Remix.run Logo
▲ josephg 2 hours ago

Does anyone else find stuff like this weirdly soulless?

I was at a puppet head making workshop recently, and the facilitator passed around a 3d print of a puppet head designed by an LLM. I found my eyes glazed over it, even though I found some of the hand-sculpted clay heads utterly fascinating.

Generally, I want to consume much less LLM output than I do. I'm confused why people care about projects like this.

▲pan69 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

It somehow reminds me of playing MIDI music in the 90s.

▲kingkawn an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Bc the actual thing that we are enjoying and looking for in this work is not aesthetics as we have long believed but purely the sense of the presence of the creator. This stuff made by robotic calculations means nothing because it comes from nobody, so we learn nothing about being ourselves through the work of others from it. It has proven, at long last, that aesthetics mean nothing

▲A_D_E_P_T 33 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Aesthetics is about ratios -- relations between things and aspects of things -- and, applied to humans, genetic fitness. It's the sort of thing an AI can easily hack. That they're still not great at it speaks to a lack of focus; it's just not their priority.

Back in the day, there was this discussion about music. Some people prefer going to live concerts, where it's easy to get "a sense of the presence of the creator." We believed that this was an appreciation for musicianship, as opposed to aesthetics. Others prefer listening to music at home. I'd maintain that this is a purely aesthetic appreciation. And the day AI can generate genuinely good music is very near at hand, I think...

Thing is, though... Man... That "Whitepill" song is really something. The aesthetics don't trouble me. The song, which is mediocre at best, is unimportant. What troubles me is that it's more brazen than Soviet propaganda from the 1970s in its message and delivery.

If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome," they really haven't been paying attention. Totally clueless.

▲andersonpico 7 minutes ago | parent [-]

> Aesthetics is about ratios -- relations between things and aspects of things

only if you stopped reading in Aristotle.

> and, applied to humans, genetic fitness.

wtf?

> We believed that this was an appreciation for musicianship, as opposed to aesthetics.

there are other aspects to the aesthetic appreciation of a live show than purely the music (even if you simply consider that a live show has a visual element to it that can also have aesthetic attributes).

ultimately, trying to isolate aesthetic qualities both from each other and from the human experience doesn't seem like a fruitful pursuit.

> And the day AI can generate genuinely good music is very near at hand, I think...

nah

> If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome," they really haven't been paying attention. Totally clueless.

we agree here

▲pigpop 21 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Some people do. I'm one that doesn't. I honestly don't care who made a thing and I'd rather not know if it would interfere with my appreciation of it. So, I think nothing has been proven. People who are more interested in other people than in the things they create will always say aesthetics are meaningless and it's the artist that's important and vice versa for the rest of us.

▲Teever 31 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Have you considered that your perspective on these physical artifacts was biased because of what you were told about them?

If the facilitator told you afterwards that actually, the 3d print was designed by a human and the hand-sculpted ones were made by a machine how would that change how you feel about this?

And if they again told you that they tricked you and both of them were made by hand, or both made by a machine?

▲NordStreamYacht an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Uncanny valley.

▲freecodeio an hour ago | parent [-]

I don't think it's uncanny valley at all. I think it's the fact that we can literally not feel any empathy with the artist because there's no artist.

Which means somewhere out there, there's someone who's artistic enough that can create something abstract that would make you forget the process in which the creation was done. And make you feel the empathy, through an AI generated picture.

I've yet to see one myself, however.

▲ern 30 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I agree it's soulless, and the "wrote the wolf in grandma's gown a thousand years ago, run your Audit" is classic Claudish.

Given that the video is actually a commentary about LLMs and AI, I can look past all that though.

▲bombcar 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The question is do you find it soulless if you don’t know it was produced in a pasteurized prose factory?

▲javascriptfan69 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I imagine in the hands of someone who actually cared about the process and the end result, AI is probably a great force multiplier for artistic process.

Unfortunately, it seems that the majority of stuff like this is by people who don't want to learn art and just want to skip to having a thing that looks like art.

I think if you want to have good AI art you're going to have to convince artists to start use it.

▲bennyg an hour ago | parent [-]

I have a background in graphic design (BA from University of Alabama) and have been a professional software engineer for ~12 years since. I finally feel that models are good enough to start using like tools for illustration (not just image-gen).

Shameless plug: https://www.fathersnight.net

I wrote and "illustrated" this children's book, acting more like Warhol in The Factory [1], providing copious amounts of art and creative direction notes, building an editing platform for me to hand edit and to provide more nuanced guidance alongside edits for illustration tweaks. All prose was written by me, no LLM-assistance there.

I think we'll soon see how artists are transforming typical practices with LLMs once we get past the binary "AI art bad" phase.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Factory

▲sebmellen an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes. I really don’t care how it was produced, I have seen the rare AI-generated video that’s truly captivating. But it’s rare to see that because there’s so much slop in the background.

Seriously, WTF is this video supposed to be? There’s no edge to it, it’s not visually very interesting, and the story just doesn’t make sense… we have a data center with red riding hood and some wolf and some singing pigs talking about sand turning into chips. What?

▲jen729w 40 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Perhaps if it wasn't immediately obvious that it had, in fact, been produced in a pasteurised prose factory, then I might enjoy it.

But I see that page and it is obvious where it's come from, and my brain just rejects it.

▲plun9 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes.

▲jen729w 41 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

I can't even make myself read a single sentence. I see it, I know what it is, and my brain couldn't be less interested. I hit space a few times to scroll the page and then I'm out.