Remix.run Logo
▲ Quad9 Is Leaving France: Why DNS Resolvers Are the Wrong Place to Fight Piracy(techstackups.com)
251 points by ritzaco 2 hours ago | 52 comments
▲trentnix 39 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Every attempt to “fight piracy” that isn’t “prosecute pirates” is just a backdoor to suppressing speech a government doesn’t like.

▲criddell 14 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

That sounds nice, but it isn't correct. A lot of piracy fights are civil in nature. If you sue somebody for infringing on your rights, you probably aren't trying to suppress speech.

When Quad9 fails to resolve malware and phishing sites without trying to get the bad guys punished, they aren't a tool of the government.

Are there some examples where a piracy prosecution was clearly trying to suppress speech?

▲peri-cl 2 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

They use the front door,

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50229861 ("France asked ISPs to prepare temporary DNS blocks for major social platforms")

Contextualize the Quad9 thing appropriately.

▲michael-sumner an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

https://quad9.net/news/blog/au-revoir-france/

https://blog.cloudflare.com/quad9-withdrawal-from-france/

▲Fe2O3 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Dupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50195959

Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538994

▲8by3 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Not a dupe as its an opinion piece by someone else, somewhat hilariously named

AL Smith, https://techstackups.com/authors/alsmith/

But the sites font looks like AI Smith, which I assumed was a cheeky way to say it was written by AI before looking up the authors bio.

▲peri-cl 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> "which I assumed was a cheeky way to say it was written by AI"

Well, it is written by AI. It's egregious.

▲ritzaco 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

yeah sorry this was an AI summary; I do find them useful for stuff like this when the information is all out there already but scattered in different places, but wasn't expecting it to get to front page!

Al(ice|en) Smith is indeed my agent and a reference to AI/Al looking similar in some fonts and agent smith from the matrix.

▲tfrancisl an hour ago | parent [-]

Why upload it to HN at all? If you didnt bother writing it, and seemingly didnt bother reading it, seems pretty irresponsible to just post like this.

▲cowlevel 31 minutes ago | parent [-]

You get benefits, like karma, and a small chance of a job interview.

▲LeBit 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

It is not a dupe

▲fanwood 3 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

We need to move beyond copyright

▲djha-skin 7 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This article is an AI-generated (see Pangram) rehashing of Cloudflare's article yesterday :(

▲rileymat2 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

One thing is not well explained, if they can’t reliably detect french users, how can they leave france?

▲jeremyjh an hour ago | parent | next [-]

It mostly means having no legal entity or property in France that French courts can render judgments on. So they will geoblock as a basic compliance measure that doesn’t fully work but they avoid exposure by staying out of France.

▲jacquesm an hour ago | parent [-]

They're Swiss (Zurich HQ), there is a lot of reciprocity between Switzerland and France when it comes to legal affairs, and one day Switzerland may want to join the EU so this isn't all that clear cut.

▲fanwood a few seconds ago | parent | next [-]

Living in Switzerland, I don't see the country joining the EU anytime soon if ever

▲mdasen 31 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think it's partly about risk and what will get a prosecutor off your back and what a court might say "c'mon, they've done enough."

By geoblocking users in France, they've probably blocked at least 95% of French users from being able to access their services, if not closer to 99%. By not having any nexus in France, it does reduce their exposure. Yes, Switzerland and France might cooperate on things, but going after Quad9 via Switzerland would involve convincing Swiss authorities that a) France is correct enough that Switzerland should want to comply, b) the steps Quad9 has taken aren't enough, c) France should get to enforce this against a company that's completely extra-territorial.

Yes, Switzerland could still side with France, but it definitely makes France's job a lot harder. Even within a country, people often "forum shop" for a district or judge they think will be more favorable. Forcing France to get the Swiss to agree means getting a second party to also be so strict (or want to cave for diplomatic reasons).

