Remix.run Logo
▲ brightball 3 hours ago

That's the main reason I've been fixated on this company in Australia for the last few years (that I found out about on HN).

https://graphenemg.com/graphene-products/thermal-xr/

They have a coating that can be applied to HVAC units which results in about a 40% improvement in energy efficiency. In the US it's distribution seems to be handled by Nu-Calgon and for whatever reason they branded it "CoolWorx" in addition to a data center focused version called "DataWorx."

The branding was bit of a shock because it takes something that's a potentially a global leap forward at a reasonable price and makes it look like something you'd buy off of an infomercial.

In terms of making your own home more energy efficient, the path is always cost optimized. You figure out where your energy bleeds are and fix them first because it's significantly better ROI than trying to add solar to cover everything. Then when you reduce your consumption enough, you don't need as much solar. Efficiency of your fridge, HVAC units, seals and temp loss from windows & doors. If you're in an area with rates that vary by time of day, home batteries that can charge when it's cheap and then use that when it's more expensive.

40% efficiency improvement in one of the most expensive utilities should be an automatic purchase for the price.

▲Aurornis 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> They have a coating that can be applied to HVAC units which results in about a 40% improvement in energy efficiency.

Sorry to disappoint, but their coating will not do that.

As far as I can see, they've mixed some graphene into a corrosion protection coating. Then their marketing team abandoned reality and claimed 40% improvements in something.

Corrosion protection is important for extending service life of an HVAC unit, but the coating isn't going to increase efficiency by 40%, or at all. It's a film on top of the coils which technically reduces thermal performance, but the film is so small I guarantee this is negligible.

Maybe they're trying to claim that the graphene in the mix improves emissivity? You would achieve the same result by coating the coils with anything black, but that's a negligible factor.

Sorry to burst your bubble, but this company doesn't have anything that will change world energy consumption. It's a corrosion inhibitor with a little bit of graphene and a lot of marketing.

▲clickety_clack 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Ya, I was thinking it’s maybe in comparison to a coating that doesn’t have graphene or something. If it was a real 40% efficiency gain, manufacturers would already be applying it.

▲infecto 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

+1 I tried to skim through what they were measuring. My best guess was maybe the coating prevents grime/grease buildup so most of that was the difference between clean coils and dirty coils.

▲fhn 9 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

exactly. show me independent studies of performance or this is just marketing garbage.

▲rokkamokka 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Correct me if I'm wrong but as I understand it this doesn't mean 40% more efficient AC, it's only the heatsink being 40% more efficient at dissipating heat?

▲brightball 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I don't have details handy, but this is a little farther down on their website. There's also a chart of field study results farther down.

> 10-50% energy reduction measured across commercial HVAC, chillers and data centres.

▲cucumber3732842 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

"40% more efficient A/C" is a way, way, way milder claim than "40% better heat sink" so I would assume that they're making the former claim.

▲rokkamokka 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Really? I guess making a heatsink dissipate 40% more heat is great for lots of applications (and hard), but it shouldn't translate to great gains in AC efficiency, right?

▲rightnutwingjob 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

No it isn’t.

If the claim is 40% more efficient AC, that’s the whole system.

If it were only for, say, the heat sink component, thats only one component.

You see how one component being more efficient contributes only a fraction to the total system?

▲cucumber3732842 2 hours ago | parent [-]

You can make a system suck 40% less energy by improving one component enough to cross some threshold that makes whatever the energy suck is happen less (e.g. the difference between zero and some insulation on a fridge). That's easy.

Improving the heat transfer of a heat sink with a surface coating is hard (for reasonable definitions of "heat sink" and "surface coating") because you run right into physics.

▲pstuart 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is great, but more solar PV installs would help too -- they should pay for themselves in a reasonable amount of time for those with high electrical costs.

▲ an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲cheschire 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There’s a reason infomercials use that sort of language. It’s like when HN users are disappointed that the average of all human English language produces substandard (for them) AI-isms in the output.

Maybe they did focus group tests that showed that name got them the attention they needed in that market.

▲cucumber3732842 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Painting surfaces for heat transfer is a 200yo trick. It's not worth 40%. It's more like +10%/-20% if you're being optimistic and using super modern engineered materials.

They must be making some weird marketing truck where they've set up some special situation where 10% improvement results in 4x that reduction in energy usage some other way For example in a heating context it's really easy to imagine how a 10% improvement to a heat pump could result in it kicking on the resistive heating much less in some climates for an overall 40% reduction in energy for the same set point.

If real world performance were anywhere near claimed without unacceptable tradeoffs (falls off if you look at it funny and then the dust gives you an incurable disease) and if you it would already be everywhere. Even if it cost as much as upsizing the hardware you'd see it space constrained applications.

15yr ago everyone was making the same silver bullet claims about ERV/HRV and it turned out those only really move the needle for very specific climates and building uses but the sellers are laughing all the way to the bank because the various codes and green this and that incentives that they got written into draw no such distinction.

So yeah, color me skeptical.