Remix.run Logo
▲ mminer237 a day ago

They're saying it's not a cyber attack, AI-based or not. It's just a good old fashioned production bug, like the last several.

▲tedd4u a day ago | parent | next [-]

It's easy to believe this is just a software or software hosting problem. United has had several outages related specifically to their weight-and-balance tools:

   • Today       : ~90 min departure hold; 400+ delayed flights
   • Aug  6, 2025: Multi-airport ground stops; 1,000+ delays, 200+ cancellations 
   • Apr  1, 2019: ~150 United Express regional flights delayed or held
   • Oct 13, 2016: Overnight departure holds and cascading system-wide delays
And if you broaden to include all flight-affecting IT issues, that adds in these dispatch, operations, and electronic comms outages:

   • Jul 19, 2024: Global ground stop; widespread delays and cancellations
   • Sep  5, 2023: ~1 hr nationwide FAA ground stop; 260 delays (~9% of schedule)
   • Jan 22, 2017: ~2.5 hr nationwide domestic ground stop
   • Jul  8, 2015: ~2 hr nationwide ground stop; 1,100+ delays, 60+ cancellations
   • Jun  2, 2015: ~1 hr domestic departure pause; widespread delays
   • Jun 20, 2007: ~2 hr nationwide departure halt; hundreds of delays, 24 cancellations
They do seem to be increasing in frequency though.
▲Tempest1981 a day ago | parent [-]

Not just United:

Dec 2024 weighing issue at American Airlines:

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42501605

Jan 2023 tail-strike:

- Bug identified after Alaska Airlines planes bump runway while taking off

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34895061

iirc, the tail-strike was a concurrency issue that occurred under load, sending artificially low weight calculations to the flight crew

▲vlovich123 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Are they legally required to be honest? In the past companies have hidden attacks because they fear it makes them a repeat target and it shakers the confidence of their clients.

▲gruez a day ago | parent [-]

Yes, because of the threat of securities fraud lawsuits.

▲vlovich123 a day ago | parent | next [-]

I don’t believe that’s the case. That only applies if the breach might be materially relevant and that’s the same wording used in the SEC 4-day reporting rule. There’s even been pushback against the SEC trying to pierce the corporate veil (successful with Joe Sullivan, not with SolarWinds). I’m not so sure it’s as clear cut as you claim.

▲fivetenpen a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

They can certainly lie if they are directed to by the government. And some governments are opposed to AI regulation as a matter of national security.

▲triceratops a day ago | parent [-]

AI regulation won't help if you're being attacked by AI.

▲joquarky 20 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Historically, what kind of penalties are applied as the result of those lawsuits?

▲gibsonf1 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Such as someone using genAI for mission-critical production code.

▲schaefer a day ago | parent [-]

If you have evidence to back up your claim, please share it. Or is this baseless speculation?

▲paganel a day ago | parent | next [-]

The evidence should now point to the contrary, i.e. that the code was not AI-generated. There are many people on forums like this one saying that at their (big, although not-named) big companies they haven't touched actual code when programming for the last 6 months or so, and judging by what I encounter on my search for a job right now this is what the general "spirit" of the industry is.

▲solid_fuel a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Haven't you heard that the age of manual coding is over? You can check almost any comment section here and see people loudly proclaiming that no one writes code by hand anymore - the entire industry has gone to genAI coding.

I don't buy that narrative for the whole industry, but I have seen management at a lot of tech companies aggressively pushing LLMs for coding, and in the process they often expect increased delivery speed. That means generated code that has not been properly reviewed or designed is often being shipped and more frequent outages would not be a surprising result.

▲carabiner a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is basically skynet.

▲cowlevel a day ago | parent [-]

the system that is down is literally a sky net

▲IAmGraydon a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Who needs cyber attacks when we’re very good at sabotaging our own critical infrastructure with vibe coded nonsense?