| ▲ | drudolph914 an hour ago |
| contrarian opinion. I think all we’ve learned is SWEs are still very much needed. gas town failed, it failed quietly, but no one doing real work talks about software factories anymore. Most companies that are running the “how many SWEs can we fire before it all breaks” experiment have learned it’s a failed experiment - this validated by every single major company/product outage where their uptime went below 90% this year. I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone |
|
| ▲ | mrbombastic an hour ago | parent | next [-] |
| It is strange this is the contrarian opinion when most of the evidence points to it being the case. Everyone working is busier than ever, more prs but no end in sight to the backlog still and fires to put out every day. PMs and designers who have deeper idea of product then most can put up some automatic prs for quick fixes, everyone with a bit of time can build siloed dashboards on their own but actually doing the day to day eng work to keep things running or design a new service to integrate with the product…I’m not seeing it |
| |
| ▲ | WarmWash 39 minutes ago | parent | next [-] | | I think my fear is rooted in knowing that the tech has moved way faster than humans can adapt to it. So we are not waiting for the tech to get good enough, we're waiting for humans to understand and integrate it. I don't work in tech, rather manufacturing, and our company is barely using any AI (or using it, but only like AI mode in Google) despite me knowing that we could easily use it to cut heads. The automation we are leaving on the table is huge. But I'm not gonna be the one to go to my bosses and say "Hey, you want me to show you what we can do with SOTA models and agents?". For now I'll just stick to using my accounts to leverage my job. | | |
| ▲ | isympathize 24 minutes ago | parent [-] | | > But I'm not gonna be the one to go to my bosses and say "Hey, you want me to show you what we can do with SOTA models and agents?" I actually did. It doesn’t really change much IME. I just did it to come out in the open about AI use and start the slow adaptive process. It’s been a year now and just this week some colleagues are starting to act surprised by what is possible. I’m in software dev for crying out loud. This world is teeming with stingy sysadmins and neckbeards proclaiming it are all toys and soon everything will be back to normal. If the culture doesn’t pick it up automatically there is some mixture of cultural factors holding them back and just knowing about tools ain’t it. |
| |
| ▲ | Fr0styMatt88 26 minutes ago | parent | prev [-] | | It’s weird to see the change in the default tone of discussions on this site over the last decade. We’ve gone from being eternal optimists to whatever this is. I think we were a bit smug as a group. Sure we were disrupting EVERYONE ELSE and saying how disruption is just the natural way things work, everyone should adapt, etc. Now that we are the ones having to cope with the same thing, suddenly all that goes out the window. I know I’m speaking in generalities here. I’m in the same boat as everyone else. I do argue that for those of us that have been into this since we’re kids, we grew up being told we were the exception. OUR jobs would never be obsolete, we are the future; we looked at people who refused to adapt with judgement. Now it’s our turn to adapt. | | |
| ▲ | matheusmoreira 2 minutes ago | parent [-] | | > I think we were a bit smug as a group. Indeed. I always call it out. It was fine to disrupt everyone else. It was fine to replace all those laborers. If they complained, we just told them it was the implacable march of technology, told them to learn some new skill. I'm a doctor. Putting me out of a job is and has always been one of the wettest dreams of hackers. It was palpable in every thread about medicine on HN. But now artists are getting automated and software developers are getting replaced. Watching people here treat it as a crime against humanity is just too much for me. |
|
|
|
| ▲ | daringrain32781 43 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| I think there's a spectrum of being a SWE and what we're seeing is the ones essentially just writing boilerplate code most of their day have a very different view than those who are solving problems with software that require careful thinking and execution. A lot of people seem to think they can pick up an LLM and suddenly write software solutions as good as a seasoned SWE. But it turns into this terrible mess that's thrown out all engineering fundamentals, solving the symptoms instead of the cause. If I were just writing boilerplate code with an LLM all day I'd be very scared for my job too. |
| |
| ▲ | wtch98 23 minutes ago | parent [-] | | I've been writing code for money for 30 years, I have no concerns about my job because 90% of my job is not writing code, it's understanding actual business needs (not just declared needs) and thinking about how to solve them. |
|
|
| ▲ | mirmor23 43 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| > I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone Here are few anecdotes: 1. I've a friend who owns a PT (physical therapy) business. He's not even a tech guy, but uses claude to manage most of the business aspects, and he has told me repeatedly that he would've to spend thousands of dollars to get things done, and instead he pays 250 per year. 2. Another friend is smart, and is a jack-of-all-trades type in the software/hardware/firmware business. He is solo bootstrapping by doing all the things from pcb to webapp. He doesn't see hiring anyone for the niche business. 3. A 65 year old friend of mine who never in any tech career was able to build website for his side business (that website looks really good btw) and he now talks about json and ocr. You are the one who is out of touch with reality. |
