Remix.run Logo
▲ marginalia_nu 2 hours ago

To be fair the peer review model has been falling apart long before AI generated text was a thing, mostly due to the exploitative nature of academic journals leading to incentive structures that don't align with producing good science.

Reviewers don't get paid and have zero incentive to do a good job. You can in many cases just submit a paper over and over to different journals until it encounters a reviewer that can't be bothered reading it, upon which it gets rubber stamped through. The result is that time and time again, incredibly shoddy and too often downright fraudulent science has gotten through peer review.

▲jrflo an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I have several papers published and this has been my experience too. One paper got submitted to dozens of different journals for several months as-is until it went through. Other times reviewers clearly did not read the paper in depth, and their critiques would have been answered if they read more than 2 pages in.

More importantly, I've never felt that the review process actually added anything, especially for engineering journals. No reviewer ever sees the actual prototype, algorithm, raw data, etc. The only thing they can critique is your methods and literature review. No one checks if the thing actually works as you're claiming it does, which is 80-90% of the hard part.

Certain fields, like mathematics, peer review is absolutely critical. But we've copy/pasted this process onto other fields where it's way less useful, which is why many fields are moving towards Arxiv instead of waiting for long, useless peer review process.

▲titzer an hour ago | parent | next [-]

> One paper got submitted to dozens of different journals for several months as-is until it went through.

I hope you're exaggerating for the sake of an HN comment, but multiple concurrent submissions of the same work is absolutely grounds for desk rejection. It borders on an academic integrity violation, as most venues have an either implicit (e.g. through the ACM SIG they are a part of) or explicit policy forbidding concurrent submissions.

If you did this, I'm glad your work is rejected without being read. That's some shit that degrades the progress.

I've reviewed at least 20 papers in the last 3 months or so, probably closer to 40 just this year. What you're describing does not match my experience in any of the venues I have reviewed for, except for maybe low quality journals. If you're submitting to those venues, then your experience isn't typical.

Major conferences do care about review quality. Community standards are improving, as there is constant reflection on the process and how it's going.

AI is definitely causing new stresses on the system, but this comment makes the whole endeavor sound like it's a crap show, and it isn't.

▲Calavar an hour ago | parent [-]

They never said the submissions were concurrent.

▲sarchertech 40 minutes ago | parent [-]

Dozens of different journals over several months implies there was concurrency.

▲mweidner 42 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> which is why many fields are moving towards Arxiv instead of waiting for long, useless peer review process.

ArXiv is also dropping the ball by subjecting papers to long moderation holds. I have a submission that has been on hold for over a month - approaching the point where I'll get the conference reviews back before the arXiv "review".

I understand that they are dealing with a flood of papers by and about AI, but it is annoying to get caught up in that for a paper in a non-AI field (cs.DS) that is entirely human-written except for a "find typos" pass.

▲bee_rider an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

I wonder if engineering or math is weird in this case. Papers are better if they are entirely verifiable from the claims in the paper, so, ideally it should be possible to fully verify the claims just based on what is said in the paper. For math that’s perfect because math is entirely made of arguments.

For engineering… I mean, sometimes you want to publish a paper about an algorithm that is more amenable to actual hardware and/or easier to tune. The reviewer would need access to an HPC cluster to verify your claim, nobody is going to burn their credits to verify your paper.

AI reviewers could be most helpful by… running the algorithm instead of their inference stacks!

▲ModernMech 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Reviewers don't get paid but that doesn't mean they have zero incentive to do a good job.

First, reviewers do get compensated, just not with money but with reviews from other researchers when they submit their papers. Not every review is good, but I've gotten enough helpful reviews from highly competent researchers whose time is very valuable which I didn't have to pay a cent for, that I'm incentivized to do the same for others. Also I want the system to work, so that's also an incentive.

> You can in many cases just submit a paper over and over to different journals until it encounters a reviewer that can't be bothered reading it, upon which it gets rubber stamped through.

This is not how to build a career in research, only high impact journals and conferences matter.

> The result is that time and time again, incredibly shoddy and too often downright fraudulent science has gotten through peer review.

Peer review isn't supposed to detect fraud, it's not designed to do that, and the people reviewing aren't trained in fraud detection, nor should they be.

The system is supposed to detect fraud through reproducible studies, but if you hop over to this thread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538303) you'll see people complaining all over that the results are obvious so what was the point of the research. Then you might appreciate how hard it is to make a career off reproducing results. If we think fraud in research is such a problem, we have to actually allocate funds toward reproducing results.

But to your point, peer review does stop plenty of shoddy research, just not all of it. It's not reasonable to expect peer review to stop all shoddy research, because we might be working on different and conflicting definitions of shoddy.

▲marginalia_nu 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Well in the scenario you're a fraud or a hack, you're likely aware that you're a fraud or a hack, so you're unlikely to pursue a career in the traditional high impact journal sense. Though you may still wish to build credibility via volume of work, or to perpetuate some agenda, perhaps manufacturing a scientific basis for the magnetized water spiral business you're running.

We know replication doesn't prevent fraud either. Like in many fields most studies simply don't replicate. It's a whole thing.

It's very difficult to get institutions to work at scale when they assume every participant is acting in good faith. That may have worked 150 years ago when scientists were wealthy and doing the work for the love of the game (and also ironically not subject to peer review), but it doesn't work in the human centipede of fraud era of society.

▲cozzyd an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

We get compensated with a line item on our NSF synergistic activities document.

▲azan_ an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

> First, reviewers do get compensated, just not with money but with reviews from other researchers when they submit their papers.

It would make sense if publishing process was free and not extremely expensive. Publishers are sitting on pile of gold made from exploiting scientists and funneling public funds.

▲BurningFrog 20 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Sounds like AIs should do the reviews!

▲dominotw an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

That sounds like pull request review that is now totally useless.