Remix.run Logo
▲ jhallenworld a day ago

>if the had 600,000 H200s in their closet, it wasn't illegal

How about in their own datacenter? Perhaps they didn't ship the H200s, but instead offered remote cloud compute services to Chinese customers which happened to include H200s. I don't know how you would prevent this exactly- the US would have to tell Singapore that its companies can not sell cloud services to China if they are using H200s?- it's weird and not really Nvidia's problem. I guess you could have terms of service restrictions, but how would Nvidia enforce them?

I think this loophole was only realized very recently:

https://techcrunch.com/2026/11/16/us-tightens-ai-chip-export...

Now just imagine if the server farms are in space with a Starlink connection to the customer. How would anyone even know who you are selling services to?

▲klrefg a day ago | parent [-]

> I think this loophole was only realized very recently:

US government only figuring out recently would be astronomically incompetent. So not unlikely. However lobbyists would have obviously brought this up long ago.

▲barelysapient 19 hours ago | parent | next [-]

This has been widely known for a while. The export restrictions were very narrowly written regarding the sale of hardware containing certain chips when the end customer is in china.

The export controls did not constrain manufacturing in of these systems in China or China's purchasing of compute (from Amazon for example) running on these chips. Chinese entities in a third country were legally able to purchase the chips and deploy that compute in the third country.

▲formerly_proven a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is an excellent "loophole" to leave open because it means you can profit from china without giving china control. You can shut down remote access overnight, like the US just did.

▲ 21 hours ago | parent [-]
[deleted]
▲4gotunameagain 10 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You are forgetting one thing. There was a major power shift in Washington after the midterms.

This is effectively the intelligence sector showing it still has teeth left now that Trump has lost a lot of his power.

If you remember, there was a lot more anti China sentiment during the previous Democrat gov, as pushed by the intelligence establishment.

▲thaumasiotes 6 hours ago | parent [-]

> If you remember, there was a lot more anti China sentiment during the previous Democrat gov

You mean the Biden administration? They were heavily anti-China, yes, but that was mostly just a continuation of Trump I's anti-China policies. The big policy shift happened between Obama and Trump.

▲s1artibartfast 10 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The cloud loophole was known. The Biden Administration had proposal for controlling cloud compute which Trump paused when taking office. The new administration took until November 15, 2026 to roll out their own alternative