| |
| ▲ | cm2012 30 minutes ago | parent | next [-] | | None of those people could afford to hire a programmer before. | |
| ▲ | Seattle3503 23 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-] | | > 2. Another friend is smart, and is a jack-of-all-trades type in the software/hardware/firmware business. He is solo bootstrapping by doing all the things from pcb to webapp. He doesn't see hiring anyone for the niche business. I've got a friend in this situation too. He's going to hit a limit of what he can do with agents. And whatever agents can't do, his business can't do. We are going to find the shape of that soon. Normally hitting a limit is where you would hire someone, but building organizations with heavy agent use is hard. AI is very very good at shifting work onto other people and business units; that's what all the complaining about review (and not just code review) is about. None of that responsibility shifting happens in a solo setup. | |
| ▲ | codethief 10 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-] | | OTOH maybe the second and third friend of yours would have never considered starting a business if it weren't for AI? And the people your first friend would have normally hired and who are now without work are (or will soon be) thinking about starting their own business, too? Who knows? In other words, the verdict is still out on whether we'll see a decrease in jobs in the long run or not. Personally, I'm not very optimistic but, as I tried to illustrate above, I might very well be (and certainly hope to be) wrong. | |
| ▲ | drudolph914 30 minutes ago | parent | prev [-] | | I don’t disagree that regular people can now make some basic software, but if you’re doing anything real with actual scale or consequences, nothings really changed. and to be exact, "real" means that if something goes, wrong then: there is massive lose in revenue for a business and or infrastructure that people rely on goes down if you’re working anything in this way, no one is just trusting a clanker. some thought leader might say the world is trusting an AI, but it’s not true. every company internally that is more than 2 people isn't trusting a bot, and it's well understand that it's a horrible idea (even by regular bullish AI business heads) so yes, I have the bot help me write a basic website for me, and it can one shot the typescript express app-layer boilerplate for me, but if you’re serving even the most basic app at scale with consequences, the bot isn't mitigating the concerns and engineering decisions that go into this work. a concrete real world example: literally msft outlook went down a week ago. it was out for god knows how many actual hours. it still might be partly down tbh. this is technology that is “solved” and is dumb simple in terms of complexity. their product was out for 48+ hours. and the status messages shared publicly by the engineering team did not only convey incompetence, but to paraphrase, the message they sent out was along the lines of, “We think we found the source of the problem, but unsure, the problem might be larger” how much you want to bet they had a team of 30+ engs running around with claude asking the equivalent of, “please fix outage, no mistakes” I’m still not convinced the outage is fully recovered because I still get errors. point is, yes there isn’t a giant 100 football field wide moat between regular people and programming anymore. smart people can do basic stuff and less inclined people can build a static website now. if you’re worried about that, go study more and you'll learn the depths of this field go WAY beyond typing code EDIT: typos | | |
| ▲ | mirmor23 4 minutes ago | parent [-] | | > point is, yes there isn’t a giant 100 football field wide most between regular people and programming anymore. smart people can do basic stuff and less inclined people can build a static website now. if you’re worried about that, go study more and you'll learn the depths of this field go WAY beyond typing code The implication is far reaching. Lots of non-tech businesses which relied on expert help can now pareto slice it and hire experts on need basis unlike before. Saving money and increasing profits can be a big motivator to own many of those tasks too. Lots of people who were cosplaying as experts on non-tech people will have less and less opportunities. Previously, being a knowledge worker could get you far, now the knowledge worker has to level up, and if opportunities are limited how could it happen? Even then, more experts (practice, not theory) is not a given, considering the bell curve effect. |
|
|
|
| ▲ | lbrito an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| >gas town failed quietly This is a big problem. When this kind of thing gets launched, its all fanfare, this is the future, get on the boat or die. But then it fails miserably and its like it never existed |
| |
|
| ▲ | medler an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| I agree, but to the extent I’m worried about the future of the profession, it’s because I don’t know how much more the models are going to improve. Today’s models desperately need a real SWE in the loop to do most serious engineering. Will that still be the case in 5 years? I really don’t know |
| |
