly.

▲somenameforme 14 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don't think this is the issue. Freezers are extremely reliable. They're built to operate 24 hours a day for years on end. They're also designed to maintain approximate temperature (when full) for about 2 days, so even a freak outage isn't that big a deal.

There's no real problem being solved. People just went that direction to follow trend of 'smart' everything because it's cheap, you can concoct hypothetical scenarios where it might be useful for marketing (regardless of whether or not they're at all realistic), and most importantly of all - complete lack of awareness about the risks involved.

▲mschuster91 12 hours ago | parent [-]

> There's no real problem being solved.

There actually is. Humans are notoriously sloppy in following mundane, boring compliance bullshit tasks, and noting down freezer temperatures is what I'd say very high up on the list of bullshit tasks that are so pointless they're demeaning to the human who has to be the eyes for the machine.

Connecting the freezers to a central logging facility now needs no human checking the freezer every hour and writing down the temperature on a sheet of paper no one will ever read. It is precisely what machines are made for. And since compliance is now automatic instead of a strong incentive for the human to just invent "valid" data and be done, actual outages can now be spotted much faster.

▲somenameforme 10 hours ago | parent [-]

Again for normal usage this is not a very realistic scenario. Freezers generally keep relatively near to their target temperatures, when full, for about 48 hours. A grocery store or something might have it as part of a routine maintenance schedule alongside bathrooms, trash bins, etc but this is hardly some problem that needs solving, especially not if one is aware of the risks.

▲josnyder a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Your view can be harmonized with your parent comment's view.

Capitalism rewards all sorts of safety requirements, if they become visible to a balance sheet within a reasonable period of time. Just look at marine insurance in the middle east right now.

The status quo is that IoT freezers are massively inconvenient every decade or so. Businesses can live out an entire lifecycle in this period of time, without the risk ever hitting their balance sheet.

pixl97 is saying: what if we made the risk far more common, so that its effect shows up on a balance sheet within 6-12 months?

▲smuhakg 19 hours ago | parent [-]

> pixl97 is saying: what if we made the risk far more common, so that its effect shows up on a balance sheet within 6-12 months?

What is the purpose of this? It's just intentionally making hacks more common and a net negative for the economy.

More secure systems aren't inherently good. You don't hear people talking about how happy they are that break-ins are common and everyone locks their doors before leaving the house.

▲pixl97 19 hours ago | parent [-]

>More secure systems aren't inherently good.

I'm sorry buddy, but you were born in the wrong universe not to defend yourself.

The internet is a global network. This means people not under your sovereign jurisdiction can reach out and fuck with your data and you can do jack shit about it unless you want to take a bunch of other really expensive actions (for example economic or hot warfare).

Computer people should know better than thinking that the internet is anything other than an inherently hostile place. Groups we consider enemy nations share the same web space. Countries that make $1000 a year share the same web space, and all the juicy servers you leave insecure look like a very good way for them to become absolutely rich. Hell, even people in your own country are apt to get away with hacking with a little bit of skill.

The internet is not your neighborhood. You can't call the police to fix every little issue for you. It is a literal war zone, just most people are still in denial about that.

Now start treating it like that.

▲po1nt a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Because of the daddy state safety net, people are not risk aware. If they suffer the consequences they can always push for more state control in the spirit of "why did you let me do this". Whole prohibition stood on this idea.

▲jodrellblank 8 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The two most common causes of child death in the USA are parents running over their own children in their cars, and guns.

Please feel free to explain how people are not aware of the danger of running over their own children because of the daddy state, and how fun owners have somehow missed the dangers of guns.

The consequences are usually suffered by other people. You speed, other people die in the resulting crash. You get the freedom to make unsafe buildings and furniture and electrical goods for profit, other people die from them collapsing and burning down.

▲ZephyrP an hour ago | parent [-]

The results of directly querying wonder.cdc.gov reveal a record of tragedy that resists easy summary.

  DATASET
    Underlying Cause of Death, 2018-2024
  CONDITIONS:
    age >= 1 AND age <= 14 GROUP BY 'ICD-10 113 Cause List'

