Remix.run Logo
▲ hackermailman 2 hours ago

Conferences are now capping authors to a maximum of 8 papers which of course screws up university departments where everyone adds their name. This ETH professor says there should be a deposit paid to avoid AI spam https://www.linkedin.com/posts/omutlu_international-symposiu...

Same professor was rejected twice by peer review for what later became landmark papers one of which even got some Intel industry award. He did not change the paper and merely resubmitted that's how broken peer review already is.

▲bennettnate5 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

> which of course screws up university departments where everyone adds their name

Good. This practice is academic dishonesty and muddies the water terribly when it comes to evaluating a researcher's productivity and impact.

▲abirch an hour ago | parent [-]

This publication had 140 authors: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aed8713

▲shawsa7 20 minutes ago | parent [-]

I looked into this a little and found that it doesn't quite fit the narrative that I inferred (which may not be the one you were implying) from this thread. The authors are apparently from many teams all working for the pharma company Merck & Co. and the companies press release[1] suggests that part of the value of this paper is the coordination of the entire production chain. The number of authors seems to be a consequence of the purpose of the paper, Merck & Co.'s policies on attribution for publications, and the relationship between pharma and scientific publication (which I think has something to do with patents). This doesn't seem to have anything to do with university departments.

I'm not saying that it's reasonable for a paper to list 140 authors. In fact, I find the "author contribution" statement at the end to be comically vague. But I think the story is more complicated than CV padding from people who didn't make a substantial contribution.

[1] https://www.merck.com/news/merck-scientists-publish-landmark...

▲abirch an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

I believe refundable tolls are going to be a must to avoid being flooded by AI. Whether it's reviewing papers or PRs, the gatekeepers should be able to charge for spam.