Remix.run Logo
▲ Spiwux a day ago

I don't understand this post. It doesn't explain the concrete problems with grading log footage. And you can convert log footage to REC709 in a way that would give you the same result as if you'd just recorded in REC709 to begin with. At least for most established camera brands. Maybe this post is referring to grading more fringe brands that have bad/undocumented color science or don't offer proper conversion paths?

Either way it does not explain the concrete issues of recording in log. If you have a strong title like "Stop doing X" you better have some damn good arguments if you think you can tell other people what to do.

▲rickdeckard a day ago | parent | next [-]

He's a colorist, stating that many videographers shoot log incorrectly and decide to defer the work to post-production, creating unnecessary complexity and bad source-material.

The plea is for filmmakers to stop following the hype, use what they are experienced with and take ownership of exposure again ("Many times a videographer will shoot log incorrectly – generally underexposed – expecting to ‘fix it in post’").

Because in his experience log doesn't add substantial value, it creates lower-quality base-material with substantial post-production work.

It makes sense. Creative work comes from decisions being taken, log means that the videographer is not deciding but is deferring the task to post-production, creating a unnecessary burden (and possibly diluting his own creativity).

▲ajasmin an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Couldn't a camera just show a grade in the viewfinder while still recording in a log format. The viewfinder settings could be saved as metadata, perhaps with some margin so that a "saturated" capture can still be brought back a little in post as needed.

▲jpc0 an hour ago | parent [-]

Yes and is generally how I train it for our videographers.

Reference colours and exposure in the target space using a lut on body or on the viewfinder, recording in Log or even Raw because we can change it in post.

Usually the LUT it was shot on is in the metadata.

▲ano-ther 34 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What are good introductions to this? I edit videos from time to time and am puzzled by all the coloring options in Premiere and my cameras.

▲whizzter a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I can kinda see "both sides of it".

Technically, the issue if I'm getting is that the camera physically (or in teh encoding) will be better at capturing within a certain range that you adjusted for, having parts above or below that isn't capture properly and if material is in those above or below ranges the output after grading will not have a good range of values (ie possibly introducing banding).

Underexposing probably feels like a "safe fix" rather than adjusting properly all the time since with more limited ranges it'd be easy to "wash out" with overexposure (irreparably removing things due to clipping), and with budgets cut it's probably easy to just skimp on a lot of these "details" if the system "is capable".

So it's budgets/speed/creativity at shooting time vs material that might just not be good to work with in the end. (Also as he mentions some of these systems aren't as sensitive, probably leaves a situation where some people who's used the better systems just don't realize that it's a problem coming to others).

Edit: Noticed some other comment mentioning that these "log" encodings are 10bits, yeah that's going to leave a bad trail of numeric resolution if you've exposed badly, it'll probably be workable for a huge range but it's not enough by far to recover really badly exposed stuff.

▲rickdeckard a day ago | parent [-]

I see the rationale for the other side. But it's the "safe fix" as you said, to create maximum room for a decision-maker in post.

The way I read it, the point is especially for experienced videographers to stop playing it safe but "making the call".

The author implies that many of them now "shoot for post-production" which basically leaves alot of their skill dormant to just create much more tuning/decision-work down the line.

From the perspective of a colorist it makes alot of sense to me. The shot and its "message" should be decided on-set already, deciding ALL of this in post is not creating as much value as people think, it rather dilutes the work as a whole.

Or as Orson Welles said: "The enemy of art is the absence of limitations"

▲yokoprime a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think the message was "stop trying to fix things in post", but I too am still I bit bewildered as to why it's an issue.

▲poulpy123 20 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I'm not in the field so I can say I'm right, but it's quite common that the "I will fix later" mindset end in in worse result even if it's technically doable because of lack of time, lack of money, lack of interest or more importantly, lack of intent

▲fmajid 13 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It creates more work for the people in post, and while rang can be salvaged, you can have posterization and other artifacts in the end product that degrade image quality.

▲Spiwux a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Upon re-skimming the post with your comment in mind I think you are right. The main issue (from the author's point of view) seems to be: You're more likely to record bad footage in log because you think you can just fix it in post.

That's certainly an interesting take to have (and it could've been compressed to a single paragraph)

▲simoncion a day ago | parent | next [-]

> (and it could've been compressed to a single paragraph)

It seems to me that it was. The essay's opening paragraph is:

  I may ruffle some feathers with [the "Stop Filming in Log" title]; but after years as a colorist, log-encoded clips can be an unnecessary challenge. Using camera log profiles is often a crutch for location and studio set-ups. Or it’s simply used because the internet tells you log = film. That’s just not true. Many times a videographer will shoot log incorrectly – generally underexposed – expecting to ‘fix it in post’. The same issues apply to shooting in camera raw or HDR.
▲fps-hero 21 hours ago | parent [-]

I think it’s necessary to separate the art from the science.

