Remix.run Logo
▲ defrost 17 hours ago

> please don't repeat "but the nuclear deal" Iran was caught TWICE, by the UN, having violated it

On what dates, and what "agreement" was violated?

Are you referring to the 2005 UN finding that Iran was in noncompliance with IAEA safeguards that occurred before the first iteration of "the nuclear deal" Joint Plan of Action (JPOA) 2013, and the following iteration of "the nuclear deal" Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) 2015 ?

▲spwa4 16 hours ago | parent [-]

Not just that (there's also the 3 statements, and the timing of those statements), plus looking up how enrichment works (the lower the %, the slower it goes, exponentially) which means that Iran was doing nuclear enrichment during the nuclear deal, with the number of centrifuges clearly indicating it was to produce nuclear weapons, not for any other reason. Again, I am very, very sorry, but Trump's and others statements on this particular issue are correct. I understand that it is currently considered critical to people's political beliefs that this isn't true. But the laws of nature (well, engineering) say different.

And as pointed out before, I believe the US negotiators weren't lying when they stated Iran was actually boasting about their enrichment.

Oh and it's not just the US current political views that are offended with this statement. WHO sold Iran those centrifuges, knowing full well the numbers meant that they were meant for nuclear weapons? The German green party and CDU approved that sale ... but it can't be discussed. I mean, were they deceived? Maybe, probably I'm going to say, but it cannot be talked about and especially the obvious question "What is Germany's responsibility here?" can't be asked.

I mean it's like the Netherland's and Belgium's role in giving Pakistan and North Korea nuclear weapons. There, too, the "... and your plan to fix that, dear Belgium and Netherlands, is what, exactly?"

But it's critical to current political beliefs to say otherwise, half of people are mad enough to deny Iran even wants nuclear weapons, so you're probably about to deny physical reality. Have at it.

Kind of like the "detail" from the Iraq war nobody is allowed to talk about anymore. That Ali Chemicali was convicted of using chemical weapons, first by the UN, then by Iraqi courts, in both cases supported by people standing there with chemical burns. But there NEVER WERE chemical weapons (and certainly not a research program or production facilities) in Iraq. NEVER!

The US politically approved history is as stupid and full of lies as any other countries' history.

So there. Pretty sure I have offended and insulted the preferred political beliefs of a solid 90% of USians and Europeans. Sadly, doesn't make it any less true.

▲defrost 16 hours ago | parent [-]

So ... you're either referring to Iran being non compliant to a deal eight years before it was made, or you're referring to Iran being non compliant to a deal after a major party to the deal withdrew.

Is that correct?

▲spwa4 15 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't care much for this discussion. Obviously, the deal doesn't actually matter for anything other than feelings. And no, I don't mean official findings I mean statements. Plus there was "a deal" before the deal (before 2013 I mean), which Iran violated even more than the nuclear deal. Iran technically first agreed to not enrich uranium in 1968 and the current government first promised not to enrich uranium in 1974, and they haven't even bothered to withdraw from that (oh, and technically that agreement says it can never be withdrawn from, but let's call that a problem with the usual UN level of realism. It's like what UN GA keeps doing with that "other" conflict: pointing out Hamas has signed a multiple treaties to fight terrorism, therefore they must be fighting terrorism and then saying that Israeli actions violated those treaties)

The simple fact is that Iran cannot be allowed to enrich uranium under any circumstances, deal, no deal, conditions, ... this is political, when push comes to shove it doesn't matters. It cannot be allowed to happen, obviously.

Iran has been under agreement that they weren't going to enrich uranium for longer than the current Iran exists. All Iranian nuclear actions violated NPT, and of course the help they got from Russia and Germany, and the help they gave to North Korea also violated NPT, but that, I'm sure doesn't matter. 1000 violations by Iran, 10 really big violations, and one by Trump/US. Three guesses which part of the list you'll be focusing on ...

This does also mean that the details, AND any blame or who violated what treaty first doesn't matter (cue the endless discussion you're about to start trying to make it sound reasonable what Iran did, it's the "US's fault", right? Or maybe Europe? I've read tankies claiming that. Hell some communists are making the point that if Iran beats the US in this conflict, they'll finally become a true communist state, what they were prevented before by evil Britain capitalist oil companies. Really. An article saying that is on marxist.com). Obviously Iran was the first to violate NPT, both as a principle and as a deal/treaty, but let's say you're right and it wasn't Iran. Or that the JCPOA somehow forgave them and makes everything that happened previously just peachy, which it of course doesn't ...

Fact is Iran has attacked everyone they possibly could, from Argentina to Saddam Hussain, from the Taliban to Norway. Everyone knows what will happen if they get nukes.

▲JumpCrisscross 15 hours ago | parent [-]

> I don't care much for this discussion

Then why did you start this tangent?!