Remix.run Logo
▲ EvanAnderson 2 hours ago

I think enthusiast computing is dying. Home users will be able to buy packaged laptops and some desktop PCs, but I think the era of enthusiasts building "gaming rigs" and such is coming to an end. I think it's being ushered out by a feedback loop of high prices driving market contraction and, in turn, driving prices even higher as demand shrinks. Gaming will move to real-time streaming and there won't be a need or a market for GPUs and high performance CPUs in the enthusiast market.

Home computing, in the context of having a marginally-powerful computer or phone / tablet with minimal storage and RAM in the home, will continue just fine. Subscriptions for storage and applications are already becoming the norm, and with the skyrocketing cost of storage the market for large capacity storage targeted at enthusiast and home users will dry up, too.

The industry wants users to rent everything.

Storage rental is particular pernicious, to me, because being able to store your personally-created works in a manner that maintains confidentiality is to cornerstone of digital sovereignty. Being forced to store your data in systems that will use your data for model training is definitely desired by the industry. If they can con users into renting that storage and giving up their data to model training so much the better.

▲webstrand an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I've never lived anywhere with low enough connection latency to accommodate real-time streaming of an action game, and my bare packet latency is 20ms to the nearest data-center (that I know of and can ping anyway). Add any latency in the input processing of the game, time to encode/transfer/decode the frame, and any local input latency on the client and you’re easily looking at an extra 50-100ms over playing locally, which is well into the range people can actually feel in anything twitchy. Turn-based or slower games would probably be fine, but I don’t see shooters or fighting games moving to streaming for anyone who doesn’t happen to live next door to a data center.

There might be some unexploited latency-masking tricks in client-side cursors and client-side reprojection (the timewarp trick some VR uses to rotate the camera without receiving a new frame), but I suspect the legacy internet connectivity of rural and suburban homes in america will be a serious barrier to widespread adoption of real-time streaming. If local hardware gets priced out of reach, it could rather mean the end of gaming as a widely accessible hobby instead of a switch to real-time streaming?

▲lmz an hour ago | parent [-]

Not everything has to be high res 3D requiring the newest GPUs. For twitchy games I guess they'll just stay low quality enough to be able to run on customer local devices.

▲Exmoor an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I think the era of enthusiasts building "gaming rigs" and such is coming to an end.

I've been hearing this for over two decades and yet gaming desktops are more mainstream than ever. Certainly the current market is negatively impacting pricing and availability, but those same factors are also pushing their competition just as hard. I'm not even sure cloud streamed games was a profitable idea when prices were sane, but it certainly isn't now.

▲cyberrock 17 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I think gaming desktops are mainstream but have a longer lifespan now, as AM4 and RTX10xx hardware is perfectly fine for most gamers who play Big Walk or Queen's Domain rather than 8k 240fps Forza. In contrast when I bought a $600 GPU in 2013 (outrageous price back then) it wouldn't be able to handle a medium quality 1080p game in 3 years. So I think both assessments are right: an enthusiast top end rig is more expensive but most gamers simply need less top end rigs every year.

▲EvanAnderson an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

I built my first PC in '94. The market today feels so much different than it ever has. We had some RAM and disk crunches in the past (and disk prices never really recovered from the Thai floods), but this market feels so different. Prices continue to spiral out of control.

On the business side I've got Customers looking to replace servers purchased in 2020 and 2021 and they're not able to get anything reasonably similar for less than 4X what they paid for the old machines. They're turning, sometimes grudgingly, to renting storage and compute. The prices for off-lease "enterprise" gear are skyrocketing, too. There's no respite.

▲Aurornis 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> I think it's being ushered out by a feedback loop of high prices driving market contraction and, in turn, driving prices even higher as demand shrinks.

Shrinking demand makes prices go down, not up.

Demand for gaming and consumer gear is higher than ever. Gaming GPUs were expensive before the AI boom. Remember when everyone was shocked that the 4090 was $1500 or the 5090 was $2000, but they were sold out anyway? Remember the extreme competition for 30 series GPUs and scalping before that?

I have yet to hear a good explanation for these beliefs that consumer PCs and gaming are going away, because they’re all driven by incorrect economic ideas (like shrinking demand raising prices) or fear imported from some other ideas, while ignoring the ever expanding market for gaming and consumer PC gear

▲Exmoor an hour ago | parent | next [-]

> Shrinking demand makes prices go down, not up.

In a simple supply/demand scenario, yes, but when shrinking demand causes manufacturers to spread costs across a smaller market it can lead to higher prices. A good example is hard disk drives. As the market moved to SSDs the constant cost decreases that had been reliable for decades started stabilizing or even rising. I paid $15/TB for 8TB drives in 2017 and that continued to be a good price for new drives until the AI boom drove costs way up recently. Similar trends have happened with lots of other products as they moved from mainstream to niche.

▲Aurornis an hour ago | parent [-]

> I paid $15/TB for 8TB drives in 2017 and that continued to be a good price for new drives until the AI boom drove costs way up recently.

So prices were low when demand was low, then they increased when demand increased?

For commodity items it’s expected to have some fluctuations, especially when prices are bottomed out and manufacturers are weighing the costs of competition in a cutthroat market with shrinking demand. However you don’t really escape the laws of supply and demand. That’s why you saw prices swing hard upward when demand increased, not when demand was the lowest.

▲Arainach 29 minutes ago | parent [-]

It's not a simple curve. There has to be enough demand for any theoretical market effects to take place.

If there isn't enough demand for something for multiple companies to find it worth building a factory and producing at industrial scale (and vendors to bother stocking, etc.), then you're faced with either monopoly pricing from the single vendor who sticks around or the dramatically higher cost of other manufacturing methods.

