Remix.run Logo
▲ haickernews a day ago

From the article:

>In SafetyKit’s evaluations involving drawings or animations that sexualize children, the classifier detected 90% of cases

>This is the first CSAM classifier with broad availability that has a specific signal on indicating if CSAM may be AI generated.

What children are being abused by drawings or AI generated images, stories, etc?

I understand the cases where it's problematic to make such content based on real children and share it, and I think it's probably a bad idea to allow photorealistic child porn to be publicly posted on the internet for the sake of not confusing law enforcement (in the same way posting misinformation is harmful), but if these images are not realistic, or if it's just text, or if they are realistic but they aren't being shared on the internet, who is being harmed?

▲nonethewiser 18 hours ago | parent [-]

Your perspective is entirely consistent with a consent/harm framework for sexual ethics. If it's all about consent and harm how is privately arranging and viewing 1s and 0s like this bad?

Do you also find these permissible, since there is no consent violation nor harm?

- Necrophilia

- Bestiality

- Adult incest

The problem with consent/harm framework is that you either have to start arguing some very indirect and abstract harm or you have to accept conclusions that everyone else thinks are just kind of fucked up to be consistent.

Once you introduce some form of natural law into your ethical framework it's trivial to say all these things are not permissible but I guess AI generated child porn and necrophilia is preferable to natural law to many.

▲haickernews 17 hours ago | parent [-]

Necrophilia harms the loved ones of the deceased by desecrating a dead body. Though the dead are non-entities and can't suffer, I still think it would be disrespectful to have sex with a dead body if it was against their wishes in life.

Bestiality is obviously harmful to animals. Best case dubious if you assume animals could consent and would be willing, but seems like there's little evidence for that.

Adult incest is only harmful if it leads to pregnancy and birth defects.

Finding something gross doesn't mean it's immoral.

I can understand the arguments others have about AI generated child porn creating more demand, but I think we're rapidly approaching a world where human beings can engage in any kind of (what would otherwise be harmful) behavior in VR, assuming we don't all die from misaligned AI. I would prefer to live in a world where I can fulfill my desires in a harmless way, even if they're abhorrent to others, rather than a world of value lock-in based on antiquated views of harm.

▲nonethewiser 5 hours ago | parent [-]

>Necrophilia harms the loved ones of the deceased by desecrating a dead body.

In the scenario where the dead body doesn't have any loved ones whats wrong with necrophilia?

>Adult incest is only harmful if it leads to pregnancy and birth defects

And when it doesn't lead to pregnancy and birth defects? Are you OK with incest then?

▲haickernews 41 minutes ago | parent [-]

Personally, it seems polite to allow someone to have autonomy over their dead body as a last wish. Necrophilia would be disrespectful in the same way an organ donor would likely not want their cadaver used for testing weapons. If you could "3D print" cadavers with others likenesses, performed sexual acts on it, and did not let information leak to the outside world, I think this would be fine.

Regarding incest, yes. I don't see the harm.