Remix.run Logo
▲ jsLavaGoat 2 hours ago

I worked in a lab where a geologist was taking soundings to understand the geometry of plate techtonics. Smart guy but needed a geek for the Sun server, so I got to ride along.

Anyway, lots of things are "actually geometry" but chemistry is kind of the one science that really does just reduce to QED first principles pretty cleanly. You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.

Arithmetic can be "actually geometry" if you're good with a compass and straight edge and the use of geometry to understand numbers is old.

Anyway, I'd say chemistry is actually physics and that may or not be actually math of any kind. At least in part, probably.

▲dnautics an hour ago | parent | next [-]

> You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.

What? All of chemistry is basically emergent. we do not for example have clean, reducible models of the details of why aufbau diagrams fill the way they do in the transition metals, it's very hand-wavey and extremely empirical. Why does iron freely access the +3 and +2 states in ferrocene? Like why are titanium [-2] and [+1] states even a thing at all. Why does zirconocene have just enough space to do an p-pi sigma bond in ziegler natta catalysis? What the fuck even with p-pi sigma bonds in the first place?

> chemistry is actually physics

You cannot throw a physicist at chemistry and expect insight or even understanding to come easily. The defining mentality and approach are just so different. So much so that probably the methodological approach should be a better definition of what constitutes chemistry vs physics.

▲jsLavaGoat 26 minutes ago | parent [-]

You know more about chemistry than me, but when I studied emergence it was considered a more transparent layer than, say, psychology. It was considered at least something worth questioning as recently as 2022. [1]

Anyway, no one outside of your specialty knows what you're talking about and so that is congruent with my "you don't hear much about" which I think you read as "does not exist." I don't know if there are emergent chemical phenomena, just that they are thrown around to mere mortals like me the way evolution or social behavior are. Or life itself.

This isn't about physicists and chemists, obviously or their praxis. It's about what is actually happening and if you can explain it solely using the tools of the underlying layer.

You have succeeded in out esotericking me, but I don't think anything I stated was incorrect.

[1] "Nevertheless, the matter of emergence in chemistry is far from settled." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9814932/ (2022)

▲smj-edison 2 minutes ago | parent [-]

How are you defining emergence? Because I've always thought of it as simple rules that compose creating completely counter-intuitive results, and man is there a lot of that in chemistry.

▲n923263 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.

To be fair, you absolutely do; it's just usually called something different. Like "biology".

▲jsLavaGoat 29 minutes ago | parent [-]

That's not what I meant. There are emergent phenomena built on chemistry, but what's emergent at the level of chemistry itself that doesn't reduce to physics?

When I was in college anyway, it wasn't part of the discussion.

▲n923263 21 minutes ago | parent [-]

Literally nothing at the level of chemistry - emergent or not - doesn't reduce to physics.

https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/435:_Purity / https://xkcd.com/435