| ▲ | jmillikin a day ago |
| > Pick one open source tool you use. Find the most annoying thing about
> installing or running it. Spend a weekend fixing it, with the people who
> maintain it. Then tell me about it.
Flex: The most annoying thing is that it's written in C (and is therefore a pain to cross-compile), and it has a runtime dependency on GNU M4, which depends on gnulib (the GNU anti-portability library). Flex is currently being rewritten to be more complicated and worse by ESR for reasons beyond my comprehension.I had an LLM write an m4 implementation in Rust based on the POSIX specs, then fuzz-test it against GNU M4 until it was mostly the same (modulo all the regex bugs it found in GNU M4). Then I had an LLM rewrite Flex in Rust, using rust-m4 as an in-process library. QEMU: It's written in C, has a bunch of huge dependencies, automated test coverage that rounds to zero, their main contribution path is a mailing list that sometimes swallows patches, and the maintainers might ask for a risky patch to be made more risky before they'll accept it. I went through that process once for a few relatively minor fixes and never want to do it again. I had an LLM write a multi-architecture emulator with a JIT, high test coverage, and a device plugin system that uses WebAssembly. Busybox: Written in C, huge pain to build. I tried switching to Toybox instead but it's incomplete, the build system involves a pile of shell scripts that require Bash, not any other POSIX-compliant shell (including its own), and the maintainer's response was basically to tell me to fuck off: https://lists.landley.net/pipermail/toybox/2024-October/0095... I had an LLM write a replacement in Rust that has enough shell builtins to run an autoconf script from within a hermetic build environment, and its only build-time dependency is rustc. --- You know why LLMs are so great? Because they save me from having to interact with open-source maintainers who intentionally choose to make their software baroque and their contribution process obnoxious. You want your project to be written only in ANSI C89 and built with Meson and accept patches only via GPG-signed email to a mailing list that silently drops HTML? Fine, have fun, an ASIC somewhere in Iowa is going to spend the next 3 hours letting me forget your project exists. |
|
| ▲ | rpdillon a day ago | parent | next [-] |
| Your post reminds me about the ongoing trend where people don't spend time together anymore. They prefer to sit in front of their computers and interact online. There's a recent article about the difference in the number of people going out on Friday night in 2025 versus 1975. It's like an 80% drop or something like that. People would rather just sit at home. People have stopped having kids as well -- because it's fundamentally a very human interaction where you have to deal with a lot of bullshit, not just with the kids, but with all the teachers, schools, daycare providers and coaches that you'll end up dealing with. People just opted out. Instagram's more fun. Software brought people together because it's a team sport and it's hard to ship anything significant on your own, especially in a short time frame. But AI has changed all that. Now we can bring all the isolation that we've brought to the rest of society to software development as well. AI just gives us another way that we don't have to actually work together anymore. And for you, that seems like a big benefit, because it's clear that you didn't enjoy working with the people that ran those projects. |
| |
| ▲ | jmillikin a day ago | parent | next [-] | | > Your post reminds me about the ongoing trend where people don't spend
> time together anymore. They prefer to sit in front of their computers
> and interact online.
This is, I think, partially a matter of social circles. The kind of people who enjoy the idea of socialization in an abstract sense but don't actually enjoy the process of socializing will spend all their time indoors on their computers. Meanwhile in the real world people are having a blast. Very few people want to spend time typing on web forums when they could be outside shopping, or dancing, or drinking. > Software brought people together because it's a team sport and it's hard
> to ship anything significant on your own, especially in a short time frame.
> But AI has changed all that. Now we can bring all the isolation that we've
> brought to the rest of society to software development as well.
While trying not to repeat myself unnecessarily, people whose social circles were formed by contributions to online open-source communities have long been viewed by the rest of society as socially impoverished (with some reason). A web forum or chat room isn't real social interaction, not in the same way that going out to a pub or concert or book club is.LLMs are finally offering us computer nerds a way out. We can have the computer write the code and debug the segfaults and babysit the benchmarks while we go outside and have fun. We are free from the keyboard now. | | |
| ▲ | rpdillon a day ago | parent [-] | | > people whose social circles were formed by contributions to online open-source communities have long been viewed by the rest of society as socially impoverished Those communities that are so impoverished were the things that created reusable software that communities could organize around and customize and improve together. One-off replacements are essentially worthless in comparison. You put up with the people to build things of greater worth. |
| |
| ▲ | ValdikSS a day ago | parent | prev [-] | | I've recently discovered this comment and it made me so sad https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44810086 |
|
|
| ▲ | zahlman a day ago | parent | prev | next [-] |
| > is currently being rewritten to be more complicated and worse by ESR I don't recognize the name "Flex" but I find this claim hard to believe in and of itself, having seen ESR's rants about the complexity of Automake. > You want your project to be written only in ANSI C89 and built with Meson and accept patches only via GPG-signed email to a mailing list that silently drops HTML? Fine, have fun, an ASIC somewhere in Iowa is going to spend the next 3 hours letting me forget your project exists. This to me sounds like the obnoxious attitude: not taking a moment to consider why others would care about their language choice, signed email or avoiding distractions like HTML email (support for which could be their "more complicated and worse"). |
