Remix.run Logo
▲ mlmonkey an hour ago

The world has plenty of barren, desert areas; do we really need to put solar panels in grass fields? I'm not against it, but just wondering why not just use barren land? Surely it's got to be cheaper than putting them grassland?

▲noddingham an hour ago | parent | next [-]

I believe transmission is an issue so having the solar array nearer to where the energy is needed is important. Not that we couldn't spend a lot of effort to figure out better transmission methods but that's one of the reasons why blanketing a desert is not as effective as it seems on the surface.

▲niwtsol an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Is transmission an issue due to physical limitations, capital expenditure, or some bad govt policy? China has high voltage lines from their western deserts to eastern cities, so it makes me think the physics of moving the electricity from unpopulated -> populated is easy enough, this just seems like permitting/government nonsense that prevents us from having nice things.

▲pyrale 34 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Capex and cost of maintenance is definitely something that factors in this kind of decisions, especially for smaller, commercial projects.

▲ericd an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

All of the above, the nimby opposition is often fierce.

▲kccqzy an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It’s as usual a mix of all the issues. Recall that the United States has had essentially flat energy demand for much of the last twenty years or so, so there are no incentives to build new transmission lines.

Also the OP was thinking that the land under the solar panels could be put into better use, but such ultra high voltage transmission lines themselves come with restrictions on what can be built beneath them.

▲hibikir 22 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

You are still wasting a lot of energy with long distance transmission lines. We are arguing with physics.

▲actionfromafar an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Everything is government nonsense when you think about it. At least we will always have clean, beatiful coal I guess.

▲toomuchtodo an hour ago | parent [-]

As coal burn declines, rising power demand will be primarily met by renewables - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50500905 - November 2026

- Coal’s share of generation will likely decline from 17% in 2025 to 15% by 2027 as 13 GW of capacity is scheduled to retire by the end of next year, EIA said.

Not many coal plants left to go.

https://www.sierraclub.org/coal/coal-plant-map

▲actionfromafar 42 minutes ago | parent [-]

Thank God for small mercies. I was just being cheeky/bitter about how when it comes to energy, everything is about government subsidies/investment but so far, fossil got so much more.

▲eastbound 27 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

> China has high voltage lines from their western deserts to eastern cities,

Long lines are AC, they must come from dams or coal generators, still with a huge loss. Solar is DC. It can be transformed at a loss.

▲bluGill 13 minutes ago | parent [-]

Long lines are often DC. Talk to an electrical engineer for details, but for long distances DC works better. For distances at the scale of a US state works great, but as you get longer distances DC becomes better again.

▲francescovv an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Yep. And don't forget solar has availability factor that isn't all that great. This further increases required transmission capacity.

▲toomuchtodo an hour ago | parent [-]

Sort of. Battery storage colocated with solar generation reduces curtailment and can increase transmission utilization. With enough solar and some battery storage, you can achieve the equivalent of base load/firm generation 24/7. Every battery storage installation also becomes a grid health support node, able to assist in voltage and frequency response, as well as providing synthetic inertia.

CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 Cycles, 30-Year Life - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50399657 - November 2026

Ember Energy: Solar electricity every hour of every day is here and it changes everything - https://ember-energy.org/latest-insights/solar-electricity-e... - June 21st, 2025

https://ember-energy.org/app/uploads/2025/06/Ember-24-Hour-S... [pdf]

- 1 kW of stable solar power across 24 hours of the day can be achieved on an average day in a sunny place like Las Vegas with 5 kW of fixed solar panels and a 17 kWh battery.

- The sunniest regions in the world can get as close as 97% of the way to 24/365 solar – stable supply every hour of every day of the year.

- Achieving 97% of the way to 24/365 solar in very sunny regions is now affordable at as low as $104/MWh, cheaper than coal and nuclear and 22% less than a year earlier.

▲wredcoll an hour ago | parent [-]

Does that price include any extra transmission costs? Is that a thing?

▲toomuchtodo an hour ago | parent [-]

This study is seven years old, but explains the nuance of transmission costs in the US. Broadly speaking, the closer you can get low carbon generation to demand and load centers and avoid long haul transmission, the better (check out https://web.archive.org/web/20261114074622/https://www.eia.g... | yellow is solar, purple are battery storage).

https://emp.lbl.gov/news/new-national-lab-study-quantifies-0

https://emp.lbl.gov/publications/improving-estimates-transmi...

Improving estimates of transmission capital costs for utility-scale wind and solar projects to inform renewable energy policy - https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S03014215193058... - December 2019

- Estimating the overall costs of transmission needed to integrate variable renewable energy (VRE) onto the grid is challenging. An improved understanding of these transmission costs would support electricity system planning as VRE penetrations increase. This paper brackets VRE transmission capital costs using multiple approaches based on interconnection studies, actual transmission projects, capacity-expansion simulation models, and aggregated U.S. VRE-related transmission expenditures. Each approach possesses advantages and drawbacks, and combining the approaches lends confidence to the results. The resulting range of average levelized VRE transmission costs is $1–$10/MWh, which is generally lower than earlier estimates in the literature. These transmission capital costs can increase the direct plant-level levelized cost of VRE by 3%–33%, based on levelized costs of energy of $29–$56/MWh for utility-scale wind and $36–$46/MWh for utility-scale solar. As VRE deployment continues to expand, policy makers can use this information to (1) assess the benefits of transmission avoidance and deferral when comparing distributed energy resources versus utility-scale projects, (2) evaluate the potential costs of large-scale public transmission investments, and (3) better analyze system-level costs of utility-scale VRE technologies. Future research can expand on the framework presented here by providing a review of operation and maintenance costs for transmission systems.

