Remix.run Logo
▲ somenameforme 7 hours ago

Your own worth is up to you to decide, but what you provide to society, or to a company is determine by your actions and by your role. And since I feel like this is all a proxy for some sort of unspoken idealism of non-capitalism I'd emphasize that this is all just as true even in a 'true' communist system. Imagine you have this commune of people, completely equal, and two people get into a critical dispute such that both insist they'll only stay if the other guy is kicked out.

One person is a highly skilled doctor - the only one in this particular commune in fact; the other is a janitor. It's not hard to guess who's getting kicked out. And this reality of some being 'more equal' than others would influence every single interaction in society. Even if everybody there genuinely believed everybody is equal, the reality is that some people would be worth much more to that society. So the equality is nothing but a fantasy.

I also find this whole concept trite. My value, as a human, is to my family. I couldn't care less what any company thinks of me so long as I am providing enough to support my family. And while I attach greater value to society as a whole, even that is again secondary to family. I think this obsession on extrinsic measures of value is probably a result of the decline of fertility and thus the decline of family.

▲komali2 4 hours ago | parent [-]

> My value, as a human, is to my family.

Heh, you happened to have stumbled upon exactly what I wrote about last month, the overextension of the term "value": https://blog.calebjay.com/posts/meaningless-value/

To save you the click, people often conflate moral worth, personal attachment, instrumental value, and allocation priority, when those are all very different things. I admit that above I was playing around with the idea a bit, though I do find it a little, idk, self diminishing to purposefully place oneself under their boss even in instrumental value. Maybe because I'm co-op-brained now and have seen for myself how effective a worker ownership structure works.

> Imagine you have this commune of people, completely equal, and two people get into a critical dispute such that both insist they'll only stay if the other guy is kicked out.

I've seen this exact situation, actually, and the solution wasn't to keep the "doctor," but for the community to assert that both need to find a resolution because neither was getting kicked out without commiting some kind of harm to the group as a whole. That is to say, instrumental value doesn't get someone greater allocation priority (or authority). I understand that under capitalism, it's supposed to, but we risk getting into an unproductive conversation about who actually has more instrumental value to a corporation if we explore that.

▲wallst07 31 minutes ago | parent [-]

You are over thinking this and I think we're just talking past each other.

I'm not talking about self-worth. I have no issues with self-confidence/self-esteem. I'm not talking about relationships out of work.

I work for money, I provide a service and get paid for it. My pay is based on how much "value" I provide.

What do you think would happen if they just decided to make me CEO of a 100B+ company? Think.