Remix.run Logo
▲ FabCH an hour ago

I am an occasional reviewer.

Peer review has been dying for a long time.

IMHO the solution was simple before AI and it is simple with AI:

Double-blind review, but after the submission process both the article and the reviews are made public, with full attribution.

▲pedro_caetano an hour ago | parent | next [-]

The issue with double blind reviews is that it really depends on the problem domain.

In many areas, the pool of people who could have written a paper on a given topic and the pool of people who are subject matter experts, capable of reviewing a paper on said topic, are often very small and easily deduced.

But I agree that post-disclosure would add more of a skin in the game dynamics for reviewers.

▲apwheele an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

IMO the solution is to just post pre-prints and be done with it. The market will naturally select on what is useful/important/correct.

(Totally open to everything public, I sign my peer reviews, but I don't see much point in people reading my peer reviews over just reading the paper themselves!)

▲suddenlybananas an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Yeah cause openreview fixed allll the problems of publishing in ML or NLP.