A CCD captures light with a fixed exposure time and analog + digital gain. This gives you a raw, or in photographer speak, RAW frame. The issue being that the required bandwidth to store RAW frames of video is simply too high to be practical.

So, you need some form of compression. RED is a great example of seeing the problem and solving it. Now the issue is compressed RAW video is a patent minefield, and just recorded video equally so.

And so, we are resorting to tricks such as “log raw encoding”, or “just get the videographer to capture it right in the first place” just to get around the limitations of the storage format.

Honestly capturing images and displaying them accurately is such a mess that it’s a miracle that we have more than 8-bits of colour, and that was hard enough as it is. From a RAW Bayer frame to what you see on a monitor preview display is multiple layers of white balance, gain, equalisation, linear to gamma, and whatever your monitor decides to do with the digital signal it’s fed.

▲adgjlsfhk1 12 hours ago | parent [-]

To me, the surprising part is that Bayer has stayed the default. Adding W subpixels that give pure brightness seems like it would make the post processing so much easier (and give you extra contrast since you don't lose as much light to the color filter)

▲rickdeckard a day ago | parent | prev [-]

yep, also my takeaway from the article, and I can see the point.

It's kinda like always shooting photos in RAW, always 4-5 photos of every scene, but then never taking the decision/work which of them is representing the scene you were trying to capture.

▲simondotau a day ago | parent [-]

Shooting RAW makes perfect sense when you’re both photographer and editor. It lets me defer technical and creative decisions until later, freeing me to focus on capturing the moment. Anything technology can do to reduce the number of variables I need to think about at the time of capture is a win imho.

What I’d really like to see in future cameras is subject-aware shutter speed selection, where the camera intelligently sets a minimum shutter speed based on what’s happening in the scene. I’d also love real-time feedback on image quality: the camera analyses a shot within a second of capture and give a subtle beep or chime if, for example, neither eye is in focus or the subject is blurred by motion. The less time I spend worrying about the technical details, the more attention I can give to the photograph itself.

▲rickdeckard a day ago | parent [-]

> "Shooting RAW makes perfect sense when you’re both photographer and editor."

Exactly. And that article describes a scale where both tasks are assigned to different roles, with the videographer mainly working to create more room for later decision-making (than practically needed).

in my (exaggerated) simile to casual RAW photography, the photographer defers technical and creative decisions to a later step that then never happens, so he actually never conveys his message of that captured moment.

In this context the article makes most sense to me.

"You are there, you know the equipment, you know what you want to capture, go and do it."

▲KaiserPro a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Hmm unless something has changed, rec.709 is 8bit, so yeah if you're good you can just shoot in rec.709

But if you want to play with the colour, loosing 4bits of colour precision means you aint recovering whats in the blacks. (log supposedly allows better detail recovery in blacks, but that was for film, I don't know about digital anymore)

▲ikatson a day ago | parent | next [-]

Disclaimer: I'm not a video pro, have nothing to do with that industry.

"rec.709 is 8bit" sounded wrong, so a quick check suggests it's either 8 or 10 bit [1], where 10 bit formats may be used during production, and 8 bits for delivery [source: gemini].

[1] https://glenwing.github.io/docs/ITU-R-BT.709-6.pdf - page 5, quantization levels

▲KaiserPro 21 hours ago | parent [-]

Ahhh this must have changed after I left the VFX buisness.

▲jpc0 an hour ago | parent [-]

Yeah Rec709 is usually 8bit you are not wrong. You can shoot log in 10 or 12 bit.

I mean there might be some inter formats that can use a Rec709 colour space with a 10bit quantisation but it is certainly not popular as a recording format

▲tosti 38 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

This is addressed in TFA.

▲rickdeckard a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> "And you can convert log footage to REC709 in a way that would give you the same result as if you'd just recorded in REC709 to begin with"

I think beside of this extra-step in post (which comes with its own set of parameters again), that's part of his point:

The videographer didn't expose for a specific look in a scene, he didn't decide at all and postponed to post-production. This is not adding value, it's creating work.

"Many times a videographer will shoot log incorrectly – generally underexposed – expecting to ‘fix it in post’. The same issues apply to shooting in camera raw or HDR."

▲ryandamm a day ago | parent | prev [-]

I think what the author is trying to say is that directors of photography don’t know how to expose an image properly when they are targeting Rec709 output but shooting and monitoring in a different color space.

But this is a nontechnical article for a nontechnical audience.