Remix.run Logo
▲ imglorp a day ago

If you know the Dewey numbers of your interests, related stuff you might like is to the left and right of that point so it's not too bad to find related topics.

What really bugs me about libraries is fiction, knowing what you want, say Asimov. They might have it under Sci-fi, YA, mystery, or any one of a dozen special interest shelves like Robots or Future or whatever.

▲bluGill a day ago | parent | next [-]

Left and right works for closely related. However most books have options. Should "traditional native American wood carving" go with the history books, the native American culture books, or the wood carving books (the above is the obvious possibilities, but likely there are several more)

▲bradknowles 19 hours ago | parent [-]

Both Dewey Decimal and Library of Congress systems would have one and only one address for that book. So, that’s where it goes.

If you’re not using the card catalog system to look up books by title, author, or subject and you’re just going to a random section of the library, then you’re not likely to have much success. That is, unless you are very familiar with the catalog system in question, and you know in advance roughly where you should start looking.

But after 4.5 years working in that library and shelving books, I never got to know either of the systems so deeply that I no longer needed the card catalog system.

Sure, if you’re a bookstore, you can put a copy at each location and let people discover for themselves what is around certain areas of interest.

But that’s not how libraries are supposed to work. If you can’t comprehend the card catalog, or you can’t be bothered with it, then you should not be allowed in the front door.

▲sitkack a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Both systems are good for browsing a genre. In curation, one needs to do a higher dimensional join. Say for the history of America you might have a recipe book next to Japanese Internment.

▲bradknowles 19 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The same is true of LC. Both of those systems are organized by topic. Broad topics first, then more narrow topics later, as the numbers or letters get closer together.

They have different methods of organizing what topics go along with what other topics, but that’s about it.

What they don’t have is large signs above each section that say “Romance” or “Sci-Fi” or whatever, but functionally it’s the same. Similar books on similar topics are grouped together. Once you get close enough, it usually comes down to alpha by author.