Remix.run Logo
▲ Shellban 3 hours ago

Do we really want to let society crumble? I do not argue that Western society is deeply sick, but an abrupt collapse of the current order will leave us in an intermediary period of poverty and war (see the French and Russian revolutions). Even the American revolution notably kept in place a lot of the pre-existing English culture and legal customs that the colonies were already following before England started interfering.

▲ted_dunning 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Also, rebuilding from scratch is a fantasy because we have exhausted many of the mineral resources that a less advanced society could extract.

▲graemep 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Some of them, like coal and oil.

On the other hand we have already extracted things like metals and they are much easier to get at.

▲Shellban 2 hours ago | parent [-]

One thing to ponder is how advanced we want the next society to be. Up until around the 19th century, societies got by with primarily wood, stone, some metals, and various animals and animal-derived substances. While we were not getting to the moon with these, we were still able to sustain stable civilizations with these resources for millennia. Furthermore, these resources are still quite available and quite accessible, assuming we do not nuke the entire biosphere in one go.

Of course, the lack of modern materials would put a damper on building massive populations and our fight against microscopic threats (see: the Black Death), but society is still quite possible, if less expansive.