| ▲ | gravitronic 3 days ago |
| MTGO biggest drawback is you need to pay real money for the virtual cards, and sometimes they cost more than the paper cards themselves. Endstep.cc is a newcomer to the field.. it runs the forge engine on the server and allows online play. It is now my favorite place to play my favorite format (pauper) |
|
| ▲ | StableAlkyne 3 days ago | parent | next [-] |
| I've been really enjoying Tabletop Simulator for EDH with friends. It's mostly manual (some automatic stuff like turn tracking, cascading, scrying, mulligans, etc), but as fun as the paper card game Granted, we all play bracket 3 or so. Since you're importing decks you could always bring out some crazy deck with moxes everywhere... But nobody does that because it's just low stakes fun |
|
| ▲ | noboostforyou 2 days ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| > need to pay real money for the virtual cards, and sometimes they cost more than the paper cards themselves. I have stopped playing since years ago but it used to be that if you collected a full digital set in MTGO you could redeem it for a physical set of cards so there was at least some value exchange there. |
| |
| ▲ | JamesSwift 2 days ago | parent [-] | | Yep its been a long time since that went away. That to me was the start of the decline of my engagement with the game, but planeswalkers and deliberate power creep accelerated it. |
|
|
| ▲ | InsidiousWombat 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| collectible bard games have been engineered specifically for that, extracting as much money as possible. Not to just have a good product and sell it, maybe even at premium, but to make sure there is constant churn of them When a guy responsible for MTG got a gig for Valve to do their computer card game it was disaster, PC gamers got shocked by the absolute greed of the business model compared to even existing popular computer card games like hearthstone |
| |
| ▲ | 6510 2 days ago | parent [-] | | I remember a sub community of people hoarding, buying and selling unopened boxes and a sub community of big spenders who would adjust what they were willing to pay for a box based on the number of readily available unopened boxes from a series. If the number declined others were afraid to miss out, increased their bid until the hoarders wouldn't sell anymore. The more they bid the less likely to get it. |
|
|
| ▲ | brightball 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| As somebody that played back in the 90s (and gave away my cards that would be worth a $30-40k today... sigh) - it's critical to the gameplay. If everybody has every card then the game just comes down to people grabbing the most powerful deck combinations and playing them. The work to actually acquire the cards, play with creative combinations that you come up with based on what you have available, etc is where the real fun and challenge of the game comes from. It's the "resource limiter" constraint. I enjoyed playing one of the old iPhone versions before the latest one came out and when they wanted to kill it, they just gave everybody every card as a "gift". It went from fun and challenging to just stupid overnight. The days of kids having binders of cards at their local comic book store and trading with each other were a great time. Now it seems like people just save up and order from somebody selling online. |
| |
| ▲ | scubbo 2 days ago | parent | next [-] | | > The work [and expense] to actually acquire the cards, play with creative combinations that you come up with based on what you have available, etc is where the real fun and challenge of the game comes from. It's the "resource limiter" constraint. I respectfully, but entirely, disagree. It's _a_ source of constraints, but by no means the only one, if your playgroup's dynamic is healthy and communicative. My group is very proxy-friendly - and we all have decks that run the gamut from hyper-tuned cEDH, all the way down to meme-y "I wanted to see if I could make a deck where every card includes a pun somewhere" jank piles. Heck, every Christmas we have a themed White Elephant event where we must build a deck with value less than $15, then swap them and play. So long as one is more focused on having fun within a game than on winning, you can always impose your own mutual "resource limiters" _without_ having to spend real money. | | |
| ▲ | gmd63 6 hours ago | parent [-] | | Competition that doesn't do enough to mitigate economic advantage always ends up a boring re-run of the same tired lesson that almost everything is pay to win. |
| |
| ▲ | fph 2 days ago | parent | prev | next [-] | | The real money market is not intrinsically critical to the gameplay. For instance, having infinite free booster drafts would give you the same limited-resource constraints. Or also a game where you just give everyone the same number of packs per day: that would make an even fairer playing field than the current state, which is basically pay-to-win. | |
| ▲ | tancop 2 days ago | parent | prev | next [-] | | But you don't need real money to make it work. Set up a community server that tracks everyone's collection and lets you trade. You buy packs for tokens you get for playing, winning and passively over time. | |
| ▲ | theptip 2 days ago | parent | prev | next [-] | | As a counterpoint, I played MTG as a kid and built my own jank. Then played Arena when it came out, and enjoyed it way more; I found playing a meta deck to just be so much more fun. I don’t know if the economy has changed but when I was playing Arena you could essentially get every card you need from a set for $100 or so in packs. (Not to mention that it’s totally possible to grind up a couple cheap meta decks on F2P.) The constrained deck building challenge you are referring to can still be had in drafts, which are also cheaper in Arena. I do agree the social aspect is lost, which is its own thing. | | | |
| ▲ | zemvpferreira 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-] | | That’s one part to enjoy. The other part is the game itself, which for many people (myself included) is great fun without having to worry about buying more boosters to dig for more powerful cards. | | |