|
| ▲ | hypfer a day ago | parent | prev [-] |
| The closer reads like people might've made the right call refusing the engagement. It also reads like a refusal of true disengagement. Maybe you can now work on that, given that your profile says you're retired? __ That said, I use AI the same way. It saves one from a ton of draining interactions, ego management etc. |
| |
| ▲ | jmillikin a day ago | parent [-] | | > The closer reads like people might've made the right call refusing the engagement. I think there's enough history of my contributions to various open-source projects over the past ~20 years to serve as evidence that I go pretty far out of my way to be accommodating to projects that are open to contributions. > It also reads like a refusal of true disengagement. I'm not sure what "refusal of true disengagement" means. My goal is generally to accomplish something like building a piano recital scoring app, or being able to run an old game on my laptop. There's a few dozen steps needed to achieve that, which incrementally go down the stack until it encounters a library that works well enough that I don't need to debug it. Sometimes this is a very short list -- I've been amazed at how well the Vulkan ecosystem works, ditto the Go stdlib and the major Go ecosystem libraries. But sometimes it's like falling down a ladder, hitting each rung on the way down, in which case I turn to an LLM to make the ladder go away. A lot of C projects seem to be like this -- it's a conservative choice of language in general, for people who saw the rise of C++/Java/C#/Go/Rust/etc and decided to skip them, so the attitudes and tooling are likewise conservative. > Maybe you can now work on that, given that your profile says you're retired? Being retired means that I want to spend more time doing fun things and less time arguing about file descriptor lifetimes on mailing lists. | | |
| ▲ | hypfer a day ago | parent | next [-] | | Yes, sure, but the initial comment is still full of vitriol, and that's why I said what I said. > I'm not sure what "refusal of true disengagement" means. It means not being mad anymore at the people and "showing them" by using LLMs to the degree where one feels the need to rant on about their perceived bad decisions on HN. I _suspect_ you might not be able to fully turn that off, as it sounds like spite might be a driving force. And that's good, but also, you've kinda made it?
So if anything, you could probably be happy that you're retired and that you do not have to have these discussions anymore. And maybe also see that the people probably did their best. Which may or may not have been very good, but they did so nonetheless. | | |
| ▲ | jmillikin a day ago | parent [-] | | > but the initial comment is still full of vitriol
If you think this comment is full of vitriol then you should try reading the kinds of emails people send to mailing lists. > It means not being mad anymore at the people and "showing them" by
> using LLMs to the degree where one feels the need to rant on about
> their perceived bad decisions on HN.
I think you're reading things into my comment that aren't there.HN is full of threads lamenting that projects are seeing a decline in community interaction and contributions because LLMs let people vibe-code whatever software they want. I hesitate to use the word "universal", but there's definitely a strong feeling that greenfield LLM-generated projects are in some sense stealing effort or attention that could be put toward an existing project. I'm sympathetic to that claim on the surface, but the actual experience is that a lot of projects have only had that sort of interaction in the first place because the maintainers forced it as a pre-requisite to getting a patch accepted. There's some 30 kLoC library out there that decodes an obscure audio codec, it almost works but you need to add some #ifdefs or whatever so it builds on Clang. The would-be user has to mentally prepare themselves for the next few weeks (or months!) of trying to cajole the maintainer into accepting their patch. And maybe it's never accepted, and now you're stuck, and that project goes into the shelf forever. The article acts as if people with LLMs are the ones whose behavior needs to change to be more pro-social, but from my perspective its the maintainers' attitude that needs to change (if they want their project to continue receiving attention). There's no reason to put up with a maintainer's dictatorial control over a project any more, because the value of code itself is plummeting to epsilon. > And maybe also see that the people probably did their best. Which may or
> may not have been very good, but they did so nonetheless.
Outcomes have never been judged by whether someone has done their best, but whether they have done well. | | |
| ▲ | hypfer a day ago | parent [-] | | > Outcomes have never been judged by whether someone has done their best, but whether they have done well. Yes but FOSS is primarily about the journey, actually. You can (and probably should, if you want to get things done) judge the outcomes and plan accordingly, but it's just people doing stuff in their free time. That cannot be measured purely with the measuring stick of the general market. Yes, this also means that a lot of it will be complete garbage, but that's fine and nothing to be upset about. At least beyond general disappointment with the lack of skill and sense of an average human. That's my point. |
|
| |
| ▲ | s3graham a day ago | parent | prev | next [-] | | > less time arguing about file descriptor lifetimes on mailing lists. Hey, I'm retired too, we can argue about that here! After working in the open for ~15 years, and generally being enthusiastic about collaborating and making shared common base-level tech internally at companies, I'm finding it shocking how much I don't want to even bother pushing projects to a public repo. Never mind doing any sort of releasing, contributing, "marketing", maintenance, patching, etc. | |
| ▲ | zahlman a day ago | parent | prev [-] | | > I think there's enough history of my contributions to various open-source projects over the past ~20 years to serve as evidence that I go pretty far out of my way to be accommodating to projects that are open to contributions. I mean, signing email and avoiding HTML sound to me like pretty trivial accommodation. And you only have to set up GPG once; it's not as if all these projects have their own mutually incompatible security/privacy/anonymity schemes. |
|
|