  +--------------------------------------------------------------------+------+---------------+
  |ICD-10 113 Cause List                                               |Deaths|95% CI Crude   |
  +--------------------------------------------------------------------+------+---------------+
  |#Accidents (unintentional injuries) (V01-X59,Y85-Y86)               |19,632|5.0 (4.9 - 5.0)|
  |  Nontransport accidents (W00-X59,Y86)                              |10,596|2.7 (2.6 - 2.7)|
  |  Transport accidents (V01-V99,Y85)                                 | 9,036|2.3 (2.2 - 2.3)|
  |  Motor vehicle accidents (V02-V89...)                              | 8,550|2.2 (2.1 - 2.2)|
  |All other diseases (Residual)                                       | 8,151|2.1 (2.0 - 2.1)|
  |#Malignant neoplasms (C00-C97)                                      | 7,750|2.0 (1.9 - 2.0)|
  |#Congenital malformations, deformations & chromosomal abn. (Q00-Q99)| 5,564|1.4 (1.4 - 1.4)|
  |#Assault (homicide) (*U01-*U02,X85-Y09,Y87.1)                       | 5,225|1.3 (1.3 - 1.4)|
  |Accidental drowning and submersion (W65-W74)                        | 4,700|1.2 (1.2 - 1.2)|
  |#Intentional self-harm (suicide) (*U03,X60-X84,Y87.0)               | 3,839|1.0 (0.9 - 1.0)|
  |Major cardiovascular diseases (I00-I78)                             | 3,271|0.8 (0.8 - 0.9)|
  |Other & unspec. nontransport accidents & sequelae (W20-Y86...)      | 2,717|0.7 (0.7 - 0.7)|
  |Symptoms, signs & abnormal clin./lab findings, NEC (R00-R99)        | 2,658|0.7 (0.6 - 0.7)|
  |Malignant neoplasms of meninges, brain & other CNS (C70-C72)        | 2,650|0.7 (0.6 - 0.7)|
  |Assault (homicide) by other/unspec. means & sequelae (*U01-Y87.1...)| 2,625|0.7 (0.6 - 0.7)|
  |Assault (homicide) by discharge of firearms (*U01.4,X93-X95)        | 2,600|0.7 (0.6 - 0.7)|
  |Intentional self-harm (suicide) by other/unspec. means (*U03-Y87.0) | 2,452|0.6 (0.6 - 0.6)|
  |All other & unspec. malignant neoplasms (C17-C97...)                | 2,435|0.6 (0.6 - 0.6)|
  |Other & unspec. infectious/parasitic diseases & sequelae (A00-U07.1)| 2,177|0.6 (0.5 - 0.6)|
  +--------------------------------------------------------------------+------+---------------+
▲malfist 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

What a ridiculous assertion. Do you go around sticking every small object in your mouth just because it doesn't have a sticker about chocking hazards?

▲hobo123 16 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

You know VPNs exist, right? Nobody has to hook their devices/freezers into the OPEN Internet.

▲happymellon 9 hours ago | parent [-]

Hell, what about the raspberry pi that logs all the temperatures and forwards them to the central supermarket logging system.

Why is there not a proxy so we don't need to expose the refrigerators to even a VPN?

▲aftbit a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Securely networking electrical grids offers improvements in reliability, which translates directly to safety. If the power goes off on a hot summer afternoon, people die. Networking enables faults to be detected and resolved faster, reducing the amount of time that the system stays in dangerous conditions.

Similarly, (securely) networking water treatment plants enables people to remotely verify that settings are where they're supposed to be and adjust them to match changing sample reports or intake conditions, reducing the risk of over-treating or under-treating the water, both of which can have safety consequences.

On top of that, networking enables much greater efficiency. Rather than having a person sitting at every substation ready to throw a breaker, or more likely, ready to drive there (taking time), you can have them sitting in a control room that monitors the whole grid at once.

Much of modern life would be much more expensive and much less safe without networking.

We really shouldn't throw the baby out with the bathwater. It is possible to build secure systems. It takes a certain degree of paranoia and dedication that humans find difficult, and a willingness and ability to respond quickly to unknown threats, but that doesn't make it impossible.

▲pixl97 a day ago | parent [-]

>Much of modern life would be much more expensive and much less safe without networking.

The modern world wouldn't work without gasoline, but it's burning the planet to the ground in the meantime.

If your efficiency is gained by taking the brakes off the car to make it lighter you're going to realize how bad you screwed up when it comes time to stop.

We've been playing a 30 year game of fucking around and we're reached find out time.

If we want to build secure systems we're going to have to flush about 95% of the programmers out there.

▲aftbit 21 hours ago | parent [-]

On the other hand, we wouldn't have gotten to fiber and 5G without spending some time on copper wires first.

I agree about one thing - incentives cannot work properly if it takes you 30 years to find out but your economy is built on 3 month business cycles.

We don't need to flush 95% of the programmers (though that is probably happening anyway). We need to flush 95% of the incentives to go fast and avoid spending money. Fast, cheap, or good - if you're very lucky and very good, you can squeeze two of them out of the equation. Most of the time, you're lucky to get even one.