| ▲ | hnedeotes 2 days ago | parent [-] | | At some point I stopped enjoying the game (due to many reasons, biggest is randomness but even the lore & flavour of the game just went downhill after a certain point and nowadays I can't even stand a release video... It's the same flavour as marvel movies and sequels but in another context) but I always enjoyed the type of game it offers. If you're into it these kind of game-play/puzzles I'm working on a slightly different game, that has no randomness (my biggest issue with MtG after having played it casually over the years). Although the web-client is fairly less enticing than arena game-play I'm working on the client and AI - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SswKnyrDAaE you can see the work in progress in that video - that's just a test run and the AI was completely dumb at that point it's now much more competitive already - note the original game, the rules engine and web-browser version, etc, weren't vibe-coded but I'm building this native client all with agents, and they actually play against the original server. On the online version you can draft for free (against bots) without keeping the scrolls (playground), but I would wait a bit as I'm releasing new scrolls and hopefully the native client not too far from now. You can also play for free by going to library, making a codex and joining the queue but you probably need to find someone to join you as right now there's basically 0 players and no AI on the web version yet. | | |
| ▲ | brightball 2 days ago | parent [-] | | For what it’s worth, there’s a variation you can play to help with randomness; particularly the too much/not enough land dynamic that just kills at times. Separate all lands into a separate deck and when your draw phase comes you get to choose which deck to draw from. It’s a fun variation and seems to lead to a lot more consistency in gameplay when my friends and kids have tried it. The flip side is that your opponents also get to choose which deck when they mill you. | | |
| ▲ | hnedeotes 2 days ago | parent [-] | | Oh, hey, I know you from elixir land - didn't imagine you were into MtG! That would definitively work for mana-screw/flood but my issue is really more with the randomness. I was never into variants nor commander and such, just drafts & sealed and a bit of constructed. Maybe in the future you'll have another game to play with them :D To me it just stopped feeling rewarding to play - I probably would enjoy a draft for the giggles with real people, but otherwise it just really stopped being something I enjoyed to play. The first deck I bought was in Ice Age (which was overall a very bad set) but the lore drew me immediately in, as a kid that also enjoyed painting warhammer figures and playing make your own adventure books. I did make a few official tournaments and we used to play at a local store FNMs, after that still went to one or two releases for sealed deck and drafting but never collected again. Then played Online sporadically and Arena did a few runs - I think Outlaws of Thunder junction was the last time I tried to play it more seriously and haven't since then. My first seriously brewed deck was an Early Harvest/Mind's Desire deck that would just have me taking turns if I didn't die in the early turns and flipping cards until brain freeze - before storm was a table stakes deck in modern. Most people hadn't seen anything like it at the time. And that's what I really in the game, the sort of turn based game play and the brewing deck list aspects of it, specially drafts or figuring out synergies. | | |
| ▲ | brightball 2 days ago | parent [-] | | |>waves in Elixir Yea, I can see that. I started in 4th edition so you and I got in it around the same time. I didn't really play at all after 97 and until my son showed an interest, so I have refreshed my knowledge a little bit. Had a good time showing him the game and beating him over and over again until he got determined...and now he smokes me every time we play. Always enjoyed the game dynamic though. Back in high school I was so deeply into it that I was analyzing card combinations late into the night trying to figure out fun decks. Definitely don't have that type of time to invest into it anymore, but I do have a lot of good memories. | | |
| ▲ | hnedeotes 2 days ago | parent [-] | | Age doesn't forgive as they say... I also enjoyed it but I think that anything more than a very casual hobby, it's actually detrimental - the whole thing, and more so with the digital versions, the land draw smoothing, the way it's been designed for a long-time, borders or is right out evil. To each their own, I'm happy I no longer have the slightest interest in it other than the mathematical properties and the game-design. On the other hand I would like to have a game that is similar but inherently different at the same time. |
|
|
|
|
| |
| ▲ | 0x3444ac53 2 days ago | parent | prev [-] | | You're right and wrong. Most edh (even the tournaments) not only allow for but encourage proxies. |
|
|
| ▲ | mock-possum 2 days ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| > MTGO biggest drawback is you need to pay real money for the virtual cards Which comes hard on the heels of MTG’s biggest drawback, which is needing to pay real money for real cards, priced according to both the current meta and artificial rarity. |
| |
| ▲ | 0x3444ac53 2 days ago | parent [-] | | Most if not all edh play groups, including at the tournament level, both welcome and encourage the use of proxies. The more interesting thing is who can build the best deck, and who can pilot it well. In a multiplayer format like edh, there is also a bit of an emphasis on table politic'ing |
|
|
| ▲ | apitman 3 days ago | parent | prev [-] |
| There are at least a few ways to play for free without paying, with access to every card in the game's history. If you want to join official events and have access to a wider player base then yes, it costs. |