Remix.run Logo
▲ this_user an hour ago

Personal assistants are like the metaverse: an idea that tech people think sounds cool, but is completely useless for any practical purposes.

Most people simply are not so busy that they need someone to manage their calendar. And if you use these things to shop for you, I can virtually guarantee that you will be paying way too much, because vendors are gaming your gaming.

▲johnnyo 21 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Here’s a specific use case I’ve successfully used an agent like this for.

I booked a family trip. The tickets are refundable up to 30 days out, which means if the price drops between now and then, I can get the lower price, but only if:

1. I notice the price has dropped

2. I call and get the lower price

In the past this was hit or miss. If I remembered and happened to check, I might get lucky. Now my AI agent is checking every day between now and the deadline. It already saved me $250.

▲asdev 11 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

this is really the only useful thing i've seen. cron as a service

▲jsemrau 10 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Would you pay an agent for this the whole year?

▲singpolyma3 9 minutes ago | parent [-]

Why would you need to pay?

▲ 8 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]
[deleted]
▲wolvoleo 15 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Hmm I think it is really nice to wade through things like group chats that I don't have time for.

▲darth_avocado 11 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

> group chats that I don't have time for

That’s what the button is for. Or the leave button.

▲ifh-hn 14 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Why you in them then?

▲asdev 12 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

you should rethink everything if you don't want to catch up on messages from real people in your life

▲Gigachad 2 minutes ago | parent [-]

Claude, read this message from grandma and send a relevant reply.

▲sixhobbits 21 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I must live in some kind of metaverse; I'm still using a homegrown agent set up with telegram/whatsapp/email/command line and it does just about everything for me now, a few examples from this week

- patched my linux servers for the nginx vuln that dropped

- replied to my accountant with some invoices they needed

- took over annoying conversations with service providers, got a certificate of compliance I had been waiting for for weeks from one, and deflected multiple messages and voice notes a day about a taxi booking for next month he seemed to think was wroth messaging me every few hour about because he hadn't been paid yet

- reviewed some contracts and found several bad typos and wrong dates and fixed them

- did all kinds of odd research jobs in things I was curious about or needed information about like whether a black friday deal I was looking at was real or just a fake discount, put together a report on some tweet saying that the EU was sanctioning 12 journalists with a balanced take on why they were sanctioned, and prepared a GDPR request for my optometrist who is refusing to share my prescription with me because of some kind of weird company policy where they will only share that information if I go in person

I'm pretty sure the commercial agents for people who want it to 'just work' and don't want to set up a VPS with various coding agent subscriptions, and have have it engineer something with pi-durable etc, will mean that everyone is interacting with the world like this in the next 3-6 months.

▲Gigachad 3 minutes ago | parent [-]

It's still far too dangerous at this point. I've been seeing so many instances of people giving ai agents access to their communications platform only for it to do insane things like arrange a facebook marketplace meetup without confirming with the account owner and lying about the owner being there. As well as a recent one where someone asked it to organize an office move only to find it had been spamming all the contractors with stupid questions until the contractors refused to do business with them.

▲0xbadcafebee 5 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

[delayed]

▲Danox 8 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

AI Personal assistant (ie.. Google secret agent) job is to report back to home base

▲frodowtf2 34 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Where do you live that people are "not that busy"?

▲pavel_lishin 21 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I'd consider myself fairly busy, but the tasks I'm busy with are simply not things that an AI assistant can help me with.

Can it sell some extra stuff for me on Facebook? This would involve taking photos of it, listing it, negotiating with people, scheduling when they would come by, talking to them when they arrive, and then handing them the thing. It can't just do part of it - the listing & messaging people isn't the hard part, and that's literally the only part it can do. (It can't schedule pick-ups, because it will not know what specific times I am available, because my time is not organized in such a way that I can commit it to a calendar.)

Can it mail things for me? I have things I have to pack and mail out to two friends. I don't need it to order stamps for me or print labels; I need it to package things into boxes, with padding because some of it is fragile, and then actually mail it off.

Can it take my grandmother to the hematologist? Can it take my child to karate? Can it make dinner? Can it take notes of last night's D&D session? Can it make sure, nightly, that my child has done her homework, check it for correctness, initial what needs to be initialed, and make sure my child's chores are done?

About the only thing it might be able to do is my shopping, if I take a picture of my shopping list, and have the local grocery store deliver it. Assuming it doesn't mis-read the list, assuming the physical shopper doesn't put in a wild substitution when they can't find the whole garlic. And then it can't put the groceries away for me, or tell me when they're on my porch.

▲johnnyo 15 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

> Can it take notes of last night's D&D session?

Summarizing meeting notes is one of the most common AI use cases, so I definitely think that would be an easy one.

▲pavel_lishin 9 minutes ago | parent [-]

Sure, as long as it can parse multiple people speaking at once, sometimes about different things. As long as it understands the context of the campaign thus far. As long as it can parse fake names. As long as it also has video of the table, I guess, for when we're doing combat on a grid, and also understands which minis represent which PCs and NPCs, and infers what's going on when we're not explicitly talking about what we're doing.

▲Melatonic 4 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Same here

Call me when AI can do my damn laundry

▲SoftTalker 20 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Sure, a few people are that busy. They already have personal assistants. Nobody else really needs this, and it can only do tasks that you'd do online. It's a lure to feed more of your personal data to Google.

▲darth_avocado 9 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Most of the people have plenty of time at their hands unless of course you consider scrolling TikTok/Reels is being busy.

▲grvdrm 19 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

This is the “I’m on top of my shit so I don’t need that” attitude - easy to have when your pile isn’t large.

Now add kids, logistics, activities. The assistants are enormously helpful in coordinating multiple calendars.