Remix.run Logo
▲ Animats 2 hours ago

Until Colt's revolver after 1830, few of those weapons were suitable for routine carry. When you were going off to fight, you got your weapon ready, which with flintlocks involved putting in fresh powder. Early pistols didn't stay safely ready for use. So pistols were offensive weapons.

Concealed carry, the early years: For loading a Philadelphia Deringer, one would typically fire a couple of percussion caps on the handgun, to dry out any residual moisture contained in the tube or at the base of the barrel, to prevent a subsequent misfire. One would then remove the remains of the last fired percussion cap and place the handgun on its half-cock notch, pour 15 to 25 grains (0.97 to 1.6 g) of black powder down the barrel, followed by ramming a patched lead ball down onto the powder, being very careful to leave no air gap between the patched ball and the powder, to prevent the handgun from exploding when used. ... A new percussion cap would then be placed on the tube (nipple), and the gun was then loaded and ready to fire.[1]

Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak. Handgun technology wasn't ready in 1789.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derringer

▲AngryData 36 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

But at the same time the people who wrote the constitution knew full well repeating firearms were coming at some point and didn't think it made enough difference to change anything or note anything about it. They saw and were offered to buy such firearms both for personal and military use and had personally saw many other firearm improvements and reduction in costs throughout their life.

▲jghn 19 minutes ago | parent [-]

I'm gonna go out on on a limb and suggest they weren't picturing anything like modern weaponry. And that if someone were to smuggle a minigun through a Time Machine, they'd think it was witchcraft

▲arcanemachiner 6 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I'm gonna go out on a limb and suggest they wanted people to overthrow their government if it became tyrannical.

▲bryanrasmussen 6 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

well, I'm gonna go out on a limb and suggest the most well known signatories to the Constitution would not have thought it was witchcraft, there may be some backward fellow in their ranks that might be so inclined, but as a general rule no, you're off by a few hundred years.

▲ericmay an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak. Handgun technology wasn't ready in 1789.

People routinely carried and possessed other guns though so I'm not sure that's a good argument. At best you are arguing against concealed carry but there is no constitutional amendment addressing concealed carry.

If you want to argue that the 2nd Amendment only talks about what would mostly be considered a professional or semi-professional military then you have to revert back to 10th Amendment since the 2nd Amendment doesn't ban citizens from owning firearms it just grants the right to have a militia, ergo each state unless another constitutional amendment happens at the federal level can set forth (or not if they don't want to regulate it) the right for individual citizens to own firearms. The worst case is you get some states banning it, and other states having a lot more lax laws, something more akin to the roll back of Roe V Wade. Anti-gun rights activists should be careful that they don't disrupt the status quo less they find even fewer restrictions, as anti-abortion activists discovered when states began enshrining the right to an abortion in their own state constitutions.

It doesn't matter anyway because we as a society for good reasons decided that we wanted folks to be able to carry a handgun concealed or to otherwise own and carry firearms. That's all we really need - we just say we want to do something and then we get to do it.

▲Forgeties79 an hour ago | parent [-]

While I disagree with a lot of your argument I think a lot of it has merit. This part though I’m stuck on

> as anti-abortion activists discovered when states began enshrining the right to an abortion in their own state constitutions.

I’m not sure I see the through line between states enshrining a woman’s right to choose and the overturning of Roe v. Wade. That was a half century project that was plowing ahead no matter what. I think states putting their own protections in place was very prudent

▲ericmay an hour ago | parent [-]

The way I was attempting to link it was that there could be a similar and (according to anti-abortion activists) in some ways disastrous result where they basically said well it's not up to the federal government, and so (much to my happiness) many states went ahead and said oh it's up to us? Fine we're going to put it to a public vote and allow access and put that in the Constitution. And oh by the way, we may make it even less restrictive than it was under Roe V Wade.

Similarly my point was that if anti-gun activists were to in some way succeed in having the 2nd Amendment interpreted as (and I understand their argument though I disagree with the results) only applying to a militia, you'd probably wind up in a similar situation where states go and put it up to a vote and then they allow for firearms in each state constitution (not all of course) and they may even expand that right. Because hey, 10th Amendment. If it's not a power given to the federal government it is given to the states.

In other words, Roe v Wade and the current interpretation of the 2nd Amendment aren't perfect and there are problems to be solved, but you might let the cat out of the bag so to speak like the anti-abortion activists discovered and wind up with a worse situation than you started with (from those various perspectives) because it seems quite clear to me, and of course I'm just a random person, that there is no constitutional amendment banning firearms so by default excluding any sort of trigger laws (no pun intended) you'd all of a sudden have guns completely legal everywhere and without restriction until constitutional amendments later on restricted them. There could be some roughness around the edges like, bringing a gun to a bar and drinking or something, but just more broadly I could see that play out. So it's a be careful what you wish for scenario, in my view.

▲saila 41 minutes ago | parent [-]

The vast majority of states already have a right to bear arms written into their state constitutions. Many of them are much clearer than the 2nd Amendment. Take Oregon's, for example:

> The people shall have the right to bear arms for the defence of themselves, and the State, but the Military shall be kept in strict subordination to the civil power.

No arguments about a well-regulated militia to be had there.

If the 2nd Amendment was reinterpreted to apply only to militias, the state constitutions and their laws would still be applicable as would federal law, given that there's nothing else in the Constitution about it one way or the other.

▲ericmay 28 minutes ago | parent [-]

That’s my point - sorry if I didn’t make that clear. Similarly when Roe V Wade was struck down trigger laws and constitutional amendments at the state level became law.

So with respect to concealed carry, going back to the OP, it doesn’t really matter whether or not handguns were “ready” in 1789. Further the 2nd Amendment itself probably doesn’t matter because if it were to be reinterpreted you’d have to then revert to individual state constitutions which in many (most?) cases allow for civilians to own firearms and thus can also decide whether concealed carry is ok or not.

▲TacticalCoder 26 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

> Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak.

So the 4th amendment that says this:

"... secure in their persons, houses, papers, ..."

doesn't concern digital information because the notion of information stored digitally and not in paper wasn't envisioned by the Constitution?