Remix.run Logo
▲ userbinator 3 hours ago

While Comcast has deployed plenty of fiber throughout the US, its cable Internet service makes the final connection to homes with coaxial cable. This results in upload speeds being far slower than download speeds. In contrast, fiber-to-the-home service can provide symmetrical upload and download speeds.

You can get symmetric DOCSIS, and apparently Comcast do offer that service[1]. Likewise, FTTH can be asymmetric if they set the traffic shaping that way. IMHO the only things that matter to the average user about an Internet connection are bandwidth, volume, and availability. As long as it terminates in WiFi or a standard Ethernet connector and passes IP traffic at the rate I paid for, I personally don't care what the physical infrastructure beyond the demarc is.

In fact, anecdotes from a few people I know have been that service interruptions actually increased after they upgraded to FTTH from DOCSIS.

[1] https://corporate.comcast.com/press/releases/comcast-multi-g...

▲RulerOf 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> As long as it terminates in WiFi or a standard Ethernet connector and passes IP traffic at the rate I paid for, I personally don't care what the physical infrastructure beyond the demarc is.

I get that attitude, but coax connections are fragile in a way that fiber is not. Water infiltration, bad crimping jobs, unterminated ends in the neighbor's house all cause signal degradation that is extremely time and labor intensive to identify and fix.

Cable is an excellent solution for distributing broadcast analog radio signals over a private line cheaply and efficiently, but two-way digital signals over the same medium aren't as robust as their fiber-based counterpart.

ISP outages are one thing, but if you ever experience service degradation—and not a full outage, but tear-your-hair-out crap like "my internet goes down for 15 seconds once every 16 hours with no discernible pattern"—and it ends up being some particularly coax-flavored problem, you'll understand what I'm talking about.

▲userbinator an hour ago | parent [-]

my internet goes down for 15 seconds once every 16 hours with no discernible pattern

Actually that's exactly the type of complaints I've heard from those who upgraded to FTTH. My understanding is that fiber is a lot more fragile than copper, and installation and testing requires significantly more expensive equipment, although it is cheaper for longer distances and theoretically capable of higher bandwidth (but the transceivers on each end are also a significant part of the cost.)

▲throwaway_new_1 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> IMHO the only things that matter to the average user about an Internet connection are bandwidth, volume, and availability.

Latency, quality of networking gear, the experience of connecting devices, customer service, price of bundled services etc.

There is a lot that matters. As someone who’s worked in networking gear and both ISPs and customers, those who just want a connection and manage the rest are a minuscule percentage.

Almost everyone who buys a connection wants it to work perfect always and when not they want a simple step to fix it (like a reboot). Achieving this has a lot of moving parts.

▲throwaway_new_1 2 hours ago | parent [-]

To add more context: fiber allows for complete remote configuration and management. While docsis does have a lot of control it’s an old technology with lot less available for remote monitoring and configuration.

With fiber you can even change the WiFi password without ever having to connect to the WiFi. Yes that’s worse for privacy and security but it’s going to save you in hundreds of thousands of dollars in customer service calls.

▲ssl-3 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I don't understand this point of distinction for a couple of different reasons:

I've remotely configured wifi services within end-user DOCSIS equipment; doing this was part of my job, and was part of a service that customers paid for

My FTTH connection at home terminates in a pretty dumb little box that does not have any wifi capabilities at all, and this box sits on the Internet-facing side of my firewall

▲toast0 31 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is TR-069 provisioning right? Pretty much all types of CPE support it, Fiber, DSL, DOCSIS. There's nothing specifically about fiber that makes it better or worse for remote provisioning, except maybe the hardware tends to be a lot newer.

▲LoganDark an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

That's horrifying. No wonder people are so obsessive about swapping out their ISP-provided fiber modems -- even moreso than they were about DOCSIS.

▲LoganDark an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Comcast is indeed starting to offer symmetric DOCSIS. I recently saw my upload speed move from a completely useless 35 Mbps to a much better 2350 Mbps. The Comcast tech really did not want to upgrade my DOCSIS 3.1 modem to a DOCSIS 4.0 modem, which was required for upload speeds to exceed 400 Mbps, but they thankfully did. The previous modem didn't even support Wi-Fi 7. (Though I now thankfully use this one in bridge mode. What a relief -- I hope to never touch their mandatory fucking mobile app ever again.)

Note that I had to make an FCC false advertising complaint earlier this year before they would upgrade my area. You should try it, the executive who contacted me was surprisingly willing to drill into the control structures to figure out what was going on.

▲SV_BubbleTime 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Symmetric docsis is pretty awesome though… still dealing with asymmetric for pay per view reasons elsewhere!

▲msh 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Cabel/docsis have a bad rep so that's the reason they are lying.