Remix.run Logo
▲ khaliostr 3 days ago

There's a bit of an open source Magic renaissance going on lately, which I find really cool.

Forge has been around forever, but we've managed to get it running in the browser via WASM with Manabrew [1]. I'm one of the maintainers, and we're mostly building it because we wanted a nicer way to play Commander with friends.

Meanwhile, Phase and Ironsmith are working on new engines in Rust, Gorge is building one in Go alongside a bot and cross-engine testing tools, and people are starting to collaborate across projects.

Magic is such a ridiculously difficult game to implement that I think it's pretty amazing how many people are tackling it in their spare time.

If you're into Magic and software engineering, come hang out with us. There's a lot going on and plenty of room for more people to get involved :)

[1] https://github.com/witchesofthehill/manabrew

▲neuwirth 3 days ago | parent | next [-]

This looks awesome. Will definitely check it out and see if there's anything from my little project here I can contribute!

▲khaliostr 3 days ago | parent [-]

Thanks! I actually came across Arcana not too long ago, so it's really nice to meet its author here. And bonus points for Rust

We started porting Forge to Rust ourselves, but quickly realised what we'd gotten ourselves into, so we went and built forge-wasm instead.

If you're curious, we've got a small engine spec that lets Manabrew work with different rules engines. Ironsmith (also Rust) already works, and we've got partial support for Phase.rs and Gorge. Would be fun to try Arcana too!

There's also a Discord where a bunch of us working on these engines hang out and compare notes. You should drop by sometime, I suspect we'd have quite a bit to talk about :)

▲algo_trader 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Have you had legal challenges?

Are you just crossing your fingers for now?

▲khaliostr 2 days ago | parent [-]

We've done our homework, at least as much as a small OSS project reasonably can :D

Forge and Cockatrice have both been around for a long time and have had to navigate legal concerns around card art and Wizards' trademarks. One approach has been to avoid distributing the artwork directly and let users fetch it separately from Scryfall. Forge itself is over 15 years old at this point.

We've taken a similar approach with Manabrew. We don't bundle card art or Wizards' trade dress, the project is entirely free and open source, and people can self-host it. We're also careful not to present it as an official Wizards product.

That doesn't mean there's zero legal risk, of course. But we're not simply crossing our fingers either.

▲shaolinspirit 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This looks amazing. I will definitely try it out

▲mtge 3 days ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]