Remix.run Logo
▲ walrus01 4 hours ago

> Tokyo, for its perspective, views the regions with the noblesse oblige that you would expect a cosmopolitan center of culture and learning to have with respect to their benighted country bumpkin cousins.

I've met several French people from small coastal villages who now live in Paris and it's been interesting to see that their perspective on Paris is basically:

a) The native Parisians think people from their area are country bumpkins.

b) The people who live in their hometowns almost universally think that Paris is dirty, crime-ridden, too crowded, too noisy, too expensive, etc.

It almost completely mirrors the attitude of certain small town Americans towards NYC or Chicago or LA.

▲NoboruWataya 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Having lived in both Ireland and the UK, a similar dynamic between the capital city and rural towns exists in both countries. I think it must be near universal.

▲esperent 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> think that Paris is dirty, crime-ridden, too crowded, too noisy, too expensive, etc.

It's made big improvements in the last decade regarding dirt and noise, at least in the city center (besides the areas with homeless encampments along the canal). But crime ridden, crowded, expensive - all 100% accurate. Bag snatchers and pickpockets are all over the place, especially on the metro.

▲Ylpertnodi 2 hours ago | parent [-]

That's any tourist-trap city.

Paris, many years ago, was just dogshit everywhere. I hope to go back if things have changed, but the smell, and the constant hopscotch was soul-destroying.

▲esperent 2 hours ago | parent [-]

It's changed a lot. Far less traffic, far less pollution, and my experience is that all the people I interacted with were lovely, far from the Parisian stereotypes. I would also strongly disagree that it's just a tourist trap city. It feels vibrant and alive, it's a city that would be great to live in (if you're rich).

▲motionlessveloc 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Japan has this plus a bunch of healthy(ish) big city rivalry. Osakans think Tokyoites are cold, boring and humorless, Kyotoites think Osakans are loud and boorish, Osakans think people from Kyoto are stuck up pricks, Kobe people pity everybody else for being unfashionable and poor, etc.

This last trio sounds funny to outsiders because Osaka, Kyoto and Kobe are 30 min away from each other by train and basically all part of the big Kansai blob, but try asking a New Yorker what they think about New Jersey, Westchester County, etc.

▲walrus01 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I wonder if any Japanese humor publishers have thought of something similar to this:

https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/23dev1/judgemental_nyc...

You'd probably need a deep level of local cultural understanding to 'get' any of it... But even as a person who only spends part of the time in NYC, I can 'get' why the gowanus canal area is marked as sludge, or other regionally specific humorous labels.

▲lazyasciiart 4 hours ago | parent [-]

This one is a 2d chart but similar flavor https://www.reddit.com/r/Tokyo/comments/1siotg/tokyo_town_ma...

The original map in that post is perhaps closer https://share.google/pDd86jU8DMBair5PN