Remix.run Logo
▲ RobotToaster a day ago

One of the problems with introducing a written constitution in the UK is that it would be unconstitutional to do so.

The current constitution is an unwritten common law constitution, but its main point is that parliament can do whatever it wants, and as such no parliament can bind a future parliament.

They tried making it so that calling an early election needed a 70% majority in the fixed term parliament act, but when the government of the day wanted to call an early election they simply repealed it instead.

The closest we've come is the human rights act, which works around this by saying that as far as possible all future legislation should be interpreted as to comply with it, but parliament can simply override it by explicitly stating so in legislation, or repealing it.

▲tsimionescu a day ago | parent | next [-]

All countries that created constitutions faced this "problem", including the UK back when Parliament was founded, against the divine right of the King and the aristocracy.

That is to say, there is no real problem here. The UK population, or Parliament itself, could just decide to create a constitution that binds future decisions, in violation of the old constituion, and the courts would anyway not be able to stop this.

Of course, the same would be true in the future - if a future Parliament/massive part of the UK population really wanted to do something that this proposed Constitution doesn't allow, they would just change the Constitution, or abolish it, or whatever they want. Any constitution is ultimately just a piece of paper, and can be ignored.

▲Gareth321 12 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I see this as a feature of democracy. People who are long since dead should not be able to bind future citizens living in a different world to certain laws and expectations and behaviours and standards. While I accept that there are good things which arise from constitutions, I think that on balance, they are undemocratic and restrictive.

▲cowlevel 10 hours ago | parent [-]

The world's been around long enough that we know how both systems go. Long constitutions like the US suffer from context drift, but they find it harder to make things worse - it can still happen but if most people are obeying the constitution over the government it's harder for a government to do bad things. Countries without constitutions can adapt to new situations, but they can also turn fascist or totalitarian on a dime.

▲carlosjobim a day ago | parent | prev [-]

And the future UK population or parliament could decide to undo that constitution just as quickly.

"Our Constitution is a remarkable, beautiful gift. But it's really just a piece of parchment. It has no power on its own. We, the people, give it power. We, the people, give it meaning — with our participation, and with the choices that we make and the alliances that we forge."

And this is true for any government debts as well. Nothing can obligate a future government and the future population to pay off the debts of the old. Anybody lending money to a government should know this and expect to never be repaid. But people in general have a little harder to swallow this than constitutional changes.

▲cowlevel 18 hours ago | parent [-]

The government would know that it would never be able to borrow money after that ever again. And that's not its decision, so it's not something it can repeal.

▲Silhouette 18 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is a common but fundamentally flawed argument. You solve that problem by having a law passed under the old system that recognises the new Constitution, creates let's say a "Senate" with the power to legislate under that Constitution, and then dissolves Parliament leaving no mechanism to elect another. In our case you might have to abolish the monarchy as well because the monarch technically is still involved in some of these processes. But in essence you recognise the authority of the new system under the old one and then leave no other way for the old one to be used any further. You could adopt an electoral system that isn't a mathematical joke and some proper constitutional basis for the scope, powers, responsibilities, and limitations of each part of the new system of government at the same time.

Of course this is probably a dream unless we end up in some nightmare scenario where we need to build a new government from scratch anyway. You would need exceptional legal minds to even write such a Constitution and then you would need exceptional campaigning to get it passed by a popular referendum to give it moral legitimacy - and the only political groups with the resources to do those things probably have very strong vested interests in maintaining the status quo.

▲viklove a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> parliament can do whatever it wants, and as such no parliament can bind a future parliament

So parliament can't do whatever it wants.

▲cowlevel 18 hours ago | parent [-]

It can. It can write a law saying the next parliament must quack thrice a day. The next parliament can also do anything so it may choose not to quack.

▲viklove 2 hours ago | parent [-]

You can use a bs contrived example to hand-wave away the problem, but keep in mind that we are discussing a constitution in this thread.

Apparently British parliament can't protect its citizens from being stripped of their rights by a future parliament. That's not a feature, that's a bug.