Remix.run Logo
▲ jiggawatts a day ago

> Understand that HDR video is not the same thing as HDR photography. They use different science and apply different technology to the sensor image.

This is where the author lost all credibility.

I have a Nikon Z8 "hybrid" camera that can take breathtaking 4K HDR footage or HDR still images.

I can easily develop both the stills and video from the same sensor, the same lenses, and interleave them in the same HDR video and have the two be nigh indistinguishable. It just looks like pressing the "pause button" on the video.

The differences -- if any -- are largely down to historical or stylistic choices, and can be freely changed depending on one's preference.

At the end of the day, they're just... lookup tables.

▲KaiserPro a day ago | parent | next [-]

HDR is a thing thats related, but not the same as this.

Its also complicated by the issue that HDR photography is all about compressing many more bits than 8 into an 8 bit image.

HDR video is a way to represent physically brighter output than 8bit on a screen.

Capturing HDR isn't that hard anymore, especially for stills. I remember seeing a light probe camera that could capture an entire film set, where we could adjust the exposure in post to the point where I could see the filament of the tungsten bulb, and the bloke eating a sandwich in the dark.

▲dofm a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The author lost no credibility.

I assumed from that sentence that the author was trying to make the point to an audience more experienced with stills that video HDR is not like multiple-merged-exposure HDR, which is historically what the term HDR has generally been taken to mean in the stills world. Basically they are saying “put that interpretation out of your mind”.

Of course, in the hybrid mirrorless world, it’s identical to a single-shot HDR.

▲jiggawatts a day ago | parent [-]

He talks specifically about cameras that take a single-shot HDR image: "Yes, there are camera and displays capable of some level of HDR".

Except that "some level" in even my previous Nikon D800 camera has been a 14-bit RAW with 13.5 stops of dynamic range, which I got back in 2012!

That puts it somewhere between the VESA DisplayHDR 600 and 1000 standards, which is plenty HDR.

I've recently been going through my old photos from the 2010s using the latest Adobe Lightroom, which can natively process RAW images into HDR output, and they look spectacular.

It's not cheating, it's not multiple exposure, it's not local contrast. The results look like you paused a Netflix 4K HDR show.

▲dofm 21 hours ago | parent | next [-]

You don't need to talk to me about DSLRs and dynamic range — I have owned many DSLRs dating back to one of the earliest (the Fuji S2 Pro — the dynamic range king of its day)

But nevertheless the point I think he is making to the reader is "don't think of this as what you colloquially know as HDR from stills". A surprisingly large number of non-photographers think "HDR" means those gaudy things people used to make from exposure blends.

(I only ever had one proper application for an exposure-blended HDR: a holiday home room that had a spectacular view that I needed to hint at in an interior shot)

▲jiggawatts 21 hours ago | parent [-]

It's possible that he meant old-school "fake" local contrast adaptation HDR, but the way it was phrased implies "new HDR-capable cameras" are somehow not the same as HDR video... which is only technically true in the most pedantic way imaginable.

▲ikatson 21 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

It is a bit apples-to-oranges to compare camera stops to DisplayHDR.

Camera stops are about relative contrast ratios, whereas DisplayHDR is a luminance-first standard where the 600 and 1000 mandate absolute peak output nits [1].

If HDR were defined purely by contrast ratio, an OLED display peaking at just 100 nits would technically be "infinitely HDR" simply because its black level is zero.

[1] https://displayhdr.org/performance-criteria/

▲Melatonic a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I mean they probably do save in different capture formats depending on what camera you're using. But theoretically with a high quality lossless or lossless compressed in either they would be comparable

There's also I suppose the process of making the HDR - with photos sometimes your combing many more into a single HDR frame with theoretically as much latitude as you want. Video your limited probably with two exposures