| ▲ | lambdaone a day ago | |
The author is being intentionally provocative, as they admit in their first sentence. I can see what they are trying to get at, which is that film-makers should not abuse HDR and set their exposure intentionally for viewer comfort, rather than trying to fix everything in post, but shooting Rec. 709, an old colour standard with wonky primaries derived from old-fashioned CRT TV phosphors, seems like a really peculiar way of going about it. "Make it look like DVD" should not be the ideal of film-making. | ||
| ▲ | prmoustache 20 hours ago | parent [-] | |
> "Make it look like DVD" should not be the ideal of film-making. I don't know, it really depends what is the target audience. I don't know the technical details but I found out that many modern TV shows have a lots of scenes with what I would call the netflix/youtube influencer's look with a very dark room and various small lights in the background that just don't work well if you don't have a very good screen. And a lot of people are watching these productions from devices of varying qualities. It is a bit like criticizing the loudness war and overuse of compressors in music production. Sure it makes for a huge loss of details when listening in your living room with a good quality equipment and in a quiet place. But most people listen to music in hostile environment: in a vehicle, in a car, in badly insulated rooms/apprtments with noisy neighbors and traffic, with shitty bluetooth speakers, etc. Sometimes you can target for the beat equipmemt, sometimes you should focus on making stuff work on what people use. It is the same when writing software and accounting for the still large amount of computers used globally with a screen resolution below 1080p. https://gs.statcounter.com/screen-resolution-stats/desktop/w... | ||