| ▲ | eptcyka 40 minutes ago | parent | next [-] | | I think integrating libraries into a product will be essentially free. Novel solutions that require an understanding of the problem space to such an extent that unorthodox solutions seem viable is still the limit in my experience. LLMs, at least in my experience, need lots of guidance when the solution you want is not something that has already been done. If you look at it from a business perspective- most software shops have a small proportion of their software that is truly unique and their USP - the rest is not necessarily boilerplate, but definitely not bespoke and unique. This overhead will now be cheaper. Similarly, software vendors that dominate despite not having any bespoke, unique software component will soon have a tougher time. Why would someone pay for atlassian products now? All of their products are not good software- they have market dominance. Replicating their features will be trivial. Anyone who will be sufficiently fed up with paying will DIY the solution. | | |
| ▲ | oblio a few seconds ago | parent [-] | | Atlassian (or Adobe) have lots of features. The famous MS Word quote applies. 80% of people only use 20% of features, but if you build the 20% solution you only attract 5% of the userbase because they all use different features from the 100%. |
| |
| ▲ | tcoff91 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-] | | I feel like once it doesn't need an engineer in the loop, does it need ANYBODY in the loop? at that point the whole company can probably be autonomous. That seems like it would be such a paradigm shift that the second and third order effects are so crazy and nobody can predict what that world will actually look like | | | |
| ▲ | hbcdbff an hour ago | parent | prev [-] | | IMO models are getting smarter at software, but not at software engineering. |
|
|
| ▲ | Miraste 23 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| > it’s a failed experiment - this validated by every single major company/product outage where their uptime went below 90% this year. This is engineering thinking, not business thinking. The question is, did the uptime drops cost the company more money than the firings saved? If the answer is no (which for megacorps like Microsoft it is) then the experiment was a success. |
|
| ▲ | ramblerman an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| Gastown was too early and focused on the angle that having agents cosplaying a mini org chart was the way to get better results. |
|
| ▲ | pipes 20 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| I didn't know gas town failed. What happened? Did Steve yegge say as much? |
|
| ▲ | gloosx 19 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| this is the only reasonable opinion. people saying "they made a thing which does the job" just fell to the hype mindlessly. someone still needs to input stuff into a thing which does the job, this someone is SWE or systems analyst. not everyone is a good systems analyst and can turn business goals into a clear specification to implement. if the hype was all true, i could just prompt the llm to make me money and it would be able to do it, but it's not possible |
|
| ▲ | javier2 31 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| Some of these staff reductions are also due to the ENORMOUS pull of the US IT sector. There are not many companies with as many SWE as Microsoft and Meta, so some reduction isn't that surprising. |
|
| ▲ | newsy-combi an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| Are they bringing their employees back in the same numbers and for the same wages though? Or are they outsourcing to Indian humans-in-the-loop for 1% of the cost? |
| |
| ▲ | nwatson an hour ago | parent | next [-] | | Some are keeping the onshore senior engineers / architects and using the LLMs / agent-harnesses to replace the offshore. | |
| ▲ | pegasus an hour ago | parent | prev [-] | | Depends what quality of work they want? Hopefully they've learned their lessons in the first outsourcing craze, before AI lured them to another ride on the same carousel. | | |
| ▲ | drudolph914 4 minutes ago | parent [-] | | from my experience, offshore talent was for boilerplate coding. and the new bar for quality is now <insert-your-favorite-LLM>. so I think most LLMs are better than the majority offshore talent nowadays |
|
|
|
| ▲ | cheeze 37 minutes ago | parent | prev [-] |
| > but no one doing real work talks about software factories anymore My friends at FAANG companies would disagree here. If anything, it seems to be the exact opposite. Sure, it's not a end-to-end 0 touch factory, but a majority of folks I talk to these days that I consider good engineers aren't writing _any_ code anymore. They do that as a hobby outside of work. |
| |
| ▲ | ro_sharp 13 minutes ago | parent | next [-] | | But are they reading it? I’m producing something like 10x more LOC than in the past, but am reading almost all of it, only excluding things like prototypes and testing tools. | |
| ▲ | arrowleaf 5 minutes ago | parent | prev [-] | | Non-FAANG, I don't have the luxury of product owners and designers who know the ins and outs of systems to present well-specced requirements docs. Or Jira tickets that aren't absolutely full of default-style Claude slop. It's not that I don't have my own slop factory which implements as-written, maybe bringing me into the loop for the most non-trivial decisions, and takes it through test, MR, and to production staging... but most of the interesting cases I pick up really do need a human to make the non-trivial design decisions. I've seen the garbage that these SOTA models put out when nobody's at the gate. |
|