Remix.run Logo
▲ didgetmaster an hour ago

The author is clearly against AI models that are trained on data produced by people without their consent. Yet the whole free software movement is built on the notion that proprietary software is unethical and any attempts to protect it (and other content like movies and music) using DRM or other mechanisms are wrong.

Does anyone else see this as a contradiction?

▲fpaq an hour ago | parent | next [-]

> [...] trained on data produced by people without their consent. Yet the whole free software movement is built on [...]

consent. The whole free software movement is built on consent. For the most part, that consent is conditional - like requiring that you pay it forward (GPL), or at least mention who the author is (MIT).

▲interroboink an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think I see what you're saying, but no, I don't think it's a contradiction.

I think the worry from the "free software movement" side is that someone consentually shares some code, then a company takes it, profits from it, but "locks it down" so their additions are not likewise shared. So basically the company is freeloading on what others produced, taking but not giving back — that's what people frown upon.

Likewise, training on data without people's consent is also a type of freeloading, and is frowned upon in a similar fashion. Note that this happens with humans, too: if an artist takes too-direct "inspiration" from another without getting credit, they are called out.

I suppose there are some more absolutist stances, like "abolish copyright" (rather than the milder "abolish freeloading" described above) which would argue against DRM, etc. of any kind, full stop. And, if such a world ever came to pass, and those people felt that their data (artwork, code, etc) should not be available for AI training, that would perhaps be a contradiction, yes.

▲mod50ack an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Well, it's not necessarily a contradiction, as the copyright protection and licensing aspects are separate. They don't support what they see as copyright infringement, but they also don't think that copy-protection schemes are good for the user, since they also prevent legitimate uses under the law. Also note that the position of the FSF et al. is that there's no reason that art (I mean this in the traditional sense of art: books, music, movies, etc.) can't be proprietary, but that programs are different.

▲whartung an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Not necessarily, becase the FSM is not about "freeing" software. Its about "free" software. They're not cracking DRM. They're not trying to pirate other software.

Rather they're arguing that software should be free, they work on free software, and then promote their free software over non-free software.

Basically, everyone involved in the FSM is consenting.

With AI IP scraping, that's not so much necessarily the case.