Remix.run Logo
▲ qeternity 2 hours ago

> A company doesn't become worth 20% more if it issues 20% new shares.

If the prevailing price of those shares does not change, then yes, it actually does.

> Existing shares become worth less.

Maybe, maybe not. You're talking like this is all formulaic.

▲joshribakoff an hour ago | parent | next [-]

You guys are talking past each other. A company‘s worth and it’s market cap are two different things. One is the actual future value, and the other is the markets prediction of the future value.

▲qeternity an hour ago | parent [-]

You're trying to find an out for GP's bad argument.

They literally talked about "adding up all the shares" and argued against that, but for mechanical reasons, not philosophical reasons about value and worth.

And for all intents an purposes, a company's "worth" (undefined) is almost always measured by its market cap (well defined) as the least-worst approximation.

▲demibabs an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> If the prevailing price of those shares does not change, then yes, it actually does.

His whole point is that you can’t assume that.

▲sillysaurusx 25 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

But that's true for every stock in the history of stocks. Every security has an uncertain future.

▲qeternity an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

No, his point was that he assumed they would go down.

Maybe, probably even...but it's irrelevant.

▲zamalek 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> If the prevailing price of those shares does not change

That assumption is doing a huge amount of work. How many shares don't change?

▲qeternity an hour ago | parent [-]

It is not an assumption. Do you notice how that sentence starts with "If..."

Critical thinking is in a bear market on HN.

▲zamalek 20 minutes ago | parent [-]

Then why mention it at all? Almost the entire thesis is that assumption.

> Critical thinking

Indeed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Begging_the_question

▲paxy an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

If a company announces a 2:1 stock split does the market cap go up 2x? What would you say if a website reported "Apple is going to double in value tomorrow!!"? After all it is possible in theory if everyone decides to value the shares at the same price they were pre-split. But reporting it as fact is still 100% incorrect. That's the same logic being used for Anthropic.