Remix.run Logo
▲ seanieb 6 hours ago

This is a disaster. Matrix's encryption is a tire fire. They continually say they're going to fix it but it's still no where near the security and privacy needed for national security use-cases.

Their work to move to MLS seems to be abandoned. https://arewemlsyet.com/

I applaud the people working on Matrix, it worthy project, but I feel the E2EE issues are at a level close to negligence.

▲teekert 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I recently listened to a podcast addressing this (one of the hosts works on Matrix/Element), basically, the "Unable to decrypt message" is what almost any error ends in. Also, they recently tried to remove all these issues and managed a 10x reduction, another highly focused effort may reduce it another 10x. I believe this was on the Late Night Linux podcast [0].

In any case, I use Matrix for anything FOSDEM related and I have seen 1 of these errors over the last year, said user said they replied from within an Android notification fwiw.

I really enjoy Matrix/Element tbh.

[0] https://latenightlinux.com/

▲seanieb 6 hours ago | parent [-]

> basically, the "Unable to decrypt message" is what almost any error ends in

That's not the issue(s) I'm referring to. And typical of Matrix's lack of engagement with weaknesses and issues that have been raised several times. They continue to neglect the issues their protocol has.

This podcast goes into some of the details: https://securitycryptographywhatever.com/2022/11/02/Matrix-w...

However, I would be prepared for a "we fixed those issues" claim which really amounts to shallow fixes that move the issue elsewhere.

The proposal to move to MLS was accepted for a lot of reasons, reasons that have not, or cannot be addressed with their current protocol.

▲codedokode 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I wanted to see what are those issues but I do not want to read the whole transcript especially written white on black which strains the eyes so I had to search for the right place. Podcasts are an awful thing it seems.

▲teekert 5 hours ago | parent [-]

Recently there was some tech invented that could help with this...

▲publicmail 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

What are the issues? Are the messages E2E encrypted or not? Asking as a Matrix user.

▲upboundspiral 38 minutes ago | parent [-]

There is a linked research paper "Practically-exploitable Cryptographic Vulnerabilities in Matrix" released in 2023

https://nebuchadnezzar-megolm.github.io/static/paper.pdf

I don't know how much things have changed, but this is the paper's conclusion:

"We presented six attacks that together invalidated the fundamental security promises made by Matrix’ end-to-end encryption against a malicious server. In particular, the version of Matrix as implemented in Element and analysed here neither provided confidentiality nor authentication against such an attacker."

My weak understanding is that if you're using it just for internal use / between friends then it doesn't have as much effect - but in public rooms anyone with a server that joins can decrypt your messages.

I think Element is slowly (slowly) working on improving security.

https://matrix.org/blog/2025/11/exclude-insecure-devices/

▲ciefa 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Hi hi :)

For transparency: I work as a technical engineer for Element.

I'd love if people check out some of the talks that recently were held on the Matrix conf, so allow me to share some :D

How encryption works in Matrix: https://media.ccc.de/v/matrix-conference-2026-98869-how-encr...

New phone who dis: User verification using X.509 certificates: https://media.ccc.de/v/matrix-conference-2026-100422-new-pho...

▲JadedBlueEyes 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There's a lot of parallel work going on to improve encryption in Matrix, including MLS. That particular effort is paused, but there are various other efforts.

You also have to remember that this is a million times better than the status quo: Teams. Cleartext directly to the US.

▲seanieb 6 hours ago | parent [-]

From what I can see there's been no work on adding MLS for over a year.

> You also have to remember that this is a million times better than the status quo: Teams. Cleartext directly to the US.

I would agree with this, but it's also being proposed to replace things like Signal.

▲JadedBlueEyes 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I guess you're not as entwined with it as I am. Here's some outside signal:

https://cfp.2026.matrix.org/matrix-conference-2026/talk/G9XJ...

https://cfp.2026.matrix.org/matrix-conference-2026/talk/7GYB...

Re: Signal, there are more concerns than just encryption. For example: https://element.io/blog/how-element-protects-against-signalg...

▲seanieb 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Thank you. I was going on the information they published on https://arewemlsyet.com/

Having said that if they were upfront about the shortcomings of the current protocol, I doubt some agencies in Europe would have chosen Matrix. Then there’s the promise to add MLS at some point. My guess is that’s years away: in the Q&A of one of their talks, they said they don’t yet know how to make MLS work with a decentralized architecture.

▲Arathorn 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

My talk (https://cfp.2026.matrix.org/matrix-conference-2026/talk/7GYB...) concretely shows how you add MLS to Matrix in a decentralised manner. You could go to https://aurora-tachyon.netlify.app/ and play with it via DMLS right now if you so desired.

Yes, arewemlsyet.com is stale as it refers to a much earlier project to swap Olm/Megolm for MLS, which lost funding in 2023. But these days the work is progressing again, as per the linked talks. We'll update arewemlsyet.com to reflect that.

In terms of Matrix's encryption being a "disaster" - the only concrete problem I'm aware of is the fact that group membership is server-controlled, so that a malicious server could add a visible malicious user (not device) to a room by spoofing an invite. The MLS work and other projects is addressing that, but how big a problem this really is in practice depends on their threat model.

▲littlecranky67 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

What do they mean, they don't know how to make it work? White Noise (Nostr+MLS) made it work already, and it is open source.

▲subscribed 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Are there any _more concerns_ than clumsy user?

As of now you seem to suggest that lack of e2ee outweighs probable safety and security because there's little chance of inviting a third party to the chat.

▲nickez 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Why would anyone use Signal for corporate chat? I don't think Matrix replaces Signal.

▲goobatrooba 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

For the commission it's for now just a backup, main one is Teams. Shocking.

▲sroerick 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I heard that matrix shares metadata of all chats with any federated instance? Is that true?

Also, isn't it made by Israeli telecom guys? I mean I guess nobody can accuse them of not having read the room

▲Arathorn 41 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

> I heard that matrix shares metadata of all chats with any federated instance? Is that true?

No.

> Also, isn't it made by Israeli telecom guys?

No.

▲panick21_ 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Chats rooms are shared if they have a client in the room I believe.

And the team worked on telecom stuff for a brazilian company as far as I remember.

▲pandemic_region 5 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Pretty sure EC staff will not be allowed to use it for highly sensitive communication. You will not see von der Leyen use this. All the rest can just add to the transparency of governance that we all want right?

▲tyrabound 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]