▲EvanAnderson an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

My thesis is shrinking demand will cause specialty manufacturing lines to be used for more profitable hardware, driving down the supply. Why make enthusiast hardware when hyper-scalers need storage, RAM, and compute to rent to end users?

▲glimshe 29 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What will prevent hobbyists from buying inexpensive but powerful Asian chips that can run Linux? Worry not, hobby computing is alive and well and will remain so.

▲csh0 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Is this true? I mean some of this biggest and most popular games like CS2 and DOTA are latency and refresh rate sensitive.

Genuinely asking I’m not sure of the state of the art here. I tried out GeForce now a couple years ago and it was fine for couch co-op platformers but I could never imagine using such a delivery method for an online FPS game.

▲joshribakoff an hour ago | parent [-]

No one can be certain anymore than anyone can time the market with certainty. Perhaps both modalities evolve independently, we went from mainframes to PCs, perhaps the cycle could repeat.

▲Forgeties79 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

>real-time streaming

Are we anywhere near that? GeForce Now is solid and xcloud surprisingly has excellent latency (for me), but it’s still there. FPS’s are off the table, not even in a snobby way. You can feel the delay it’s just too severe. The only shooters I’ve ever ever been able to successfully do are slower third person ones and even that’s dicey unless they have other mechanics you can lean on (Mass effect for instance).

I think people get snobby about frame rates but latency is a real thing and there is a threshold you have to cross or everyone notices it, and I’m not sure anyone’s capable of crossing it

▲odo1242 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Yea, see above. I think mobile gaming has been going far better than cloud gaming, in that respect.

▲EvanAnderson 2 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm sure you're right. I'm not gamer, mobile or otherwise, but I can definitely see walled-garden mobile devices taking over for the "gaming rig" in a lot of cases.

▲Forgeties79 an hour ago | parent [-]

I am what people would consider a “serious gamer” and I don’t have the natural revulsion to Mobile gaming that my peers do. However, it’s a narrower field than you would think.

▲EvanAnderson 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Are we anywhere near that?

> ... latency is a real thing ...

When enough players don't know any different the latency won't be an issue. It'll be the norm, just like using the molasses-slow UI on today's PC is considered normal.

Play a real Atari 2600 on a CRT TV. You'll be amazed at the fluid responsiveness of the system. Use an Apple II or a Commodore 64 and you'll be amazed at the lack of input latency.

We've gotten used to crap latency on our PCs. Gamers will get used to it in games too-- especially if it obviates a four-figure hardware purchase and paying for the privilege of "buying" games you don't own and can't keep anyway.

▲viklove 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> It'll be the norm

It's obvious you've never played any shooter game. It can't be the norm, because the game becomes completely fucking unplayable with even 50-100ms of input lag.

▲DiskoHexyl an hour ago | parent [-]

Meanwhile GTA 6 has a total input lag north of 150ms. In ps3/xbox360 times it wasn’t out of the ordinary to see 100-200ms (killzone 2 was on a higher end, for example).

Total input lag (a time between a button press and an animation showing on your screen) isn’t just 1000ms/fps, although they do correlate.

Outside of the competitive FPS scene, most people using a gamepad can do just fine with extra 50ms of latency. Some genres hold better, some are worse (mouse lag in RTS games feels pretty shit, but no one plays these anymore).

Cloud gaming sucks for other reasons- it’s expensive, it’s fragmented (you can’t just play all of your pc library in geforce now), there are no mods, no real ownership and, more importantly, edge devices like smartphones becoming powerful enough to satiate the gaming appetites of the casual crowd, while the hardcore want all of these features that the cloud lacks. It’s neither here nor there

▲strken 15 minutes ago | parent [-]

It sucks because of the input lag (for me). Probably the worst part (for me) is that 100ms of network latency is effectively random within a band of 50ms or so, which makes it difficult to compensate for and stops you building muscle memory as easily.

▲kulahan 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Consoles theoretically cover this need.

▲gerdesj an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Bollocks!

Components are still available to buy, take a look at any marketplace. Yes, components are rather expensive these days, especially RAM, but perhaps I should remind you that in the '90s I paid something like £30 per megabyte. Then again I can now buy a ESP32S3 for a couple of quid.

Anyway, its horses for courses. With a small amount of imagination you do not have to rent anything.

You are completely wrong about storage costs which are now nearly negligible compared to RAM.

I still have my Commodore 64, which now sports a USB interface. I also play games on my phone and that is still working OK, without a sub. My Clash of Clans Town Hall is level 17.

How much more "enthusiast" do you need from anyone who really couldn't give a shit about gaming?

▲EvanAnderson an hour ago | parent [-]

> You are completely wrong about storage costs ...

That's not what I'm seeing in the pricing trends: https://pcpartpicker.com/trends/price/internal-hard-drive/

Every tracked storage device there has trended up dramatically over the last year. I see the same trends on other price-tracking sites, too.

▲raincole an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's... so funny. One of the most debated topic among gamers is whether 180hz monitor makes any difference or it's just a placebo effect, and in the meanwhile non gamer are like:

> Gaming will move to real-time streaming

▲viklove 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Gaming will move to real-time streaming

Non-gamers will try pitching this over and over again, without ever learning from their past mistakes.

Streaming doesn't work for gaming. Any gamer can easily feel even just 50ms of latency in the form of input lag, and it makes the controls feel terrible. Gamers won't accept worse game feel -- they want better games, not worse ones.

How many countless game streaming platforms have to fail before you guys realize it will never work?

▲ an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲NooneAtAll5 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

demand doesn't shrink - it moves into cheaper segment

the main problem is not existence of cheaper options - but lack of advertizement

there are 20$ gpus, ffs, nobody is simply aware of them

▲ 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲ 2 hours ago | parent [-]
[deleted]