Remix.run Logo
▲ saghm 6 hours ago

Honestly, I can't help but hope that ends up leading to enough popular support for more regulation for AI that something gets implemented. On the other hand, there's also ample historical precedent for hoping that a mass movement heading in the right direction ends up stopping at the point that feels reasonable and then being surprised when the momentum continues and people like me looking foolish for thinking that it wouldn't, so I might just be overly optimistic.

▲swatcoder 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

AI is not the cause of this kind of problem and it's regulation won't make it go away. Maybe it needs regulation, maybe it doesn't, but you're missing what's happening if you think that's what these widespread failures and vulnerabilities are about.

AI is acting as a sudden precipitator for problems that have been latent and growing for at least 15-20 years.

In pursuit of maximally rapid innovation and reduced capital expenditure, the software industry adopted a "move fast and break things" mentality and homogenized code and service infrastructure over a few winning cloud vendors, SaaS providers, and code solutions/frameworks/packages/etc.

The pitch was that you could rely on downstream experts to do better work than you could, that the biggest vendors and publishers had the best experts, that have them invest the capital would look better on your accounts, and that their scale would give you the best value for your investment.

The caveat is that effectively all technology products have serious faults lurking in them, even with the finest expertise working on them (not that most actually had that), and that when everybody homogenizes over the same providers and solution the industry shifts from a bubbling froth of localized bugs to a heavily correlated house of cards where widely correlated failures manifest in widespread collapse and catastrophe.

Whoops.

AI is acting as a breeze against the house of cards, but lots of things could have and would have and did, especially as it continued to inflate year over year.

▲saghm 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

If you're saying the parent comment I responded to wasn't talking about AI, what are you saying they were talking about? If you agree they were, why are you trying to correct me instead of them?

▲swatcoder 4 hours ago | parent [-]

From experience, since the parent commenter didn't specify, I would take the "coworkers" as having a vague sense of dread and distrust with no real confident insight to the cause. They're likely to nod along to any explanation they hear from anyone they think is more technical or news-following than themselves, and then maybe repeat whatever last such they heard when chatting. With the occasional exception of politics, that's how most people approach technical topics outside of their expertise. I didn't guess what they might have in mind today at all, and didn't feel the need to.

But you did speak directly to AI, and specifically to advocate for regulation of it, which is why I replied to you. You were being specific and material in a way that the parent commenter was not, and that invited a different response.

▲saghm 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I didn't specifically claim that it was the direct cause of this though, so you still decided to confront something I didn't claim over something the parent comment didn't claim

▲randomNumber7 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

> With the occasional exception of politics, that's how most people approach technical topics outside of their expertise

You give other people way too much credit.

▲retwakm4 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

[dead]

▲alala-lala-lon 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]

▲SoftTalker 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What's actually more likley are power grabs executed while the chaos is attracting all the attention. That's how we ended up with DHS.

▲canibalrex 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I don't really see how regulation for AI helps. Companies were on this crash course of trusting Microsoft (or pick your other dependency that cant be eliminated as it is a monopoly or the minimum) to provide more and more of surrounding infrastructure. Until they had AI to run simulations of outside.competence there wasn't a snowball's chance in hell they were competent enough at IT to run someone else's infrastructure.