Remix.run Logo
▲ zahlman a day ago

> That's a very common misconception I see among the developers. They get upset when someone sells their software, especially when the author distribute it for free.

No, that isn't the argument here at all. The argument is that the existence of OSS alternatives (for which there is no real reason to pay more than a nominal distribution fee, aside from contracted support) makes it harder for proprietary software to retain commercial value.

▲ValdikSS a day ago | parent [-]

>for which there is no real reason to pay more than a nominal distribution fee, aside from contracted support

FOSS doesn't mean you have to distribute the software for free. If you want to earn money from FOSS, just don't publish it and sell it instead. It doesn't make it less open.

I sell open-source software of myself and others, for example, quite successfully.

Linked article states:

>So if you are redistributing copies of free software, you might as well charge a substantial fee and make some money. Distributing free software is an opportunity to raise funds for development. Don't waste it!

It has been this way all these years, that's why I call it a common misconception. The GNU article by the link above is from 2012 or earlier.

▲zahlman 7 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Unfortunately, that's not how capitalism works. Given that the cost of distribution is trivial and the underlying good (the software) not only has perfect "resale value" but can trivially be duplicated, your first customer has every motive to undercut you (even if they don't outright give it away). If they still charge something, the logic applies recursively. Supply is effectively unlimited once the first copy exists, thus price goes to zero. If you use force of law to prevent this, you don't actually have OSS but just a "source-available" license.

▲ValdikSS 3 hours ago | parent [-]

I can just politely ask people not to distribute it if I want to, by not supplying them with the updates :)

That's how grsecurity patches work for Linux, despite being GPLv2.

I have about 1000 copies sold and nobody had posted the software publicly yet. And no, I don't have additional clause of not supplying the updates.

▲komali2 20 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Zahlman is correct that my meaning in my post was that I write FOSS so as to reduce the commercial viability of proprietary software, and I do so in niches where I don't expect to extract any money from doing so myself. I just want people to have to pay for less things.

For me it's an explicitly anti-capitalist action.

Of course if you want to sell FOSS, by all means. As you said, it's in the license.