Remix.run Logo
▲ stavros 37 minutes ago

Just because the house I'm selling is expensive, doesn't mean I'm not going to try and get a good price for it.

You should unionize and negotiate for better terms, no matter how good your terms are already. Your employer isn't going to negotiate for you against themselves.

▲logicchains 26 minutes ago | parent [-]

>You should unionize and negotiate for better terms, no matter how good your terms are already

A business only has a fixed amount of money it can spend on wages. Unionizing is not going to bring it up if you're already near the top of the pay scale for your role, and if it brings the wages of your lower-paid colleagues up then that means there'll be less left to pay those at the top so the wages of top earners will come down.

▲antihipocrat a minute ago | parent | next [-]

Profit is value generated by workers' time and effort that is being allocated elsewhere.

A business that has operating expenses equal to revenue is not withholding anything. One option available in this case is for workers to improve their productivity, no loss of jobs are necessary if there are market opportunities available. What better incentive is there for workers to improve their productivity than to share in the benefits of that improvement.

Also, a pay scale is a policy set by the business. Individual employees working at a level subject to scales like these have no influence on what these scales are, unions however spend a lot of time negotiating these scales with businesses. The C-suite captures a lot of value (CEOs now earn +300x more than the typical worker), this is a wage, and included operating expenses, that gap could come down quite a lot without impacting on the executive's lifestyle...

▲cowlevel 5 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

A business has a fixed amount of money it can spend in total. It has a team whose job is to minimise the percentage of it that's wages.

Unions can't create more money than the business actually has. Many unions have made this mistake and taken themselves down with the business. Many others haven't.

▲stavros 23 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If you aren't in a union, you weren't negotiating as well as you could have been, therefore you left money on the table. All a union does is level the playing field so workers can negotiate as one body, just like the company does.

▲ForHackernews 15 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

"near the top of the pay scale for your role" does not mean you are anywhere near the top of the pay scale for the organisation.

This is the madness of engineers making $200k thinking their interests are more aligned with the executives on $10,000,000 pa than the people mopping the floor for 40 grand.

Yes, absolutely you want the union to negotiate more money for lower-paid staff because that is YOU, buddy.