As you say, it's definitely not clear cut. It does make it harder. It does reduce their risk. It makes it more likely that France will just declare victory and move on. Sometimes it's about making it not worth the fight. Would a French prosecutor's career be better served trying to get Switzerland to agree to essentially enforce French law worldwide against a non-profit? Especially when they are geoblocking most French users already - basically complying with the ruling as much as technology realistically allows? I think they'd probably find that their efforts would be better spent elsewhere. If Quad9 were still serving DNS queries from France, a prosecutor would have a much stronger reason to go after them in Switzerland. At this point, it just feels like a prosecutor would see it as a waste of time - like worrying about the cost of an array offset in a loop when you're doing a network call every loop, the network call's cost is just going to be so much greater and you should be spending your time on what matters. That said, people aren't always rational.

It doesn't get them in the clear for certain, but I think it does reduce the risk substantially.

▲zephyrthenoble 41 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

No offense, but if you know any Swiss, you would know that's unlikely

▲jacquesm 35 minutes ago | parent [-]

I know plenty of Swiss. Some of them are really happy being 'inside but outside' and others would see Switzerland as a model of how the EU could function if they set their mind to it but they realize this will not happen from the outside. But there are many areas where Switzerland and the EU are currently not very compatible. Time will tell, I think in the very long term it is inevitable, in my lifetime rather not. Even so, for practical things like legal issues like the one we are discussing I would not be surprised if a Swiss court was sympathetic. It is called the "Berne Convention" after all...

▲nonethewiser 20 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Could Quad9 still get fined because they inevitably will handle French traffic sometimes?

▲Charmunk an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Was wondering this to. The article explains why geoblocking France IP's isn't sufficient, then goes on to talk about how it will stop working for French users, without explaining how they do that other then based on IP

▲ketzu 23 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Seems at least the "geoblocking is enough" part should be legislated at a higher level, even if you agree that dns blocking is the right solution. Long and expensive fights in every country to get that recognized are stupid.

▲bruce343434 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

A self hosted recursive resolver fixes this. Have the courts take it up with ICANN

▲smolder an hour ago | parent [-]

Better yet, let's vote to keep people out of office who have stupid ideas like battling ICANN.

▲cowlevel 31 minutes ago | parent [-]

Better yet, let's vote politicians out of office and vote ICANN out of power too. They are not any better, e.g. they sell gTLDs to make money by spamming the root zone. Don't know who you'd replace it with - OpenNIC is just as bad.

▲qalmakka an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

One thing that drives me nuts is that your average European Government (look at Italy or France) is absolutely open to implementing draconian laws with borderline authoritarian censorship in order to save the profits of football leagues. It's absolute madness, and it's a reflection of the corruption and how football got too big and too powerful in Europe.

There's nothing bad with football, but having it take >90% of all sport revenues and mindshare is unhealthy

▲jMyles 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Every place is the wrong place to "fight piracy".

▲hobo123 34 minutes ago | parent [-]

https://www.oreilly.com/content/piracy-is-progressive-taxati...

▲NikxDa an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The irony of this clearly AI-written piece starting out by referencing the need for "a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path" is amusing

▲CarlitosHighway 44 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

John Todd, American, using the Switzerland ("The terrorist's favorite bankers / FIFA safe haven") scam not being able to offer his service to French people is supposed to make a mark? Why then does NextDNS (also based in France, and a much much better service) not cry on the Internet like American Johnny?

▲dietr1ch an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

They can follow-up by banning Google Maps so people wouldn't find their way to doing crime

▲MadrasTh0rn an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Really disappointing situation.

▲shevy-java 39 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

France makes everyone sad these days. Macron nuked the economy and fights the people on the street while amplifying censorship laws. The guy is the ultimate turncoat - unfortunately Le Pen will just implement ultranationalism 2.0 while appeasing dictator Putin. Meanwhile France's economy is not going forward anywhere - no real way for competition, rising debts dragging the whole Eurozone down. I think all those lobbyists that ruin a country, need to be held responsible, both with mandatory jail time (no way to pay fine to escape) as well as seizure of all illegal assets. The handwriting of what is going on is so clear.

▲kapilvt 29 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

“Macron nuked the economy” evidence? It’s not clear to me that anything here was policy based vs an accounting of what was already in place adapting to a changing world.

▲lotsofpulp 28 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

France’s economy was nuked long before Macron, when it promised excessive benefits to non workers relative to the country’s economic output and population growth.

▲p-e-w 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> In that thread, Quad9's CTO John Todd asked readers to write "a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path", with plenty of sources, and to send it to policymakers.

