Remix.run Logo
▲ atestu 3 hours ago

They highlight some examples of alleged misbehavior on the /about page but they don't really sound worthy of the scale of this website to me...?

> In Colombia, for example, the bank’s own internal investigation showed that in 2019 it had processed thousands of transactions for companies linked to the adult entertainment business. The money had been sent to women in Colombia through suspicious paths without the bank reporting most transactions to authorities..

So they failed to report some payments that went to porn stars? okay?

> Again and again, internal documents suggest that warnings from the bank’s own experts gave way to commercial interests. This applies in particular to the bank’s Russia business. After Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, numerous bank clients almost immediately ended up on sanctions lists — the same clients who had been coveted by the bank for years.

So they had clients in Russia before the invasion... again what is the problem here?

> The documents show Deutsche Bank assisted numerous clients in tax minimisation, including the Siemens corporation. In that case, the then-head of wealth management at Deutsche Bank noted concerns in 2015 about potential adverse media headlines that could arise about banks helping companies dodge their tax obligations. Nevertheless, Deutsche Bank continued; according to internal bank calculations, the German treasury would lose up to 30 million euros per year due to the tax-saving model it promoted.

Isn't it expected that they would help their clients "minimize" their taxes? Isn't that what all accountants do? Note that it doesn't say "evade" but "minimize"

Maybe there's more to it or I'm missing it entirely but none of it sounds groundbreaking to me. Maybe I'm just numb to it.

▲rmah 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I agree. I don't really like DB much, but these seem like non-issues to me. The porn business is a bit distasteful, IMO, but I don't think they should be denied banking services. Many nations have unsavory governments, but if they're not under sanction, why should a major bank not do business there, especially when their own host nation's gov is doing so? And doesn't everyone try to minimize their taxes? As long as you stay on the right side of the law, I don't see the problem.

I dug into some of the articles in "The Stories" section and found similar conduct. Long story short, they did business with someone who later got accused or investigated for something bad. Since when should a bank close out customer accounts before a criminal conviction or government order to that effect?

It's like the authors think banks (or maybe just DB in particular?) should have a crystal ball that tells them who will later be found wanting.

All that said, I vaguely recall that DB has been involved in criminal activities in the past so they certainly aren't an angelic player. And it wouldn't surprise me if some people within the firm have broken laws. If they break rules or regulations, they should be punished harshly to discourage future rule/law breaking. But honestly, the tone of the website (who's existence itself is sorta odd) seems... well... highly biased and weird.

▲avidruntime 40 minutes ago | parent [-]

> I dug into some of the articles in "The Stories" section and found similar conduct. Long story short, they did business with someone who later got accused or investigated for something bad. Since when should a bank close out customer accounts before a criminal conviction or government order to that effect?

This is not an accurate summary of the scope of reporting. Simply reading the article title + subheaders available on the landing page of the site reveals that.

> It's like the authors think banks (or maybe just DB in particular?) should have a crystal ball that tells them who will later be found wanting.

Which of the linked article(s) in TFA are guilty of this? Please link it!

▲wins32767 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There are a lot of stories that boil down to journalists not understanding how businesses work or run and writing standard practices as sensationally as possible.

▲estearum 2 hours ago | parent [-]

So why did the bank's own internal watchdogs flag much of this behavior?

▲rmah 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

All large banks have such risk/compliance groups. They generally behave like highly risk-averse lawyers, i.e. they will issue warnings about many things that are perfectly legal. I've seen it happen even to small businesses. A friend of mine imported electronics from China to customize and resell to US businesses (i.e. not retail). His small firm was flagged because of "strange foreign transactions" maybe 10 years ago. He said no one at the bank could tell him what was strange about them. As far as I know, he never did anything wrong.

▲estearum 2 hours ago | parent [-]

"Legality" isn't the line being discussed nor the one that compliance groups exclusively focus on.

The comment above was claiming people "don't know how businesses work," but presumably the internal compliance groups and e.g. the head of wealth management do, and they were raising concerns too (even if those concerns fell short of clear "we will be breaking the law if we do this.")

▲blfr 35 minutes ago | parent [-]

Only a sliver of a company usually knows how/why their business works and rarely are these people in internal compliance groups or anywhere outside of the executive suite, sales, and operations. Even within these, it's rarely most people.

Sometimes a smart lawyer, but one who deals with clients, or a financial controller know but this is strictly due to their individual curiosity and intelligence.