I don't have a link handy at the moment, but there is also a project to use machine learning to maximize the power existing transmission lines can carry using real time monitoring of their health metrics to push harder towards maximum safe utilization (versus more conservative limits).

▲chamomeal an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

A guy I know works on a sustainability research farm. They basically spend all their time trying out different strategies and technology to figure out how farms can be sustainable without sacrificing productivity. It’s a non profit. They’re well respected in the surrounding farming community, and they get other farmers to adopt new practices.

Anyway there’s my ethos. This farm has solar panels only on top of grazing pastures, cause it keeps cows cool. They’re not like blotting out the sun or anything. It’s a productivity and health boost for the cattle, and renewable energy that runs other systems on the farm.

▲jgilias an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

My country has none. It’s all forests and grassland. Plenty of solar farms with sheep grazing on them. I quite enjoy using locally generated electricity as opposed to depending on some other country for our energy needs. We still do that ofc for oil and gas as we don’t have those.

▲schiffern an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

  >The world has plenty of barren, desert areas
Often (but not always) these areas are actually degraded by human influence.

In these cases, we should regenerate the ecosystems we destroyed, not treat it as "free" surface area that doesn't matter just because we damaged it.

No sane Antique Shop has a "you break it, it's now yours to do whatever you like" policy. I wonder why? :)

▲9072997 an hour ago | parent [-]

> you break it, it's now yours to do whatever you like

I mean, you break it, then you pay for it/deal with the consequences, then the broken pieces are yours to do whatever you like with. That is generally how it works.

I don't think leaving the land as-is is going to be better than putting solar panels on it. In fact, is seems like solar panels might be better than leaving the land alone: https://www.ecoportal.net/en/sahara-solar-panels-double-sahe...

▲schiffern 26 minutes ago | parent [-]

  >I don't think leaving the land as-is is going to be better than putting solar panels on it
I agree, but who said "leave as-is?" I said we should regenerate the land.

If some folks think it's hard to regenerate desert land, it just goes to show that perhaps we should be learning more about ecosystems and how they work.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WCli0gyNwL0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f-sRcVkZ9yg

▲philipkglass an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Like noddingham said, avoiding long distance transmission is one reason. There is a lot of opposition to new electrical transmission projects, which makes them slow and difficult to construct, even in countries that otherwise support renewable energy (like Germany). In the United States, the SunZia transmission line entered operation this year:

https://patternenergy.com/sunzia-comes-online/

It took 3 years to build from start of construction but 20 years from start of planning:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SunZia_Wind_and_Transmission#H...

▲Havoc 19 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

That’s why Europe keeps talking about putting solar on North Africa.

It’s not a bad idea but comes with a number of substantial challenges so hasn’t seen much traction this far

▲jsphweid an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Grazing animals like shade too, like silvopasture. Might as well be something that also benefits humans?

▲sophacles 4 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Why would it be cheaper? That's not a given.

All sorts of reasons make sense though:

* farmer wants supplemental income - if X fewer sheep means you can have > Xprice_of_sheep dollars from solar. Not to mention diversifying income streams.

Transmission losses are real.

* not everywhere has access to a desert.

* A lot of places are barren "deserts" due to overgrazing, and the overgrazing causes a lack of shade that is a positive feedback on desert conditions. Solar panels can provide just enough shade to bring back plants and grazing area.

▲ an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲iamflimflam1 36 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

As others have pointed out, transmission. But also accessibility - being able to service these things is important.

▲undersuit an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Barren land? Where's that? Are you thinking US deserts?

https://www.fws.gov/project/wildlife-friendly-solar-energy

▲KaiserPro an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

grassland tends to be nearer population centres.

▲stickfigure an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Dunno where you live, but here in California pretty much every square foot of undeveloped earth is covered with some kind of foliage. Grasses, shrubs, chaparral, forests, etc. Grass is just another ground cover, it grows by itself.

There's nothing really "barren" in a natural landscape. Maybe dry lakebeds?

▲aleqs an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Another thing I'm wondering - would putting solar panels in the desert help moisturize/greenify the desert over time because of the extra shade?

▲tygon 2 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Yes, but keep in mind the ecological impact. We see deserts as dead and devoid of life, but many plant and animal species thrive in these "barren" climates, so changing them as its own adverse effects and pushback.

▲throw-qqqqq an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think it should yeah.

Many efforts to reverse desertification, plant trees and grow stuff/crops in the semi-shade. Shade does a lot for keeping moisture in the ground, but it’s much less effective than tree cover, as the roots draw water up from deep below etc.

▲lukan an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Yes it does. China has done it big scale and studies show this effect. (But it does not happen overnight)

▲ an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]
[deleted]
▲ForHackernews an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Sibling comment mentioned, but China is trying:

https://www.scmp.com/news/china/science/article/3363108/grea...

▲jeffbee an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

[flagged]