Remix.run Logo
▲ tencentshill a day ago

RCS was their best attempt at a cross platform service, and it has silent failure rates of over 50%, forcing me to stop using it entirely.

▲Miraste a day ago | parent | next [-]

I've been on Android since Gingerbread but RCS makes me want to get an iPhone. No idea how Google thought shipping it with worse reliability than SMS/MMS was acceptable.

▲Falell a day ago | parent [-]

Replied to a message: Yeah it's pretty bad.

▲ggm a day ago | parent | prev [-]

This is not my experience. I dont doubt it is your experience, but you surely must mean 50% of your messages not 50% of the cohort because RCS is now deployed worldwide at scale to BILLIONS of people and if 50% were failing, we'd know.

RCS is normalised, and works at the same reliability as SMS for the vast majority of the global messaging community.

▲fc417fc802 a day ago | parent | next [-]

> RCS is normalised, and works at the same reliability as SMS for the vast majority of the global messaging community.

Not at all, no. Among my non-technical acquaintances they all (all, not just some subset) complain that RCS is unreliable seemingly at random some small fraction of the time. However it works most of the time and (unlike SMS) you can send high resolution pictures and (in particular) videos so they continue to complain about it rather than switching. (There are various downsides to any of the options they could switch to.)

▲wolvoleo a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Maybe in the US but here in Europe we don't use RCS at all. I don't want to use the Google messages app. I just want to use WhatsApp and Telegram. I have RCS turned off and Google messages uninstalled (I use Fossify Messages)

But even my friends and family never use it. The main raison d'etre is compatibility with iMessage but hardly anyone does iPhones here and those who do just use WhatsApp anyway.

Here it's a solution for a non-issue and as such it's just another option cluttering the landscape. https://xkcd.com/927/

I'm open to switching to something else but moving from meta WhatsApp to Google RCS is just as bad. I want to cut out big tech. For now WhatsApp is unfortunately unavoidable but moving to something else from Google is just wasted effort.

▲annzabelle 21 hours ago | parent [-]

RCS was a massive improvement to my messaging experience as an American Android user. We would regularly get into all kinds of issues with SMS group chats because they just didn't work right, but they were still the default way to message a group in the US.

In the US the standard is you give people your phone number and you text them from the messaging app that came with your phone, and if you want to get multiple people into a chat you add them to a chat on that default messaging app.

You quickly run into issues with any other chat client that at least one person in the group doesn't have it. Instagram and Facebook often have one person or another who's cutting social media, Snapchat is for children, Discord is for gamers, iMessage is Apple-only, WhatsApp is for messaging people who don't have +1 numbers, Signal/Telegram etc are for the paranoid or for buying drugs.

We're not locked into WhatsApp like many countries are, and I find it odd that somehow everybody using WhatsApp is supposed to be a better solution than everybody using RCS, and it's kinda funny to see people acting superior about their entire communication system being on Meta products.

▲wolvoleo 21 hours ago | parent [-]

Well for me Google is even worse than meta.

But for us SMS/MMS is long dead anyway. It won't even occur to someone to use it. The only thing it's still used for is insecure 2FA and spam.

SMS also got a really bad name here due to high costs and lots of fraudulent pay-SMS services that the operators didn't do much against because it was a goldmine.

Also, RCS was invented by the carriers to re-insert themselves into messaging revenue. It failed at that but then was co-opted by Google for their purposes. It's not been able to shake the bad name though.

I don't feel superior about meta and I'd much rather use something like Signal if the network effect allowed it. But I do think Google and RCS are even more inferior. If not the same meaning there's no advantage. It would have to be a big privacy boost and also be resistant to the upcoming chatcontrol for me to be willing to move.

Personally I don't use Google accounts on my mobile anymore (even though it's android) but due to network effects I am still tied to WhatsApp and Instagram anyway.

Ps not everywhere in Europe WhatsApp is that big, the Nordics are more into Snapchat and the balkans are all on viber.

▲annzabelle 21 hours ago | parent [-]

We've had free unlimited SMS for much longer than the EU, so we never switched to WhatsApp in the first place because SMS was functionally free on every plan that had data. RCS wasn't the carriers reinserting themselves into messaging here (they were already dominant outside of iMessage, and it was not a profit center for them), it was them fixing major issues with how SMS/MMS chats worked.

Your carriers price gouging you into all consolidating on a Meta platform is not a good thing.

I don't really think this is your personal stance and I don't mean to be argumentative, but I frequently see Europeans on this site talking about how superior Europe is for never using SMS/MMS/RCS and only using WhatsApp, without realizing that that situation was caused in the first place by the misbehavior of European carriers.

▲wolvoleo 13 hours ago | parent [-]

Well SMS and MMS were also functionally deficient. No encryption, heavy compression on MMS images, 160 character limits on SMS.

The only reason it became usable in the US is because so many people use iMessage. So you consolidated on big tech too, just a different platform.

And when we moved to WhatsApp en masse, it was not a meta platform. The network effect was already there when it was taken over.

But you don't need to be a big tech to run a messaging platform. I hope a European one stands up. RCS I don't want though. I don't want involvement of my carrier (which don't have RCS servers here anyway) or Google in my messaging. That's not an improvement.