▲wins32767 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The incentives for internal watchdogs are to flag anything remotely risky. That doesn't mean it's a bad decision to go through with it. The false positive rate is quite high so there is a discussion and then the really bad stuff generally gets stopped after a meeting and the not so bad stuff goes through. But you can look after the fact and find emails that maybe didn't have the full context of the discussions or the record of an accepted risk.

▲estearum an hour ago | parent [-]

I didn't say it was a bad decision to go through with it. I'm saying that it's unfair to say this is a case of journalists not knowing how businesses work when in reality the business's own processes raised the concerns that journalists are raising now.

▲wins32767 an hour ago | parent [-]

Why do you think it's notable or important that watchdog groups raised it? What's the rate of raised issues that are ignored or unsupported? How do you know the watchdog group is effective at highlighting real risks instead of justifying their position with lots of unimportant raised flags? Wouldn't it be good journalism to give all that context rather than pick out the few most sensational areas where there was a hot button issue that had a risk raised with it?

▲hrncn 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Because their job is to flag everything within reach? Large companies have lots of people that are getting paid to worry, so business decisions can note these concerns and ignore them, if appropriate. Just like big tech getting caught doing some nasty things all the time, the fine is the cost of doing business.

▲atestu 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Just looking at the examples they put forward on the /about page:

> then-head of wealth management at Deutsche Bank noted concerns in 2015 about potential adverse media headlines that could arise about banks helping companies dodge their tax obligations

"adverse media headlines that could arise" doesn't sound like it was flagged for potential illegal or even unethical practice. They just thought it might lead to bad press (which it did! ha).

▲estearum 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Sure, the claim above wasn't "people are making up crimes," it was "journalists don't understand how businesses work."

Does also the head of wealth management not understand how their business works?

▲tokai 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

>So they had clients in Russia before the invasion... again what is the problem here?

Depends on who. The sanctions on russia and russian officials started much earlier than the '22 full invasion.

https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2014/0...

▲avidruntime an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

You can get a far more accurate summary of the scale and scope of the reporting by reading through the subheadings for each story. I've posted them here, in the order that they appear on the site:

1. The Inside Deutsche Bank files span some of the bank’s most sensitive functions and activities: anti-financial crime, sanctions monitoring, internal auditing and the units responsible for deciding whether risky clients stay or go.

2. Leaked documents reveal how dealings with royal dynasty blurred traditional boundaries between investor, client and counterparty

3. More than a decade after Jho Low remains elusive a decade after implicated in the world's largest kleptocracy case. Among his enablers was Deutsche Bank, which facilitated at least 24 transactions totalling €172.98 million linked to Low.

4. Documents in the Inside Deutsche Bank leak reveal Deutsche Bank’s role in supplying weapons now used against civilians in Palestine.

5. One of Hungary’s largest banks allegedly platformed a multi-billion-euro money-laundering scheme linked to a Russian oligarch. Deutsche Bank, which processed many of its payments, struggled to curb the wrongdoing.

6. The Inside Deutsche Bank leak reveals the bank's closeness to the war industry, and how it financed arms supplies to "high-risk" or conflict-ridden countries, violating its own internal policies.

7. Deutsche Bank financed blacklisted operations involving Spanish companies under investigation for corruption.

8. “As you know we have a large Russian Oligarchs client population,” an analyst wrote as the bank braced for sanctions against wealthy clients.

9. Deutsche Bank documents connect Trump-owned companies to laundromat schemes.

10. "Crooks don’t improve miraculously as they get older", said Deutsche bank executive about André Esteves, owner of BTG Pactual, the largest investment bank in Latin America.

11. Deutsche Bank leak shows suspicious Epstein payments that double previously known figure.

12. Deutsche Bank secured an investment portfolio worth hundreds of millions of dollars linked to Saudi Prince Mohammed bin Nayef and helped establish offshore corporate structures to manage it.

The discussion of how much there there is there is still open, but I think the reporting there is more than just payments to porn stars, Russian clients before the Ru-Uk war, and tax shelters.

▲atestu an hour ago | parent [-]

Thank you, you're right! That's a lot...

▲avidruntime an hour ago | parent [-]

NP! Consider editing your initial comment to reflect the revelation as to not dissuade would be readers who might mistake your comment as representative of the scope of the reporting :)