I honestly can’t tell if this is a serious but hilariously misguided effort, or a deliberate attempt to fool people about what’s going on.

Judges and lawmakers didn’t do this because they misunderstood some technology issue. They did this because they got paid, or were appointed by people who got paid. They don’t give a rat’s ass about what the “correct” approach is in the opinion of tech bloggers.

If you want things to change fundamentally, you need money, leverage, or guns. Those in power have all three, and they are laughing at your attempts to educate them about what you think they should be doing. They’re not misunderstanding you. They’re not holding it wrong. This isn’t some random mistake born out of ignorance. Everything is going perfectly according to (their) plan. You’re barking up the wrong tree.

▲trashb an hour ago | parent | next [-]

IANAL but I wonder is there a way for them to be required to read the statements? In that case the policymakers (that probably don't care about the technical side) will be flooded with work.

That would waste their time and money and make it less interesting to fight and showing them that it is a topic that impacts a lot of people (and angers a lot of people). That could work as leverage to get them to reconsider.

I can imagine them appealing and bringing a collection of these statements forward as evidence that 3rd party individuals largely oppose the decision but I don't know if that would work like that.

▲o_-_o an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Shhh, don't give them any clues. Have them block dns resolvers ;-)

▲hdhxbsbsbshs 32 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Oh but my friend, this is Europe, where we strive to be above such primitive dealings (while getting absolutely crushed by everyone who doesn’t…).

▲usernametaken29 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It’s insane to me that they found a legal way to prevent the distribution of copyrighted material via DNS. Why isn’t ChatGPT.com blacklisted? I can ask for a verbatim copy of any book and get it 1:1 too? Clearly piracy but somehow tolerated

▲alerighi an hour ago | parent | next [-]

It's known that they will block DNS records of piracy sites from a ton of years. Of course one user can just change the DNS, or even configure DNS over TLS/HTTPS, but 99% of the users doesn't know how to do so, and they use the default DNS server that the ISP provides, hence blocking piracy sites by simply pointing DNS records to a scary page that informs that piracy is a crime etc is far more simpler than blocking actual IP traffic (yes, they tried to so so in my country, Italy, recently, the effect was that they ended up blocking stuff like Google Drive so they gave up I think on the idea).

And yes of course in the reality the piracy site will just open under another DNS name and we know that, their goal is based on the assumption that it takes time and that if they block stuff right before an important football match (it's done for that, they only care about football because football clubs lobby the politics and they have big money, whatever else you can pirate and they don't give a fuck) the users doesn't have time to search the match on another domain or so and thus they will end paying 30 or 40 euros for Sky/DAZN/etc that of course it's not even true.

▲lesspassiveobse an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'll give you one more: Ask chatgpt to do a DNS lookup of some piracy site via the webchat (It will run on some VM in a datacenter in USA and return accurate results)

▲singpolyma3 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I don't think you can?

▲peri-cl an hour ago | parent [-]

Astra actually pretty regularly offers me hyperlinks to PDF's hosted on pirate sites, which I didn't even request. It's very eager to help, or something.

(API version, if it makes a difference).

▲nwsm an hour ago | parent [-]

That's not quite the same thing is it?

▲peri-cl an hour ago | parent [-]

It's not returning the text from its own weights (which is impossible anyway); but it is returning a direct link to that text, which a clean analogy to the DNS resolver. (Which is the analogy I interpreted the GP comment to be making).

▲CarlitosHighway an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I just tried to get some books from ChatGPT and it never offered me downloads or anything. What do you prompt it ?

▲dist-epoch 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Why is it insane?

It's well known that EU is a very regulated place, with strong protections laws for everything.

▲looperhacks an hour ago | parent [-]

There's a large difference between very regulated and a court making a stupid decisions. Afaik there's no law that defines how and when a DNS block should happen

▲jacquesm an hour ago | parent [-]

> There's a large difference between very regulated and a court making a stupid decisions.

The problem with that is that the court has been handed this outcome on a platter by the defendant: they have shown that they are not just a DNS resolver but that they can and do block access to various parties at their discretion. So any kind of 'common carrier' like protection (in so far as these applied to begin with) goes right out of the window.

▲airza 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Ai dr