Remix.run Logo
▲ jmyeet 5 hours ago

So what you're saying is somebody took something that was public or at least community-owned and built a fence around it? Or, you might say, an enclosure [1]? Interesting. One could even describe this as rent-seeking behavior [2]?

LLMs themselves are built from the sum of human output when almost nobody who created that got paid for the value they created.

So what I'm hearing is that we have a distortion that can be described in terms of the worker's relationship to the means of production?

I honestly love it when people when people discover socialism from first principles.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inclosure_act

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking

▲ericmay 5 hours ago | parent [-]

That's one way to look at it, another way to look at it would be something like a community farm where someone took a few ingredients that were just sitting there and being given away for free and cooked them up into something special and sold it.

There's nothing wrong with people working on hobby projects for fun, regardless of how useful they may be, and there's nothing wrong with others taking that work and building upon it for their own purposes. That's the entire point of open source software.

If you find yourself upset that someone "stole" your freely given away work or is making a profit off of it or you yourself are not being "compensated" for giving away "free" things you're the problem here.

▲pocksuppet 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I think this analogy breaks down when you make money from it. It's more like your chickens lay more eggs than you need, so I break into your coop, steal the excess (you still have all you need) and set up a stall by the side of the road selling eggs for $2 a dozen.

▲ericmay 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't think that follows at all. IF you wanted to use the chicken analogy then they would just be community chickens with freely given away infinite eggs (since it's software) and someone (open source maintainers) because they think it's a lot of fun and are happy to give away their time and labor for free just keep the chickens happy and well-fed.

If you find yourself later being upset that someone took the eggs and made an omelet and sold it and made a few bucks, then you are lying to yourself and others about your reasoning for writing open source code.

▲pocksuppet 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I agree that big corporations tricked a lot of people into believing the wrong things about open source code.

▲ericmay 2 hours ago | parent [-]

If that's the case then you've also been tricked into believing the wrong things about XYZ and separately I can only argue what I'd been tricked to argue because you've stripped away my agency and have accused me of being unable to think for myself.

It's kind of a shit argument, why bother with it?