Remix.run Logo
▲ jillesvangurp 21 minutes ago

Peer review will need to evolve; but that isn't necessarily a bad thing. The issue is not so much AI but people wielding it taking responsibility for how they wield it. Scientific reputation is tied to what you publish and where you publish it and how you conduct yourself doing so. And peer review is an important part of the process.

So, if you are say flooding a lot of channels with low quality slop that shouldn't be great for your reputation. And if your publication publishes a lot of slop, that should discourage scientists from risking their reputation by submitting articles. Peer review works both ways. If filters out low quality articles from high quality publications. And it makes authors of high quality articles prefer publications that have good reputations and good peer review. I take it as a given that people on both sides are going to be using AI. It's how they do that, that matters.