Remix.run Logo
▲ poulpy123 an hour ago

I would have expected a modern language to have an extensive datetime library in its standard library

▲lambda an hour ago | parent | next [-]

The problem with this model is that then you try to build all of the libraries that you anticipate users are going to need in one big go before you release version 1 of you language. Because you're trying to do a lot at once, they don't ask get the proper attention they deserve. Then, because of stability guarantees, you're stuck only making backwards compatible changes in the future (or you risk either constant breaking changes, or big changes where a lot changes at once forking the ecosystem, like Python 2 to 3). So if you made any mistakes in the library, you're stuck with them, only being about to deprecate but never really remove them.

The alternative is to keep a relatively small standard library, and a good package manager, to make it easier for people to iterate on API design in third party packages. Major version changes in a single library can have much less impact accross the ecosystem than standard library packages. Eventually you may get a de facto standard, and sometimes they are then later incorporated into the standard library.

This model isn't without its downsides; it can sometimes mean fragmentation when standardization would help, sometimes these de facto standard libraries can become important enough that they run into the same ecosystem fragmentation issues on major releases. But it allows for more flexibility.

The latter model is what the Rust project decided on for everything outside of the most fundamental time types. Dates and times and timezones are notoriously hard to model in code, and easy to create API designs that are full of footguns, so this is a place where that extra freedom to iterate was more important than standardizing on an API early on.

That iteration has led to a number of different libraries, including time, chrono, and now jiff, allowing for exploring the space of API design to really get it right rather than being stuck with what was available early on.

▲dminik an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Any modern language recognizes that some things are inherently complex and will always have tradeoffs that certain users won't be satisfied with and that will be locked in forever. Such modern languages then let users pick whatever approach they actually need by implementing sensible package management.

▲darksaints an hour ago | parent [-]

A default standard encompassing the most common usecases is a completely reasonable approach. Having a date/time library in the standard library does not preclude other libraries, it just makes it the default and keeps ecosystem integration sane. Not to mention the massive potential reduction in supply chain attacks.

▲kbolino 5 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

In this particular matter, I can't help but be biased against your perspective due to Go. In that language, the desire to meet the "most common usescases" has led to an IMO pathologically bad attitude towards doing this right. In Rust, only the bare primitives are exposed -- Instant, SystemTime, Duration -- but these are sufficient for others to build better abstractions. Whereas, in Go, all of the primitives are kept hidden behind a "good enough" (it's not) abstract API, and you have to break out O/S-specific and/or unstable code if you want to do things better.

▲masklinn 11 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Having a date/time library in the standard library actually makes it very difficult for other libraries to take off, and when it's deeply deficient (which is generally the case, turns out time is quite hard) it's actively detrimental to users of the ecosystem, both because it's hell to use and because it teaches them to do things incorrectly. Which then makes an innovative library have a harder time take off, because they need to fix most of their possible users.

▲solidsnack9000 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm not sure this makes sense for a systems programming language -- but I can see it for an application programming language.

For a systems programming language, Rust is relatively easy to write applications in -- but I suspect standard library choices (and other choices) will be driven by the systems side for the foreseeable future.

▲tredre3 an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Rust doesn't even have an async runtime in its standard library, despite async being part of the language. They believe increased reliance on third party dependencies is better for the ecosystem. Things like supply chain risks or disparate documentation or conflicting dependencies or enormous .cargo are seen as less of a problem than having a built-in API that could go stale one day.

▲afdbcreid an hour ago | parent [-]

As I've said in other places, supply chain risks have nothing to do with things not being in std, only with them not being official - and things can be (and are) official without being included in std.

Documentation certainly has nothing to do with it.

Other factors you mentioned are more convincing.

▲sunshowers an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

A poorly designed one, maybe. My understanding is that the Temporal model is a very recent invention.

▲masklinn an hour ago | parent [-]

In fairness, Temporal largely follows the model originally defined by Joda, and refined in java.time. So I'd say that Java is probably one of the few languages with a well designed datetime library in the standard library.

Temporal does improve some things (it has more strict zoning / less defaults, and improves serialization through RFC 9557), but some of the divergences are not necessarily improvements and rather divergences of opinion (e.g. java.time wilfully made non-ISO calendars second-class, Temporal makes them first class more like Joda, and it's one of the things Colebourne — the lead author of Joda and java.time — strongly disagrees with[1], but the Temporal authors have pretty compelling reasons for it[2]).

[1] https://blog.joda.org/2009/11/why-jsr-310-isn-joda-time_4941... https://github.com/tc39/proposal-temporal/issues/5 https://github.com/tc39/proposal-temporal/issues/1454

[2] https://tc39.es/proposal-temporal/docs/calendar-review#why-a...

▲vips7L an hour ago | parent [-]

I really enjoy working with java.time. It's one of the best additions to the standard library.