Remix.run Logo
▲ flyingsky an hour ago

>But it leads to World War III.

No! I'd expect a tense standoff around compute and Taiwan. Not a world war.

If a first strike can’t outthink drone production, the domination attempt just fails. If China wins any war longer than a year and is pulling ahead on electricity, it has no reason to escalate.

The closest precedent is the 1945–49 US nuclear monopoly. Preventive war was seriously argued for and never launched,the other sides raced instead.

▲lukan an hour ago | parent | next [-]

One could probably write books about the mindset of people assuming war is inevitable, because electricity production of their biggest competitor is slowly slowly approaching their consumption.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_electrici...

So yes, china is improving their tech and raising standards of living. But one has to take into account where they are coming from. How poor the average chinese person was just some years ago. So good for them making progress. I don't see this as a reason for WW3. But of course, them having more power will maybe lead to a world where the US is not dominating superpower number 1 anymore. And here is maybe a reason for WW3, as quite some apparently rather would blow up the world, then let this happen. So I certainly don't want chinese dominance instead, but fighting for world dominance in the first place is the problem here, not electricity production or AI developement.

▲trescenzi 39 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Totally agree and to comment more on the piece this is why it strikes me as effective: “I didn’t believe in AI doom because I thought more of people.” The reality is before these past few years I thought more of people. Like you’re saying I do think there’s some who don’t understand that the world can be positive sum.

▲ordinaryradical 41 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It also misunderstands the impetus for war.

War is always a matter of ambitions, territory, hubris, personality.

Abstract competition is never the fuse, just the thing that makes it possible for there to be escalating conflict.

US’s problem is imperialism; China’s is One China. It’s where those two collide that war happens.

AI is an instrument in this war, not an impetus.

But technologists often think technology is the dominant factor for everything, when in the end culture, personalities, and accidents of geography are often the things that matter.

▲Forgeties79 37 minutes ago | parent [-]

> War is always a matter of ambitions, territory, hubris, personality.

You’re forgetting arguably the biggest driver of all: resources. Strategic/natural resources is arguably the #1 driver of all wars.

3 of those 4 also seem borderline redundant.

▲ordinaryradical 13 minutes ago | parent [-]

Resources is inherent in territory—they are in the ground.

Hubris and personality maybe interchangeable but one can have a relatively stable personality and high hubris or vice versa, each of which can start a war. Ambitions is distinctly cultural and historical, not necessarily a characteristic of a leader.

▲Forgeties79 9 minutes ago | parent [-]

Territory, when I think of it, is primarily space and people. Expansion, regional territory, conquer and enslave or incorporate the local population, etc. That is also a reason countries have gone to war. Resources falls under it but to not explicitly mention it is striking to me. It’s a square-rectangle thing in some ways. Japan attacked the US primarily for oil and rubber (this is very simplified but it was a major driver), the land itself was not the most important part. In fact they probably would’ve been fine not holding the land if it somehow meant they could keep those resources.

“Ambitions” of a nation is a very nebulous concept and ultimately driven by leadership. No one asked me about any of the military engagements that my country has participated in in my lifetime, so I would not say my ambitions are reflected.

This is one of those situations where I think I understand what you are saying, but ultimately the list is kind of rough. Especially because it overwhelmingly attributes war to personality quirks and some general sense of “mood.”

▲piva00 2 minutes ago | parent [-]

That's exactly what territory means, no one will fight endless wars to capture a resourceless desert, it's useless except as a buffer zone. The territory that people fought for time immemorial is always because of resources: timber, gold, arable land with good soil, water, etc.

There's no point in fighting for territory for territory's sake, it's always about the resources, with a minor caveat for defensible geography.

▲A_D_E_P_T 43 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

lol, did you just rediscover the Thucydides Trap from first principles?

▲A_D_E_P_T an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

> If a first strike can’t outthink drone production, the domination attempt just fails. If China wins any war longer than a year and is pulling ahead on electricity, it has no reason to escalate.

Uh, US "first strikes" can't beat the Houthis and can't beat Iran. Track record: Remarkably poor. I'd go so far as to say that the entire US way of waging war -- its warfighting doctrine -- has been thoroughly discredited in light of this & the efficacy of top-dollar NATO weapons in Ukraine. (Good enough to hinder Russia, but far from good enough, and far from numerous enough, to win the war or even produce a decisive advantage.)

"You don't understand, we haven't gone Berserker Mode yet." (Sorry, couldn't resist.)

▲Muromec 31 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

>the efficacy of top-dollar NATO weapons in Ukraine. (Good enough to hinder Russia, but far from good enough, and far from numerous enough, to win the war or even produce a decisive advantage.)

This is more of US being unreliable ally than them being incapable one.

▲throwaway384034 19 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

It is a war of attrition like in the Soviet-Afghan war which contributed to the collapse of the Soviet Union.

▲A_D_E_P_T 10 minutes ago | parent [-]

Aye, but if so, who is on the wrong side of the curve? I think that a very persuasive answer could be made in either direction. Consider: Ukraine is in very serious demographic and economic trouble. [1] The large economies of the EU are presently suffering from severe internal divisions -- and in some cases open riots on a regular schedule -- with outsider pro-Russia parties poised to make real electoral gains. A collapse in support may only be a matter of time.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Ukraine#Popula...

▲A_D_E_P_T 24 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

It's both, and NATO stocks from elsewhere in Europe aren't exactly turning the tide, either.

▲a2tech 41 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

The US can reduce the entire world to living like the houthis. We can’t wipe out all of humanity. But we can shatter civilization and send people back to barbarism.

Personally I see that as being terrifying.

▲torginus 7 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

They can't. I remember thinking working out that even a full nuckear exchange between the USSR and USA at their full claimed inventories would leave like 20% of the population untouched. Which is an upper bound imo, and that would leave the rest of the world intact.

▲A_D_E_P_T 35 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

If you use nukes, maybe. The exact same could be said about the Russians, the Chinese, and even perhaps the French and Brits, with proper bomb placement.

Conventional war, though? Not in your wildest fantasies.

▲icameron 27 minutes ago | parent [-]

“First Strike” is a nuclear strategy that’s what the post is talking about.

▲A_D_E_P_T 22 minutes ago | parent [-]

I don't believe the blog post used in it that context, as it ignored China's second strike doctrine+capabilities and instead focused on drone production. The way I read it, it was more along the lines of an Iran or Iraq conventional first strike.

▲Muromec 25 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

That's a worthless capability, because everybody knows the US will not use it. At best it will equalise their standing with the most radical types

▲Fricken 7 minutes ago | parent [-]

Americans have a track record of handing power over to delusional cultists. The Trump administration is backed by several end-times cults including the fossil fuel industry, the AI industry, and of the evangelicals. All the worst people are in kahootz.